FOREST

CABIN

The Impala pulls up outside Andy and Josh's cabin, Dean, Elena and Sam get out of the car.

"Yeah, look, I get why we're here, but there is no way that those dumbasses took Ashley without me waking up. No way." Dean Says

In the prep room Josh walks over to Ashley. She panics as he comes closer. He picks up an axe from the bloody table and she screams.

Sam, Elena and Dean hears Ashley's scream. They run towards the cabin and take out their guns.
The three hunters burst through the door with
their guns aimed. Andy and Josh hear the front door, he drops the axe as he and Andy run out of the room.

Ashley breaths heavily as she looks around the room. Sam, Elena and Dean walk through the room with their guns aimed. Dean walks over to her and puts his gun back in his jeans. He starts to open the gag around her mouth.

"Okay, alright, okay." Dean Says

"Thank you." Ashley Says

"Where are they? Where are they?" Dean Asks

"I-I don't know. They ran." Ashley Says

"Okay, let's go. Come on." Dean Says

Dean helps her up from the chair and walks her out behind Sam and Elena.

"Come on, come on." Sam Says

Dean walks Ashley towards the door, but Josh comes up behind them and pushes Dean against the wall. Elena moves Ashley towards the book-shelf on the other side of the room.

As Andy grabs Sam and throws him back, both of them fall over a chair and onto the ground. Josh smacks Dean's gun out of his hand and starts to choke him, his fangs baring.

"Hunters. I bet you even had silver bullets in that gun." Josh Says

"Well, you win that bet." Dean Says

Sam repeatedly punches Andy, as Dean slams his fist against Josh's hands and headbutts him. He reaches up and grabs the deer antlers trophy from above him.

Dean hits Josh with it, but it breaks. Andy and Sam continue to fight. Dean grabs Josh and slams him into the coffee table.

Josh rolls them over and grabs Dean, his fangs still baring. Andy growls at Sam and picks up his gun. He aims it at Sam as he puts his hands up in surrender.
He picks Dean up as he growls in his face, and slams him against another wall. Elena takes out her gun and aims it at Andy, who points it at her.

"Don't or I'll kill him." Andy Says

"Drop the gun, drop it Andy...you shoot him..I'll shoot him." Elena Says, aiming her gun at Josh.

Andy looks over at Josh, "Josh!"

Josh doesn't hear him and continues to growl at Dean. Andy keeps looking between Sam, Elena and Josh.

A gunshot is heard and Ashley screams, Josh fangs ascend as he lets go of Dean. He falls to the floor dead.

While Andy is holding the gun as he looks down at jobs older brothers body. Sam gets up from the floor, Elena moves closer still aiming her gun at him as Andy points the gun at Sam.

"Woah, woah. Andy, no. You don't have to do this. Alright? You don't wanna do this." Sam Says

"He... he was my brother and he promised. But he was never going to stop. And he turned into a monster. And I'm a monster too." Andy Says

"Andy.." Elena Says, as Andy looks to Ashley with tears in his eyes.

"I'm sorry." Andy Says

Andy points the gun into his stomach and shoots. He falls to the floor. Sam, Elena, Dean and Ashley look on in shock.

"Damn it." She sighed, and looked over at Sam, "You okay?" Elena Asks

"Yeah, you good?" Sam Asks, looking at Dean.

"Yeah. Yeah, that was...that was weird." Dean Says

"Really weird.." Elena Says

Ashley steps away from the book-shelf and Dean takes her arm.

"Hey, you okay?" Dean Asks, as Ashley flinches away from him.

"Don't touch me!" Ashley Says

Ashley trips and she loses her balance and falls back; the deer antlers piercing through her.

"Woah!" Dean Says, as the three of them look on in shock.

"What?" Elena Says, as Sam shakes his head.

"Well, this is a bitch." Ashley Says

Ashley gets up, the antlers still stuck in her body. Sam, Elena and Dean are confused.

"And I was doing so well, too." Ashley Says, she bends her back. The deer antlers fall out of her.

"What are you?" Sam Asks

"Aww, Sam. You don't remember little ol' me?" She Says

Ashely's pupils turn up, her eyes completely white. Flashbacks to 4.22 Lucifer Rising of Sam killing Lilith with his powers. Ashley now Lilith, looks at Dean and Elena and her eyes go back to normal.

