PHILLIP'S QUARTERS

"So you hid Colette's body in the attic so that she wouldn't steal Bunny's thunder?" Elena Says

"I couldn't stand the thought of overshadowing Mrs. LaCroix's funeral with another death. She deserved a proper farewell. I owed it to her." Phillip Says

"Well that's just crazy." Dean Says

"No, Mr. Winchester and Ms.Singer, that's loyalty." Phillip Says

Dean receives a text from Sam: "Just found Phillip. Dead." Dean turns toward Phillip and he throws him across the room. Elena picks up the wrench and hits Phillip across the face with it, He punches Elena in the face and throws her across the room and leaves. As Dean and Elena gets back up, they see the pile of clothes and skin by the door. He dials his cell phone

"Dean." Sam Says

"Sam." Dean Says

"Yeah?" Sam Says

"It's no ghost." Dean Says

"What?" Sam Says

"It's a shapeshifter." Dean hangs up

__________________________________

KITCHEN

Sam, Elena and Dean are standing near Phillip's body past the kitchen.

"So the shifter's getting its jollies by impersonating dead people." Sam Says

"Yeah. First Bunny, then Lance, now Phillip. Guess we can rule out "the butler did it." Dean Says

Sam, Elena and Dean re-enter the kitchen

"And the creep just shed so now it could be anybody. Even you two." Elena Says

"Or you. We need to find some silver." Dean Says

Olivia enters the kitchen and sees Phillips dead body. "Oh my God!"

"Hey. He was like that when we found him." Dean Says

"Who did this?" Olivia Asks

"We don't know yet, okay? Now, listen. Calm down. I know you think he was working with ghosts but there's something way worse going on here." Sam Says

"Worse than...What is going on?" Olivia Says

"If you want to help, then help. Can you do that?" Dean Says

"Olivia Do you happen to know where Bunny's silverware is?" Elena Asks

Olivia nods and goes to grab a box, she returns with it and opens a silverware case.

"Why do you need the silverware?" Olivia Asks

"For protection." Sam Says

"Butter knives?" Olivia Says

"Trust us. There's a method to our madness." Dean Says

Sam hands silver knife to Olivia "Can you – uh – hold this?" Olivia holds the knife and nothing happens

"Okay." Olivia Says

Sam picks up another silver knife and hands to Dean and Elena.

"Dean, Elena." Dean and Elena holds the knife, nothing happens "All right." He picks up another knife "Let's do this." Sam Says

LOUNGE

Beverly and Heddy are sitting on a couch in the Lounge scrolling through men's pictures in a dating app on an iPad.

"No – No – No – No! Ugh!" Beverly Says

"Wait, wait, wait. Go back. He owned an island." Heddy Says

"And a harelip." Beverly Says

"Who cares if he's ugly if you're drinking Mai Tai's in the lap of luxury?" Heddy Says As Sam clears bus throat

"Hey. Hey, ladies." Sam Says

"Hi." Heddy Says

"What are you doing?" Sam Asks

"Trying to find Beverly a man." Heddy Says

"I've resorted to fishing online because the live ones won't bite." Beverly Says

"You mean back there? I - I was just playing hard to get." Sam Says

"Well, then...you're a very convincing actor." She motions for Sam to sit on the couch "Come." Beverly Says

"Sure. Alright." Sam walks over to the couch

Beverly Beverly pushes Heddy over "Sit here. Yes" Sam sits between them

"Ah. Oh. Mmm." Sam Says

Sam has a silver butter knife under his shirt cuff to the underside of his right hand. He puts his hand on Beverly's bare leg.

"Boo. I'm feeling so left out." Heddy Says

"Well then, uh, come on in darling. Water's warm." Sam Says

Sam has a silver butter knife under his shirt cuff to the underside of his left hand. He puts his arm around Heddy with his hand on her bare shoulder.

"Oh. Oh yes." Beverly Says

BILLIARD ROOM

Dean and Elena enters the Billiard room, they are about to exit and hears something in the closet. Dean sees a silver candlestick and picks it up. Elena opens the closet doors to find Amber and Dash kissing.

