MOTEL

Dean, Elena and Corrina are sharpening wooden stakes, while Sam uses the laptop. Five other wooden stakes are on the bed and floor near Dean.

"I knew it! Something was way off with those two." Sam Says

"What'd you find?" Dean Asks

"The Carrigans lived in Seattle, last year, where two abductions took place right around Christmas. They moved here in January. All that Christmas crap in their house – that wasn't boughs of holly. It was vervain and mint." Sam Says

"Pagan stuff?" Elena Says

"Serious pagan stuff." Sam Says

"So what, Ozzie and Harriet are keeping a pagan god hidden underneath their plastic-covered couch?" Dean Says

"I don't know. All I know is we gotta check them out. So, what about Bobby? He's sure evergreen stakes will kill this thing, right?" Sam Says as Dean Looks at the Stakes

"Yeah, he's sure." Dean Says

____________________________________

CARRIGAN HOUSE

They All walk toward the house. Christmas music is playing ("O Come All Ye Faithful") Dean picks the lock.

Sam, Elena, Corrina and Dean each hold a wooden stake.

"See? Plastic." Dean Say As Sam touches it too as Dean his head disapprovingly.

Dean and Elena goes into the living room and looks at all the Christmas decor, while Sam and Corrina goes to the hall, which is also decorated with ornaments and snow globes. Sam and Corrina goes into the kitchen and sees plates of cookies and cakes. Sam shines his flashlight on the lock of a door, Corrina Takes Cookie and puts it in her pocket Sam Looks at her

"What?" Corrina Says

"Nothing, Hey Dean." Sam Says

They All walk downstairs to the basement. Dean points his flashlight and finds bones covered with blood in a large bowl. They check the room and realize the whole basement looks like a butchery room rather than a storage room. Elena finds a leather bag covered with blood. She looks disgusted and moves to another spot. She pokes a bag that is hanging from the wall and the bag moves – someone inside is struggling. Madge grabs Elena's neck from behind and lifts her off the ground as she yells in surprise.

Dean, Sam and Corrina hears her and comes running.

"Elena!" Dean Says

Madge pushes Elena against a wall and holds her by the throat. Dean runs to him and tries to stake Madge, but Mr.Carrigan grabs his arm and knocks his head against a wall. Dean falls to the ground, unconscious. Madge Lets go of Elena, She and Mr,Carrigan Goes After Sam and Corrina, Mr.Carrigan Grabs Sam's Head and Slams his head against the wall, Corrina Tries to Stake Madge but she overpowers her and Headbutts Corrina, then Throws Corrina Against the wall she hits her head hard and goes unconscious, Madge grabs Elena By the throat again and looks at her husband, who smiles and nods and looks back at Elena, who is struggling to breathe

"Gosh, I wish you boys and girls hadn't come down here." Madge Says As Elena moves her flashlight to the Carrigan's faces, which appear monster-like when in the beam of the flashlight but turn back to normal out of the light. Madge slams Elena head hard against the wall and lets her drop to the ground.

___________________________________

The Christmas decorations on the lawn are lit up with lights and Christmas music plays.

CARRIGAN HOUSE

A number of bowls and a knife are set out on the kitchen table. Sam, Dean, Elena and Corrina are tied up in chairs, Sam Back To Back With Dean, Elena back to back with Corrina

"Guys, You okay?" Sam Asks

"Yeah, I think so." Dean says

"Super" Elena Says

"When I say I liked to be tied up, this isn't what I meant" Corrina Says

S"So, I guess we're dealing with Mr. and Mrs. God. They All nods, Nice to know." Sam Says

"Yeah." Dean Says As The Carrigans come into the kitchen, dressed in colorful Christmas- themed sweaters.

