PENDLETON, OREGON

BAR

A man is getting pushed out of the bar by the Bartender and they continue to argue.

"It wasn't me, man! I didn't take it!" He Says

The Bartender forcibly pushes him "You keep on coming and stealing from me! Huh? Where's my money?"

"It was that—" He Says

"Where's my money? Where's my money?! You give me my money!"

The Bartender pushes him out the back the door, The Man falls on the pavement.

"Swear on my mother, J.P., I see your face in here again...I'll kill you."

A homeless man by the dumpster over looks the whole fight.

"Like Hell. This is freakin' America, man. You can't just—" The Bartender walks back into the bar and closes the door, He glares at the homeless man
"What you looking at?!" J.P Says

J.P walks to his car and is jumped from behind by a large man with a scar on his face. The man grabs the hex bag that is hanging from his neck, causing a beam of light to illuminate the parking lot. J.P. screams. The homeless man runs over to the noise and encounters a pile of clothes where J.P. used to stand and looks up at the sky.

_________________________________

BUNKER

Dean is in the Men of Letters Bunker researching on how to extract the Mark of Cain from his arm. James Gang's, "Ashes, The Rain And I" play in the background during the montage.]

"After Cain killed Abel, He became a demon."

"I felt connected to you right from the beginning. You and I are very much alike. I can give you the mark, Dean, if it's what you truly want."

"But when I kill, I kill for a reason. I'm nothing like Cain."

"Why are you fighting what you really are?"

Dean is in the library on the computer on a website titled "Scar removal".

DEANS BEDROOM

Dean is on the floor of his room leaning against his bed and is reading a large book with ancient inscriptions written in it, Sam enters his room.

"Hey." Sam Says

"Hey." Dean Says

"Caught a case." He hands over a tablet "Apparently something is taking people and leaving their clothes." Sam Says

Dean takes the tablet. The screen is on a News site with the title "Mysterious Disappearances Baffle Police" He enlarges the picture of J.P. on the tablet.

"Hmm. About time this gig got an "R" rating." Dean Says As Sam scoffs

"All right why don't you and Lena check it out? I'll hold down the fort." Dean Says

"Dean, you haven't left the bunker in a week."
Sam Says As Dean tosses the tablet behind him on the bed

"And?" Dean Says

"And you can't just live the rest of your life locked up in this room." Sam Says

"I don't know. I got three hots and a cot. Could be worse." Dean Says

"Look, I know you're worried about the mark." Sam Says

"Yes, Sam. I am. Between what I did to Charlie—" Dean Says

"Charlie forgave you. How about you forgive yourself?" Sam Says

"Because I'm not exactly batting 1,000 here, you know?" Dean Says

"Yeah, I do know that, but staying locked up in here, sitting on the ground reading the same lore books over and over and over again, it's not helping you. You need to get back in the game for your own good. You can beat this, Dean." Sam Says

"Do you really believe that?" Dean Asks

"Yeah, you're damn right I believe that." Sam Says

"You know, you also believed in the Easter bunny till you were 12." Dean Says

"No I didn't...Look, I was 11." Sam Says

"And a half." Dean Says

"And a half. Right..So?" Sam Says

Dean sighs then closes the book "Okay."

BAR

Sam, Elena and Dean are outside of the bar in their Fed suits talking to the homeless man.

"And then—then—then there was this bright light, and—bam—the dude's just gone. Nothing left but, uh..." He Says

"Cheap suit and a pair of florsheims?" Dean Says

"Pretty much." He Says As Dean nods

"You see anyone else?" Elena Asks

"No, ma'am , officer." He Says

"And what about, uh, a chill? Or did you smell any rotten eggs?" Dean Asks

"What? No, man. Uh... I smelled flowers, though." He Says

"You smelled flowers? What kind of flowers?" Sam Asks

"Flowerly Flowers." He Says

"Flowerly Flowers." Sam Says

"Look. We all know what's..going on here, okay?" He Says

Dean closes his eyes "Don't say it."