"Really?" Dean Says

"Gods it's like we're living in an episode of Days of our lives." Elena Says

"We can explain." Amber Says

"Let me guess. You two got bored last Christmas." Dean Says

"New Canaan clambake, actually. We were in line at the buffet, they ran out of steamers. One thing led to another, and, well..." Dash Says

"But we didn't kill Stanton." Amber Says

"We may be guilty of cheating but not murder." Dash Says

Dean pulls two silver butterknives out of his pocket. "Touch these."

"What? Why?" Amber Asks

"Do it or I go cards up on your whole clambake."
Dean Says Then Dash and Amber touch the knives

"Did... we pass?" Amber Asks

"Yep. Don't worry, your secret is safe with us." Elena Says

"Come on you two." Dean Says

LOUNGE

Sam is still sitting between Beverly and Heddy on the couch. Beverly is touching his hair and Heddy is touching his fingers. Dean, Elena, Amber and Dash renters the lounge.

"Did you see how long his fingers his fingers were?" Beverly Asks

"There...there's just." Sam Says

"First of all, did you see this? Look how long..." Heddy Says

"Should we come back when you're done?" Dean Asks

"Oh, he's – he's – he's calling to me, so..."Sam gets up from the couch

"And it's all going to hell, right here, right now." Dean Says

"Sorry to interrupt." Elena Smiles

"Pfft. Gray Gardens cleared." Sam Says

"Okay, well so is Dash and Amber. They're a thing, by the way." Dean Says

"Y—" Sam Says

"Yeah, W.A.S.P.S." Dean Says

"Well, so that's everyone. Except for..." Elena Says

Olivia screams and everyone startles, Sam, Elena and Dean reach Olivia down the hall. She's pointing in a bathroom. Sam, Elena and Dean enter the bathroom. Detective Howard is dead with his head in the toilet. Everyone else is in the doorway.

"The Detective." Elena Says

"Well, we got a floater." Dean Says

"Great." Sam Says As Everyone else comes in the bathroom

"Yeah, he's a goner." Dean Says

"Drowned in a toilet? How filthy." Heddy Says

"What kind of monster would do such a thing?"Heddy and Beverly turn to Olivia

"Don't look at me. I was just trying to pee." Olivia Says

"Okay, hold on. Before we start pointing fingers..." Dean Says

"Amber has motive. She killed the detective because she knew that it was just a matter of time before he figured out she killed Stan." Heddy Says

"Bravo Rizzoli! You solved the case. Want to weigh in too, Isles?" Dash Says

"I didn't kill Stanton or the detective. And I have proof." Amber Says

"Okay, guys..." Sam Says

"My alibi is in this room." Amber Says

"Ooh, wait for it." Dean Says

"Amber couldn't have killed the detective cause she was with me. We're in love." Dash Says

"We're sleeping together." Amber Says

"I knew it." Beverly Says

"Well then you have motive too. You offed Stan because you were diddling his wife." Heddy Says

"Oh. The old lady doth protest too much. You're only pointing the finger to distract from your own guilt. And you probably got Baby Jane to help." Dash Says

"Well I never! I'm leaving." Beverly Says

"All right, hang on. First of all, who talks like that? Second of all, no one's leaving, okay?" Dean Says

"Ohh, get your hands off me young man." Beverly Says leaning towards Dean, he pushes her away

"Okay, see - I don't trust anyone. And leaving just makes you look guilty." Dean Says

"Ohhh." Beverly Says

"Dean is right, okay. We have four corpses now." Elena Says

"Four corpses?!" Amber Says

"Yes. You can add Phillip and Colette to the list." Dean Says

"Clown college Colette? But I thought she..." Heddy Says

"She's dead! Alright, she's dead." Dean Says

lAnd we can't help you unless you stop arguing with one another. You need to trust us." Sam Says

"Trust you? Uh, we don't even know you. Look Buddy, I'm trying to be objective here, but we've had countless family functions before, and even though we wanted to kill one another, we never did." Dash Says

"Dash is right. Our get-togethers never end in murder. The only thing different this time around is you." Heddy Says

"Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. First of all, whoa. Whatever you're suggesting..." Dean Says

Dash grabs detective's gun and points it at them.

