Jason Voorhees: He gave you a homemade bracelet.

Freddy Krueger: He gave you a heart... Wtf...

Michael Myers: He found a baby and gave it to you. You loved him and named him Damion.

Hannibal Lector: He got you a book you wanted.

Leatherface: He got you a batch of wild flowers.

Norman Bates: He got you a necklace. You loved it.

Ghostface: He got you a new knife that had writing on it saying that he will always love you.

Pinhead: He got you a whip to use on yourself and victims.