"Aliens." He Says

"He said it." Dean Says

"Yeah he did." Elena Says

"Dude was abducted. Believe me, I know." He looks up at the sky "May 2003. Those suckers, they grabbed me, and they probed me everywhere." He Says

"Okay." Sam Says

"Thank you sir." Elena Says

Sam, Elena and Dean get disgusted looks on their face and begin to walk away from the man.

"Thanks for your time." Sam Says

"I'm talking everywhere." He Says

Sam Gives him a thumbs up "Yup." He Clears his throat "Okay. Okay."

"Well, the wheels just came flying off the bus." Dean Says

"Yeah. No cold spots means it probably wasn't a ghost." Sam Says

"No sulfur means no demons, so that leaves us with what?" Elena Says

"Couple of little green dudes and a bucket of lube?" Dean Says

"Or fairies. Or...angels." Sam Says As They stop walking in front of the bar

"Ugh. I'd rather have the little green dudes." Dean Says

"All right, Elena and I will go scope out J.P.'s place. You, uh—you ask around inside." Sam Says

Dean gets a very concerned look on his face, Sam and Elena notices.

"Or you know what? We don't have to split up." Elena Says

"No, no, no. It's cool. I can handle a little 20 questions with the locals, okay?" Dean Says

"You sure?" Sam Says

"Yeah, hey, look, it's a dive bar. It's my comfort zone, hmm." Dean dangles the Impala's car keys in front of them

"All right." He grabs the keys "Good. Great." Sam Says

"Call us if something comes up." Elena Says

"Will do." Dean Says As Elena smiles at him

Sam and Elena walks past Dean, She pats him on the shoulder. He and Elena then proceeds to get in the car. Dean walks into the bar looking a little nervous. Headwater's "Only A Matter Of Time" plays in the background. Dean walks up to the bar and takes a seat, the bartender looks at him.

"What can I do you?" He Asks

"Screw it. I'm gonna believe in myself." Dean Says

"Attaboy." He Says

"Give me something dark and strong. Hey, did you know that guy that went missing – J.P.?" Dean Asks

The Bartender pulls out a shot glass and begins to fill it with whiskey. Meanwhile, a woman at the bar overhears Dean's conversation.

"Who's asking?" He Says

"Just an old pal." Dean Says

"Look, I'm sorry to hear about what happened. But... guy's a lowlife. That night, I had to kick his ass out of here for stealing my tips. Whatever J.P. got... probably had it coming." He Says

"Ouch." Dean holds the drink and hesitantly throws it back

Dean's heart is pounding as he touches his arm where the Mark of Cain lies.

"J.P. wasn't that bad." She Says

"You knew him?" Dean Asks

"This isn't exactly "Cheers," but yeah." Dean walks over to the woman "And don't get me wrong, I would not buy a used car from the guy." She Chuckles "But he was harmless." She Says

"So, what was his problem?" Dean Asks

"What wasn't? You're in here getting stunned while the sun's still up, your life's a regular Charlie Foxtrot. Trust me." She Says

A man sitting at the tables in the bar listens in on their conversation.

"I'm Dean."

"Tina."

Dean signals the Bartender down for two more drinks. Later He and Tina have moved from the bar to a table. They've been there for a while, drinking, for there are various empty glasses on the table. A waitress drops off two more shots.

"There you go."

"How do you know the Royale Motel in Scranton?" Tina Asks

"My Dad, me and my bro – we got snowed in there for a week." Dean Says

"Well, I was there for about three months after my father drank all our money away. Lived on white rice and Tic Tacs until they kicked us out. Good times." Tina Says As Dean chuckles

"My Dad was always working, so I came up with about 101 different ways to make macaroni and cheese." Dean Says

"Serious?" Tina Says

"Oh, yeah. Now, add ketchup for spice, hmm? Uh, tuna, hot dogs, fluff marshmallow mix." Dean Says

"Ugh! That sounds disgusting." Tina Says

"Yeah, well, my brother thought it was exotic." Dean Says As Tina laughs

Tina holds up her shot glass "Well, here's to, uh, crappy childhoods." Dean holds his up as well and they clink glasses

"Hey. All right." He clears his throat "Oh..Oh. Sorry." Dean Says As he fishes for his phone in his suit jacket

"I should go." Tina Says

Dean pulls out his phone and Sam is calling him.
"Uh..."