"You three! Let's go. Don't even think about it. I....hunt pheasant." He holds the gun on Sam, Elena and Dean and puts them in a room. "Sit tight until the cops get here." Dash Says

"Listen here Eric Brady, You don't want to do this." Elena Says

"She's right We are your best shot at making it out of here alive." Dean Says

"We're not the bad guys, Dash." Sam Says

"I beg to differ. You're wearing flannel."Dash shuts and locks the door

"Hey!" Dean Says

Dean tries to open the door, He takes a silver butter knife and tries to force the door open. Sam and Elena is rifling through drawers and finds keys.

"Hey. Keys." Sam Says

"No, it's locked from the outside." Dean Says

"Are you kidding me? Great." Sam Says

Dean stops trying to force the door open with the silver butter knife and sees the knife is bent "Made in Taiwan. Freaking stainless steel."

"So that's why no one sizzled? They're not even real silver?" Sam Says

"First cubic zirconium and now this. No wonder the rich stay rich. How we gonna kill this thing?" Dean Says

"You know, we got silver bullets in the trunk." Elena Says

"Yeah, assuming we ever make it out of here." Dean Says

_________________________________

LOUNGE

"I don't get it. Why would Sam, Elena and Dean want us dead?" Amber Says

"Isn't it obvious?" He's waving the gun around "They wanted our inheritance. Guess whatever Aunt Bunny left them wasn't good enough." Dash Says

"For the love of God Dash, put down the gun before you kill someone!" Heddy Says

"It's okay. I....Hunt....Pheasant!" Dash Says

"Put it down!" Amber Says

Dash puts the gun down on the coffee table.

"I knew those three were trailer trash the moment they rolled up in that American-made." Heddy Says

"Not to mention homosexuals." Beverly Says

"Ugh. Homosexual murderers. Like Leopold and Loeb." Heddy Says

"Only hotter." Beverly Says

Olivia enters the room carrying whiskey in a glass bottle on a tray.

"Oh. Call the police at once." Heddy Says

"Oh, I don't think so." Olivia Says

"Excuse me, young lady? Killer or no killer, you're still on the clock." Heddy Says

"You idiots couldn't be more wrong...about everything. Don't you know, if it's not the butler, it's the maid?" Olivia picks up the gun and points it at them

CLOSET

In the locked room, Elena sees Olivia with the gun on the Security feed.

"Sam, Dean. You gotta see this." Elena Says

"We got played by the maid." He throws himself against the door "Both doors are reinforced."

LOUNGE

"I'm not the maid." Olivia Says

"Well, that explains the dust." Heddy Says

"I'm Bunny's daughter." Olivia Says

"What are you talking about? Bunny didn't have a child." Beverly Says

"Oh, yes she did – a very devoted one. I loved mother more than anything, which is more than I can say for any of you." Olivia Says

"Then where have you been hiding all these years?" Dash Asks

"The attic." Olivia Says

"Like in the movie." Amber Says

"Oh, Amber." Heddy Says

Sam opens a cabinet while Dean and Elena watches the surveillance video.

"Outside of mother, Phillip was the only one at the manor who knew. So after she died, he took pity on me, and he let me out. He told me to pose as the new maid so I can hide in plain sight." Olivia Says

"That's why you killed Colette – for her job?" Amber Says

"Oh no, no, no, no. Colette was just an accident. I just wanted to scare her because I caught her stealing." Olivia Says

"Well that doesn't explain wanting us dead. None of us are thieves." Heddy Says

"Oh, no. You're worse. Your greed. Your disdain. Your blatant disrespect for mother. Oh. You all had it coming!" Olivia Says

"But, why kill Phillip? I mean, if he was on your side..." Dash Says

"Because he turned on me. After Stanton, he locked me back up. Lucky for me, the cute, dumb one let me out." Olivia Says

In the locked room, Sam opens a cabinet.