"Ooh, and here we thought you four lazybones were gonna sleep straight through all the fun stuff" Madge Says The She Giggles

"Miss all this? Nah, we're partiers." Dean Says

"Isn't he a kick in the pants, honey? You're hunters, is what you are." Mr, Carrigan Says

"And you're pagan gods. So, why don't we just call it even, and go our separate ways?" Dean Says

"What, so you can bring more hunters and kill us? He Laughs, I don't think so." Mr,Carrigan Says

"Maybe you should have thought about that before you went snacking on humans, now, huh?" Sam Says

"Oh now, don't get all wet." Mr, Carrigan Says

"Oh, why, we used to take over a hundred tributes a year and that's a fact. She Puts a napkin on Dean's lap. Now what do we take? What, two? Three?" Madge Says As She Napkins in Sam, Elena and Corrina's Lap

"Hardy Boys, Iola Morton and Nancy Drew here make four." Mr, Carrigan Says

"Now, that's not so bad, is it?" Madge Says

"Well, you say it like that – I guess you guys are the Cunninghams." Dean Says

"You, mister, better show us a little respect." Madge Says

"Or what? You'll eat us?" Elena Asks

"Not so fast, There's rituals to be followed first." Mr. Carrigan Says

"Oh, we're just sticklers for ritual." Madge Says

"And you know what kicks off the whole shebang" Mr, Carrigan Says As Madge smiles

"Let me guess... meadowsweet." Corrina Says

"Oh!" Corrina Says

"Oh shucks, you're all out of wreaths. I guess we'll just have to cancel the sacrifice, huh?" Dean Says

"Oh, don't be such a gloomy Gus. Put wreaths around Dean and Sam's necks, Mr. Carrigan Does if to Elena and Corrina, There. Ohh... Don't they just look darling?" Madge Says

"Good enough to eat. He Smacks his lips, All righty-roo. He whips out a knife with a shhing, Step number two." Mr. Carrigan Says

"Now These Two Are at the top of the list of the craziest couple" Corrina Says

"No Kidding" Elena Says

Mr,Carrigan walks to Sam carrying a knife and a bowl. He holds the bowl under Sam's arm and prepares to cut him with the knife.

"Sammy?! Sammy?!" Dean Says As Mr,Carrigan slices Sam's arm and collects his blood in the bowl.

"D-Don't!" Sam Screams

"Leave him alone, you son of a bitch!" Dean Says

"Hear how they talk to us? Heh heh. To Gods? She takes the knife and bowl, Listen, pal, back in the day, we were worshiped by millions." Madge Says

"Well Times have changed Bitch!" Elena Says

"Tell me about it. All of a sudden, this Jesus character is the hot new thing in town. All of a sudden, our – our altars are being burned down, and we're being hunted down like common monsters." Mr.Carrigan Says

"But did we say a peep? Oh ho ho, no, no, no, we did not. Mr, Carrigan adds something to Sam's blood in the bowl, Two millennium. He picks up a tool, We kept a low profile; we got jobs, a mortgage. Wh-What was that word, dear?" Madge Says

" We assimilated." Mr.Carrigan Says

"Yeah, we assimilated. Why, we play bridge on Tuesday and Fridays. She Holds a large knife, We're just like everybody else." Madge Says

"You're not blending in as smooth as you think, lady." Dean Says

"This might pinch a bit, dear." Madge Says As She comes closer to Dean and slices his arm, Mr, Carrigan Slices Elena Arm and collects her blood

"Ahhh" Elena Screams, He Then Goes to Corrina

"Get Back you creepy son of a bitch" Corrina Says

"I like when they get feisty, they taste better" Mr.Carrigan Says as he slices Corrina's Blood

"Screw You" Corrina's Says, Madge Slices Deans Arm Again

"You bitch!" Dean Screams

"Oh, my goodness me! Somebody owes a nickel to the swear jar. Oh, do you know what I say when I feel like swearing? Dean looks Madge in the eyes, as she gestures with her sharp knife in cheesy emphasis"Fudge." Madge Says

"I'll try and remember that!" Dean Says As Mr,Carrigan Picks up some pliers

"You boys and Girls have no idea how lucky you are. There was a time when kids came from miles around, just to be sitting where you are." Mr. Carrigan Says As He stands in front of Sam with the tool

"What do you think you're doing with those?" Sam Asks as Mr.Carrigan smiles.

"You fudging touch me again and I'll fudging kill you!" Dean Says

"Very good!" Madge Says As She slices Dean's other arm again and he groans in pain, while Mr, Carrigan grabs Sam's hand.

"No. No. Don't." Sam Says As Mr,Carrigan pulls the nail of Sam's index finger and Sam screams while Elena and Corrina look horrified.