Tina gets up from the table and grabs her jacket.
"Before you fall hopelessly in love with me."

"You gonna be okay?" Dean Asks

"I always am." Tina leaves, Dean answers

"How we looking?" Dean Asks

J.P.'s APARTMENT

Sam and Elena are walking down the steps of an apartment.

"Not great. Turns out J.P. was about three days from getting evicted. His landlord said the guy blasted Neil Diamond 24/7." Sam Says

Tina is giving the Bartender a hug goodbye, Dean eyes them suspiciously.

"And that his bathroom was, "Like staring into the Devil's butt." Elena Says

"That's vivid." Dean Says

"And accurate we saw it." Sam Says

"You guys saw the John, or, uh—" Dean Says

"Don't." Elena Says As Dean smiles, amused at his joke

"So, you got anything?" Sam Asks

"Yeah. I got, uh, jack with two scoops of squat." Tina leaves the bar "I don't know, man. I think we ought to just call it a night and, uh—" Dean sees a large mysterious man walk out of the bar right after Tina

"And what? Dean? Hello?" Sam Says

"Sammy, I think I got something." Dean hangs up the phone

BAR

Dean follows the same path Tina and the mysterious man went.

"Tina?" Dean Says

Tina screams off screen and the same white light appears. Dean pulls out his pistol and rushes over to a smoking pile of clothes by the dumpster. As he examines it, the mysterious man comes up behind him. Feeling someone else's presence, Dean turns around. The man then grabs the hex bag hanging around his neck and a white flash appears.

_______________________________

WITCH'S BASEMENT

Dean opens his eyes and looks around the room. There are bars on the windows. He's changed clothes as well. He's now wearing an oversized yellow hoodie.

"What the hell?" Dean Says

He tries to open the door, but it is locked from the inside. He then pulls on the bared windows but they don't budge. He notices his hands look different and quickly turns to a dusty mirror. After wiping the dust off with his shirt it's revealed that Dean has reverted into his 14 years old self.

"Son of a bitch." He is looking at himself in the mirror "Seriously?" He checks out his new clothes.
"Seriously?!" Dean Says As Tina clears her throat off screen

"Hey." Tina Says

She too has reverted into a younger version of herself. She's in the cell next to Dean but is separated by a broken wall.

"What's your name?" Tina Asks

"Dean." He Says

"Dean? It's me – Tina." She Says

"What?" Dean Says

"Please tell me you know what the hell is going on." Tina Says

"Honestly, I'm not sure yet." Dean Says

"Because I left the bar and then there was this..." Tina Says

"A light? A bright light?" Dean Says

"Yes, and then I was here, and I thought this was a nightmare, but... Oh, God, if you're here...It can't be real. This doesn't –" Tina Says

"I know. Just try to stay calm, okay?" Dean Says

"Stay calm? I'm a freakin' tween, and you look like some One Direction reject. And we're in some freaky serial-killer basement. I can't—" Tina Says

"Tina, Tina, just—I'm not gonna let anything happen to you, okay? Well, anything else happen to you." Dean Says

"This is crazy. How are you so calm?" Tina Asks

"Practice. Who's your friend?" Dean Says

"I'm not sure." Tina Says

A black haired kid in Tina's cell is sitting on the cot, staring at the ground with his arms crossed.

"He doesn't talk." Tina Says

"J.P.?" Dean Says

The kid slowly looks up. Dean smiles and nods, realizing that was the man they were searching for. The basement door creaks open and the mysterious man from before comes down the stairs leading to their cells. The man opens J.P. and Tina's cell. J.P. begins to scream.

"Ahh! No!" J.P Says As The man grabs him from the bed

"Hey. Hey!" Dean Says

Dean begins tearing into the broken wood that separated Tina from Dean.

"Don't!" Tina Says

Tina grabs the man taking J.P. away but he merely swats her away, causing her to fall on the floor and continues to walk out carrying J.P.