"No..." Elena Says

"Lilith?" Dean Says

_________________________________

CABIN

"No. You're dead." Sam Says

"Was dead. Yeah. In the Empty, sleeping the big sleep, until the boss brought me back." Lilith Says

"The boss? Lucifer?" Sam Says

"God. I was supposed to get rescued and in a moment of sweet relief seduce Dean, blah blah blah, obviously that's not happening now, so–oh, well." Lilith Says

"So, Chuck sent you to kill us?" Elena Says

"No. I wish. That's not how this story goes." Lilith Says

"Story?" Dean Says

"Oh, come on. You know how he is. All this? Personally, I thought the whole thing was kinda... easy. Stupid. But I batted my eyes and put Dean to sleep. Made sure you guys saw those two mutts go all murder-suicide. So, yeah." Lilith Says

"Right. If you're not here to kill us then what do you want?" Elena Asked

"The magic gun. The one he gave you." Lilith Says

"The Equalizer?" Dean Says

"Yeah I'm not calling it that. Just give me the gun and we'll be done." Lilith Says

"If God wants his little toy back, he can come get it himself." Dean Says

"Oh, okay. We're gonna do this the hard way. I love the hard way." Sam takes out the demon blade from his pocket, "Demon blade." Dean and Elena takes out their angel blade's, "Angel blade. You've guys upgraded." Lilith Says

"Lady, you have no idea." Dean Says

They move towards her but Lilith blasts them away with her power. They fall back on the ground, Sam and Elena is knocked out, Lilith slowly moves towards them as Dean quickly gets up.

"Wait, wait, wait. No. Don't touch them. Fine. You want the gun, I'll show you where it is." Dean Says

"Oh. You would promise a girl the moon, wouldn't you, Dean Winchester? I should've spent more time with you the last go-around. But what if you're lying?" Lilith Says

"Then you can kill me." Dean Says

"Except, like I said, I can't. Still, a girl has needs. So...if this is just some desperate attempt to save poor Sam and Elena, by the time I'm through with you, you'll be begging to die. So, are you sure?" Lilith Says

"Yeah, I am." Dean Says

"Deal." Lilith Says

In the cabin Sam is lying on the floor, still unconscious.

THE BUNKER

In his dream Dean punches Sam across the face, repeatedly. He throws him against the railing which breaks, causing Sam to fall onto the map table and then onto the ground.

Dean jumps down and rolls up his sleeves, the Mark of Cain is on his right arm. He grabs Sam by the shirt and slams him on the map table. Dean punches him across the face before throwing him to the ground.

"Dean. Stop. Stop. This isn't you." Sam Says

Dean walks closer to Sam he stands up him from the ground. He grabs Sam by the throat and pushes him up against the controls on the wall as he holds up the First Blade.

"No. No, no, no." Sam Says

Dean's eyes flash back and he stabs Sam with the blade. His eyes flutter closed as Dean pulls out the blade as Sam falls to the floor.

CABIN

Sam is still asleep, Elena's eyes open and she sees that Dean and Lilith aren't nowhere in sight.

"Oh no Dean.." She sits up and crawls over to Sam, "Sam, Sam! wake up!" Elena Says

Sam wakes up and he looks around the room, then at Elena.

"Elena, whoa whoa where's Dean?" Sam Asks

"Where do you think." Elena Says

"Right, come on." Sam Says, as Elena lends out her hand and helps him to his feet.

IMPALA

Lilith faces Dean as he drives, he continues to stare at the road. She noticed the ring on his finger, and smirks.

"Is that a ring, wow I don't know how I didn't notice earlier. So who's the lucky girl that won Dean Winchester's heart?" Dean doesn't respond, "Wait don't tell me..is it Elena, oh my it totally is. Wow you two actually made it happen I'm shocked..well not really I mean even back then I knew she had the hots for you." Lilith Says

"Lilith why? just...why?" Dean Asks

"Well, because, of the three potential vessels, Ashley had the best hair." Lilith Says

"No, why are you doing this? You even said it yourself, this is stupid." Dean Says

"It is. Do you think I want to be here? I died to free Lucifer from the Cage. I had to die for what I wanted most. Then you three went and screwed it all up." Lilith Says

"Yeah, but that was God, too, right? Just another one of his stories?" Dean Says

"Well, I can't hurt him. But I can hurt you." Lilith Says

CABIN

Sam picks up the demon blade and he and Elena rushes out the door. They look around the area, until he sees Andy and Josh's truck parked there.

IMPALA

"I don't get it. Why the games?" Dean Asks

"What? You didn't like the part when you bonded with the victim?" She pretends to be Ashley, "Wouldn't it be great if everything was just
planned out for you?" Lilith Says, then laughs.

"Let me guess, one of Chuck's lines?" Dean Says

"Word for word. God..he is not exactly Shakespeare. He's more of a low-rent Dean Koontz. I had to listen to his whole, quote "writing philosophy". And his very weird, very pervy obsession with you. Then it always ends the same. One brother killing the other. I mean, this world...he could've ended it in so many ways, and...he likes that one. You know, I guess that's why you had to see the werewolf brothers die the way they did, 'cause...foreshadowing." Lilith Says, as Dean looks over at her.

MOTEL ROOM

They arrive back at the motel Dean parked the Impala, turning on the light as he walks into the room, followed by Lilith.

"So...here we are. Now, be a good boy and show me that big gun, huh?" Lilith Says

"You know what? It's on me. I forgot; we didn't actually bring it. Sorry." Dean Says

Lilith flicks her finger through the air. With her powers, she slices Dean's left cheek.

