okay, so

i have compiled the orders of the Batfam and Bigtop Band based on when they joined 

Char correct me if I fucked anything up w/ your ocs

BATFAM

Dick (Nightwing)

Jason (Red Hood)

Harmonia (Harms-Way)

Missy & Kody (Chastity & Chameleon)

Lottie (Tanzanite)

Sammy (Nighthawk)

Tim (Red Robin)

Steph (Spoiler)

Jade (Dreadmist)

Damian (Robin)

Cass (Orphan)

Duke (Signal)

BIGTOP BAND

Joselyn (Birdcage)

Lucille (Sealed-Deal)

Kylie (Chaosheart)

Marlene 

Athena (Blue Jay)

Caden

Lulu (Nightmare Haze)

Apollo (Sunny)

Duchess

Damaris (Nightshade)

Rickie

Calliope