"This is freakin' America, man! You can't do this!" The cell door slams "No!" J.P Cried

BAR

Sam and Elena walks into the bar, she pulls out her phone and calls Dean.

"Anything?" Sam Asks

"No it's just ringing." Elena Says

In Dean's cell, a covered food tray is slid under the door.

"What is it?" Tina Asks

Dean hesitantly takes off the cover to reveal a rather large slice of cake. Elena is still trying to call Dean, She and Sam then hears Dean's phone ringing behind the counter at the bar. The Bartender goes into Dean's jacket and silences the phone.

"Sam." Elena Nudges his shoulder

"Hey, buddy? Where did that jacket come from?" Sam Asks

The Bartender chuckles silently "My Bar Mitzvah."
He comes around in front of the counter. "It was a magical night."

"Yeah, I bet." Sam smashes the Bartenders head on the counter "Why don't you try that again?"

"Dumpster. Found it by the dumpster." He Says

"All right." Sam Says

"Thank you for cooperating." Elena Says As Sam lets go of the Bartender

WITCH'S BASEMENT

Dean is eating the cake with his hands, enjoying every bite.

"Mmm." Dean Says

Tina stares at her piece of cake "They probably poisoned it." Dean stops eating

"Right." He sucks the remaining frosting off his finger "Obviously." Dean puts his cake to the side

"What do you think they're doing to J.P.?" Tina Asks

Dean Sighs and hits the wall "Nothing good."

Dean feels around on the walls looking for a weak spot, or someway of getting out there. He then begins to pull fiercely on the bars from the bed. He starts kicking it, Tina watches him.

"What are you doing?" Tina Asks

He kicks off one of the bars from the bed and picks it up.

"Getting us out of here." Dean Says

He pulls the bed in front of the window as leverage. After getting on top of the bed he begins to hack away at the cement holding the bars in the window in place.

"You know, before...I thought you were just another drunk." Tina Says

Dean stops hacking to look at her "I prefer functional alcoholic." He goes back to work

"Seriously, who – What are you?" Tina Asks

Dean stops and sighs, He looks at her again."That... is a long-ass story." And once again he goes back to chisel away the cement

BAR

Sam and Elena is walking around where Dean disappeared with a flashlight. Under the dumpster where Dean was seen last, Elena and Sam sees Dean's shoe and pistol. On the pistol Sam dusts off a yellow dust off the handle. He sniffs it.

"What does it smell like?" Elena Asks

"Like Flowers." Sam Says

WITCH'S BASEMENT

Dean continues to hack away at the window, He finally pulls one of the bars free.

"Yahtzee." Dean Says

Dean and Tina hear a door creak in the distance. The mysterious man is starting to come down the basement stairs, Tina turns to Dean.

"Get out." Tina Says

"What?" Dean Says

The man is walking down the hallway, he's approaching closely.

"Hurry. I'll keep him busy." Tina Says

Dean jumps down from the window and over to Tina.

"Screw that. You're coming with me." Dean Says

"There's no time. Go. Get help." Tina Says

"Tina—" Dean Says

"I know you will." Tina Says

The man begins to unlock Dean's cell door, They're running out of time. Tina starts screaming at the top of her lungs. The man gets distracted by her screaming and stops unlocking Dean's door.

"HELP ME! HELP ME PLEASE! I NEED A DOCTOR! I NEED A DOCTOR NOW!" Tina Shouts

While Tina's is screaming, Dean uses the opportunity to exit out of the window. The man enters Tina's cell.

"What are you screaming about, girl?" Hansel Asks As Tina whimpers

_______________________________

MOTEL ROOM

Sam is on his laptop researching Yarrow and Transfiguration Spells, Elena looks over his shoulders looking at the screen. When they hear a knock on the door. Suspicious of who could be at the door, he grabs his gun and cocks it back. After a moment he opens the door to a young Dean, now wearing a red hat but they don't recognize him right away.

"Yeah?" Sam Says

"You lost kid?" Elena Says

"Hiya, Sammy." Dean Says

Sam lowers the gun realizing it's his brother, He stares at him shocked.

"Dean?" Sam Says