"Please Just Stop okay!" Elena Says

"Oh Sweetie We Haven't even gotten to you two, now what we need from you are Uh Honey mind helping me" Madge Says

"Sure, I want the blonde one" Mr,Carrigan Says

"No, No, No Please get away!" Corrina Says as Mr,Carrigan And Madge grab their faces and Takes Pieces of Elena and Corrina's Hair, Then They take a finger nail from Elena

"AHHHH" Elena Screams

"See Was that so hard" Mr,Carrigan Says

"Oh, we got a winner!" Madge Says As She Hold up a fingernail

The Carrigan's put all the ingredients in the bowl and stir them.

"What else, dear?" Madge Says

"Well, let's see. Uh, fingernail, blood. Oh... Hit his own head, sweet Peter on a popsicle stick... he laughs, I forgot the tooth." Mr, Carrigan Says as Sam, Dean, Elena and Corrina Look Horrified

"Oh, dear!" Madge Says

"Merry Christmas, Guys." Dean Says as They All Groan, Mr, Carrigan picks up pliers and grabs Dean's chin.

"Open wide... and say, "Aaah." Mr.Carrigan Says As He puts the pliers into Dean's mouth and Dean groans. The doorbell rings.

With the pliers in his mouth, "Somebody gonna get that?, Madge and Mr, Carrigan look each other. They All looks relieved, You should get that." Dean Says
As Mr.Carrigan Rolls his eyes and sighs

"Come on." Mr.Carrigan Says as Dean sighs in relief and runs his tongue around his teeth.

The Carrigan's open the front door. A Neighbor wearing a green reindeer sweater rings a bell and holds out a fruitcake.

"Merry Christmas!" Neighbor Says They Gives Madge a fruitcake

"I told you I smelled fruitcake!" Mr.Carrigan Says

"You shouldn't have." Madge Says

"Oh, bite your tongue, it's my pleasure." Neighbor Says

"It looks scrumptious!" Mr.Carrigan Says

"Say, Neal and I are going caroling. You care to join?" Neighbor Asks

"You know we would—" Madge Says

"It's my back. Darn thing's giving me fits." Mr.Carrigan Says

"Oh, well, that's a shame. Oh well, Merry Christmas." Mr.Carrigan Says

"And to you too, dear." Madge Says

"Hey, are we still on for bridge tomorrow?" Neighbor Asks

"With bells on!" Mr.Carrigan Says

"Yes! Okay, bye!" Neighbor Says

"Bye-bye." Mr.Carrigan Says As They smile broad fake smiles. When the Neighbor is gone, Mr. Carrigan drops the fruitcake and steps on it on the way back to the kitchen.

Madge and Mr.Carrigan open the door to the kitchen and hurry inside.

"Now, where were we?" Madge Says

Sam and Dean, Elena and Corrina are no longer in their chairs. The Carrigan's see one of the doors close, and turn around to see the other door close too. They are each standing behind one of the doors, as the Carrigan's try to open them. Dean pulls out a drawer to hold his door closed and goes to help Sam.

"What do we do now? The evergreen stakes are in the basement!" Dean Says

"Well, we need more evergreen, Dean!, Looks at the Christmas tree, I think I just found us some more. Looks at large cabinet next to the door, Help me get this." Sam Says

Sam, Dean, Elena and Corrina move the cabinet in front of the door and push the Christmas tree over. They break branches from the tree to use as stakes. All is silent when they approach the kitchen door. Suddenly Mr.Carrigan tackles Dean and Elena to the ground. Madge walks up to Sam and Corrina.

"You little thing. She looks at the tree, I loved that tree." Madge Says

"Aww Too Bad" Corrina Says As Sam raises his stake. Madge hits Sam hard and he crashes into the couch and onto the floor, Corrina Starts Throwing Several Punches at Madge, She Kicks her in the stomachs sending her down, Corrina Then Gets on Madge's Back and Tries to put her in a choke hold but Madge Catches her Arms and Flings Corrina Over to the couch near Sam. Mr, Carrigan punches Dean a number of times in the face, Elena Kicks Mr.Carrigan In the Face and She Gets on top of him and Starts Punching him in the face. Madge walks closer to Sam and Corrina and he hits her with the branches. Madge is about to attack Sam, But he and Corrina stabs her with the Christmas tree stakes in the back and the chest.