"Have you ever heard of Ling Chi? It's Chinese. It means "lingering death." Death by a thousand cuts." She does the same to Dean's right cheek. Blood drips down his face, "Where is the gun?" Lilith Says

"Go to Hell." Dean Says

Lilith laughs at him then she flicks her hand again, causing Dean to double over as it cuts his body.

"I can make this last for a really long time, Dean. I can make it last almost forever." She uses her powers to cut Dean again, "Tell me!" Lilith Says

Elena and Sam opens the door and comes into the motel room. She aims her gun at Lilith and shoots, the bullet hitting her in the forehead. She tries to move, but she can't.

"You..What?!" Lilith Says

"Devil's Trap bullet. We upgraded, Bitch." Elena Says

"Dean, you good?" Sam Asks, looking over at him.

"Nothing that a box of Band-Aids can't fix." Dean says, as he walks over towards them.

"Where's Chuck?" Sam Asks

"Why would I ever tell you anything?" Lilith Says

"Because I've killed you before..." He takes out the demon blade, "And I can do it again." Sam Says

"See, you keep saying that, but you killed me because I let you. Now I'm feeling...less generous." Lilith Says

Her eyes roll back and Lilith's eyes flash white. The room starts to shake as lights start breaking and falling.

"Let's move!" Dean Says

The boys and Elena rush out the door, Lilith uses her powers to remove the bullet from her forehead.
Sam, Elena and Dean run towards the car in the parking lot.

"Wait!" Sam Says

"That shot ain't gonna hold her forever, man. We gotta get-" Dean Says, then all of sudden they stop in their tracks.

"What the?" Sam Says

"Sam, Dean, I can't move." Elena Says

"Oh, crap." Dean Says, as Lilith appears and stands in front of them.

"Sucks, doesn't it?" Lilith Says

"You're never getting that gun." Dean Says

"Sure I am. See, you guys left that room so fast you had no time to grab anything. So, the gun was never there. Would you really take something like that home? I mean, what if you need it? Hmm? So, it's not in the room. And it's not in the Bunker..." Lilith Says

Lilith looks back at the Impala and she walks over to the car.

"No, no, no." Sam Says

"Come on." Dean Says

"Bitch." Elena mutters

Lilith looks around inside the car. She opens the glove compartment and laughs. She takes out the gun and as she turns back to Sam, Elena and Dean. She walks back over to them.

"Well, this was fun." Lilith Says

"You know what? Go ahead and take it. We'll get it back." Elena Says

"Will you?" Lilith Says

The gun lays in her hand as it starts to glow. It melts away from her hand and falls into a puddle on the ground.

"Thank you, boys. See you soon." Lilith Says

She disappears, Elena and the boys step forward. They look down at the melted gun.

_______________________________

THE BUNKER

Sam is in the library, he sits on the table on his phone as Elena sits down in the chair with Wren on her lap rocking her asleep. Dean walks in, he hands him a glass of whiskey.

"That Cas?" Dean Asks

"Yeah, straight to voicemail. Again." Sam Says

"Yeah, well. We gave the heads up on Chuck and Lilith, so... what else are we supposed to do?" He
sits down at the table with his glass of whiskey.
"He was supposed to be gone. God was supposed to be gone." Dean Says

"Yeah, well apparently he's not.." Elena sighed

"So, what? We're just stuck in his...in his maze, still? And now, Lilith is back. I mean, what's he gonna do? Just throw our greatest hits at us?" Dean Says

"I mean...why doesn't he just kill us, already?" Sam questions

"Because that's not what he wants. Lilith said that... Chuck only likes one kind of ending. You kill me or I kill you." Dean Says, as Sam and Elena looks over at him.

"What?" Sam Says

"Yeah. Well, that's not happening." Elena Says

"Nope." Dean Says, as he drink his whisky.

"Dean, Elena..my dreams, or visions, or whatever... they all end the same way. With us killing each other." Sam Says, as he takes a seat.

"What?" Elena and Dean Says

"Yeah." Sam Says

"You're just telling me this now?" Dean Says

"I-I thought they must've been some form of messed up PTSD, but...but what if they're not? What if I'm somehow seeing Chuck's endings? You know, different ones." Sam Says

"How would that be possible?" Elena Says

Sam points to his shoulder where the bullet wound is.

"'Cause of this. When I shot Chuck, the bullet wasn't a bullet, it was uh... a piece of me. Right? So, what if it created a–a link of sort, you know? I mean, what if-what if I don't...what if somehow, I'm in his head?" Sam Says

"This was supposed to be over. We were done. We were free. And now...what are we supposed to do, man? We just keep running in this–this... friggin' hamster wheel until we die? Or until we get boring and he ends us." Dean Says

"Or we fight." Sam Says, as Dean laughs bitterly.

"Come on Sam, fight God?" Elena Says, as Sam nods.

"Without the gun? It's God, Sam. And he's coming for us. How the hell are we supposed to fight God?" Dean Says

Sam looks at Dean, he picks up his drink and turns away.