"Ha! Gunsafe." Sam Says

"Hey." tosses keys to Sam "Try these." Elena Says

"No wonder you were locked away. You're a monster!" Heddy Says

"Oh, you have no idea." Olivia Says

Sam opens the gunsafe and takes out a gun, He's pointing it at the locked door. In the Lounge, they hear the gun blast.

"What in God's name." Dash Says

"Shut up!" Olivia Says

She's aiming her gun at the entrance to the Lounge. As Sam enters, she shoots at him and runs out a different door as the rest of the family cowers.

"Stay here." He exits the same door that Olivia used

"Did anyone else wet themselves?" Heddy Says

KITCHEN

Sam enters the kitchen and Olivia fires shots at him. He ducks down behind the kitchen island.

"You don't have a clear shot." Olivia Says

"Neither do you." Sam Says

"Killing you is the next best thing to killing Bobby Singer..even better I'll kill his daughter and your brother." Olivia Says

"What's your beef with Bobby?" Sam Asks

"For starters, he killed my father." Olivia Says

"Lance was a shifter?" Sam Says

"Lance wasn't my father. Mother had an affair with a shifter. She got pregnant, told Lance I was his. He bought it....until she brought me back from the hospital. My real dad was waiting. Lance put up a fight, but he was no match for a shifter. And just as my dad was about to take me....the hunter became the hunted." Olivia Says

"Bobby." Sam Says

"After Bobby killed my father, he came after me. Mother pleaded with him to spare me. He agreed, under one condition." Olivia Says

"That she keep you locked up." Sam Says

"For my safety, and the safety of others. Mother told the family she lost the baby. And she locked me in the attic. But she remained devoted to me until the very end – Even got Bobby to promise to take care of me if anything happened to her." Olivia Says

"Wait a minute. Then, Bobby spared you. You should be grateful." Sam Says

"For what? Keeping me locked up my whole life? It would have been kinder to kill me." Olivia Says

"Olivia...you don't have to do this. Being a monster is a choice." Sam Says

"That choice was made for me a long time ago. Why haven't you taken a shot? Oh, you don't have any silver bullets, do you?" Olivia Says

Olivia is now pointing the gun directly at Sam. She's shot from behind by Dean and Elena After she drops, Dean shoots her seven more times. Later Sam, Elena and Dean, and the family are walking out the front door. Dash is talking on his cell phone.

"Yes, officer. Yes, thank you very much. Yes, no you can't miss it. Big house on the end of the street. Alright, bye now." He heads to Sam, Elena and Dean "Guys? Police are on the way. What a mess. I owe you three an apology." Dash Says

"Don't sweat it. I mean, you were just protecting your family and...there's nothing wrong with that." Sam Says

"So I spoke to Aunt Bunny's attorney. He said outside from the pendant, everything was left to Olivia." Dash Says

"Hey, you know what? Speaking of that...you guys should keep it." He hands the pendant to Dash. "It's a key to the attic." Dean Says

"Bobby must have really meant something to Aunt Bunny. How can we repay you?" Dash Says

"You know what? Just forget we were ever here." Elena Says

"But you saved our lives. I want everyone to know what heroes you..." Dash Says

"Look pal, the fact that we pulled your bacon out of the fire is nobody's business. Okay? Hey. I'm serious Izod. Put a pin in it. Or we'll come back for your preppy ass." Dean Says

ROAD

Sam, Elena and Dean drive off the estate in the Impala.

"Dean, what was that all about back there?" Sam Asks

"What are you talking about?" Dean Says

"I mean....all those extra shots after the shifter was already dead." Sam Says

"Yeah What was that?" Elena Asks

"I don't know. Target practice?" Dean Says

"Come on, man. I'm serious. You sure it wasn't....I don't know, demon residue or something to do with the mark, or..." Sam Says

"No. No, none of that." Dean Says

"Right. Look man, I got to be honest..." Sam Says

"Oh my God, Sam. It was my first kill since I've been back. You know, I got a little anxious. I wanted to make sure it was done right – plain and simple. Its... Why am I even explaining this to you?" Dean blasts the stereo

"Dean, I..." Sam stops talking, shakes his head, and looks out the window