"Madge!!!" Mr.Carrigan Says As Sam and Corrina pushes the stake deeper and Madge groans, while Mr,Carrigan Punches Elena in the face she gets off him, but Dean Catches her and hands her a stake and they takes the opportunity and hits Mr.Carrigan with his branches. Corrina pushes the stake in further and Madge falls to the ground, dead. Elena stabs Mr.Carrigan , who screams in pain, and Elena pulls it out and stabs him again. Mr.Carrigan lies dead, next to his wife. Elena and Corrina breathes heavily, while Dean and Sam sighs in relief. They All look at the dead bodies.

"Merry Christmas" Sam Says As He Looks at Dean, smiles briefly and sighs and they all laugh

FLASHBACK, 1991
MOTEL

It's snowing outside. Sam is asleep and Dean shakes him.

"Sam, wake up!, He wakes, Dad was here. Look what he brought." Dean Says As He looks around at a little Christmas tree, decorated with a few lights.

"Dad was here?" Sam Asks

"Yeah. Look at this. We made a killing." Dean Says

"Why didn't he try to wake me up?" Sam Asks

"He tried to, like a thousand times." Dean Says

"He did?" Sam Says

"Yeah. Did I tell you he would give us Christmas, or what? Sam looks around, Go on, dive in." Dean Says
As Sam jumps out of his bed and hurries to the Christmas tree. He finds two presents wrapped with Christmas- themed gift wrap. One of them has green shiny bow. Sam sits on the couch and unwraps his first gift. Dean sits on the other end of the couch and watches, excitedly.

"What is it?" Dean Asks

"Sapphire Barbie." Sam Says

"Dad probably thinks you're a girl." Dean Says

"Shut up!" Sam Says As He Throws the Barbie onto the ground

"We'll Probably Give That Barbie to Elena you know since she's a Girl, But Open that one." Dean Says
As Sam opens the other present and finds a cheerleading stick. He looks at Dean.

"Dad never showed, did he?" Sam Asks

"Yeah, he did, I swear." Dean says

"Dean.... Where'd you get all this stuff?" Sam Asks
As Dean realizes he can't lie anymore and looks down.

"Nice house up the block. Sam looks away, I swear I didn't know they were chick presents. Sam nods Look, I'm sure Dad would have been here if he could." Dean Says

"If he's alive." Sam Says

"Don't say that. Of course he's alive. He's Dad." Dean Says As Sam nods and Dean looks sad. Sam takes the present he wrapped from the pocket of a jacket that is lying over the arm of the couch. He holds it out to Dean.

"Here, take this." Sam Says

"No. No, that's for Dad." Dean Says

"Dad lied to me. I want you to have it." Sam Says
As He continues to hold out the gift. Dean looks at it and at Sam.

"You sure?" Dean Says

"I'm sure." Sam Says As Dean looks at the gift again and takes it. He unwraps the gift, which is a gold amulet on a black string.

"Thank you, Sam. I–I love it." Dean Says As Dean puts on the necklace and Sam nods.

The flashback ends.

__________________________________

MOTEL

Sam looks touched with his own memory. Ella Fitzgerald's "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" plays as Dean walks into the room. The camera focuses on the necklace Sam gave him in 1991. He looks surprised because Sam, Elena and Corrina has decorated the room with a Christmas tree and "Merry Christmas" sign.

"Hey! You get the beer?, Holding a cup of eggnog, What's all this?" Dean Says As He Looks at the decorations in the room

"What do you think it is? It's – it's Christmas." Sam Says As Dean looks at Sam, who lets out a deep breath.

"What made you change your mind?" Dean Asks

"Don't Know, He Came into our Room and Said He needed help decorating for Christmas" Elena Says

"Yea, It was totally weird but it brought back some good memories of when I was a kid and decorating was my favorite part Ahh good times" Corrina Says

"Here, uh ... try the eggnog. He Gives Dean a cup, Let me know if it needs some more kick." Sam Says As He holds out a bottle of whiskey, Dean sips it, coughs, and looks surprised at the taste.

"Well" Elena Says

"No, we're good." Dean Says

"Yeah?" Sam Says

"Yeah." Dean Says When Sam looks away, Dean changes his expression, like it tastes toxic Elena Giggles at him, Dean and Elena Suddenly Walks under a Mistletoe

"Oh No" Elena Says

"Oh Come On Lena, it's a simple tradition you gotta do it" Dean Says

"Yeah Right Winchester My lips will never touch yours" Elena Says then chuckles

"Come On, Please I'm a dying man" Dean Says

"Oh Your Gonna pull that card huh" Elena Says

"Yup" Dean Says the he smirks

"Okay Fine, Close your eyes" Elena Says, Dean Closes his eyes and leans in Elena stares at him for a a sec she grabs his chin turns his face and kisses his cheek

"There Ya Go" Elena Says

"Oh wow" Dean Says

"I Believe The Tradition is a kiss and I did that" Elena Says

"Uh Huh" Dean Says As Across The Room Corrina is looking at them Smiling

"Hmm, That's A Start" Corrina Says

"Well, uh, have a seat. Let's do... Christmas stuff, or whatever." Sam Says As Dean looks at the Christmas tree, which is decorated with lights and car air fresheners.

"All right, first things first. Sam and The Girls sits on the couch and Dean pulls up a chair. He takes two packages wrapped in brown paper from a plastic bag and holds them out to Sam, Merry Christmas, Sam." Dean Says

"Where'd you get these?" Sam Asks

"Someplace special. They All Look At Him, The gas mart down the street" Dean Says As Sam laughs Open them up.

"Well, great minds think alike, Dean." Sam Says As He reaches under the couch for two packages wrapped in newspaper, which he gives to Dean

"Really?" Dean Says

"There you go." Sam Says

"Come on." Dean Says As Sam opens his first gift, which is two porn magazines.

"Skin mags! Dean nods, satisfied with Sam's reaction and... and opens the other gift, Shaving cream." Sam Says

"Wowww" Elena and Corrina Says

" I know, You like?" Dean Asks

"Yeah. Yeah." Sam Says As It's Dean's turn to open his presents. He chuckles and unwrap the gifts.

"Look at this. He lifts his presents, it's a candy bar and a bottle of oil, Fuel for me and fuel for my baby. Sam nods, These are awesome Thanks." Dean Says

"Good. Uh Elena and Corrina Did you guys buy gifts?" Sam Asks

"Uh I Did, Now Corrina Here is my gifts" Elena Hands Her A Bag, She looks through it

"No Way, Red Socks that look similar to my old ones" Corrina Says

"Yeah" Elena Says

"Is This a yin and a yang bracelet?" Corrina Asks

"Yup, Obviously because your my yin and I love you" Elena Says, Corrina then gets up and hugs Elena and kisses her cheek

"Now Here's My Gifts" Corrina Says As Elena takes the gifts

"Okay Lets See, Uh you got me some new converses, some vintage Rock shirts, And A Taser, She turns on the taser, Wow" Elena Says

"Yeah I know, 50,000 Volts Cool Right, Elena Nods, look there's one more" Corrina Says As Elena Looks through the bag and she sees a necklace

"Oh My God, Corrina this is beautiful" Elena Looks at the necklace

"I got it at a thrift shop and I thought you'd love this" Corrina Says

"I do thank you so much" Elena Says as she hugs Corrina

"What A Holiday" Elena Says

" Yeah, Merry Christmas." Dean Says as he lifts his eggnog

"Yeah. Yeah. He Lift his eggnog as well as Elena and Corrina and they all makes a toast, Here, Merry Christmas." Sam Says

"Merry Christmas" Corrina & Elena Says As Sam and Dean are silent, knowing that this could be their last Christmas together. They all take a drink of their eggnog and Dean whistles softly at the taste.

"Hey, Dean, y–. He looks sad and about to say something, but he hesitates, then sighs and looks at Dean again, Do you feel like watching the game?" Sam Asks

"Absolutely." Dean Says

"All right." Sam Says As Sam stands up and turns on the TV. They watch the winter football game. Sam glances at Dean and Dean smiles. He glances at Sam Then At Elena She Glances Back Smiling, Then At Corrina, She Lays her head on Corrina's Shoulder, Dean takes another drink of his eggnog

Outside of the room and we see Dean, Sam Elena and Corrina through the window, sharing their Christmas moment, with a large picture of a farm in a snowy field in the background. It's snowing outside. There Are Christmas lights reflected in the paint of the Impala, which is parked outside the room.