- <3 -

JEON JUNGKOOK RESULTS (R1)
First off, I wanted to say thank you to all JJK participants and judges! Thanks for being patient and doing all that was asked of you!

Remember, there will be three rounds. The final round will have the top three winners, released on January 7th!

Once you are eliminated, you are free to leave unless you have another book in another category.
As participants are eliminated, there will be a small Active Check (not mandatory) at the very bottom, just asking how your experience was and any improvements, etc. It would help a lot!

The Most Liked results will be in Round 3!

In this category, the most repeated things were the following:

- idolxfan trope
- pov inconsistencies
- past and present tense confusion/mix
- misspelling names/not capitalizing them
- punctuation issues/grammar issues

Each individual review highlights certain issues like these (if they were found), so please note them down and revise your books with this help!

When it comes to the idolxfan trope, it was very common. However, that's not the main issue. For points to be deducted, the trope must have been too common. If the trope included some unique things, not as much points were deducted. Please understand that since a lot of stories had a very similar approach, there needs to be something to distinguish each of them from one another. One has to shine on top.

DISCLAIMER
This round includes the lowest scored books + books eliminated for AI percentages or for not following the rules. Some books that were eliminated due to AI do have feedback as it was detected after judging.

Every participant needs to pick up their reviews! Down below in the Active Check you can write any social media (Insta, X, Discord, etc.) you may have so I can send it to you. If you do not have one, we can discuss how to send it in the comments.

Remember, if VVIP, you'll pass straight to Round 3 for a final re-evaluation done by me. Your scores will not be seen until Round 3 in which you can either win or be eliminated.

If you only have one judge review that means I was your only judge.

I do tend to judge harshly at times, which can be seen with a significance in score drops, but it's because of accuracy when it comes to judging all the books. Just to ensure all are graded similarity. Please understand.

The mean average of all the scores total in this category is: 57.86!

—

ROUND 1 RESULTS
(will include five books)

JASMINE by shilohshammah [M] {Eliminated}
- AI detected in the preface and some in blurb, which disqualifies the book from competition. Some areas included 20% AI, but others included 100% in multiple detectors. Since I can't pinpoint if AI was used for editing or for the writing itself, the story will be disqualified as per the rules. It's a shame it was eliminated, the story seemed promising.

Hearts in chaos: Embers of Passion by katrina12234 [M] (first judge - 58) {Eliminated}
- AI detected in the blurb and in multiple chapters as 100% in multiple detectors, which disqualifies the book from competition. Since I can't pinpoint if AI was used for editing or for the writing itself, the story will be disqualified as per the rules. [first judge left some feedback to check out!]

Twisted Love by stillwithkook_ [M] (first judge - 81) {Eliminated}
- AI detected as 100% in the blurb and in multiple later chapters through multiple detectors, which disqualifies the book from competition. Since I can't pinpoint if AI was used for editing or for the writing itself, the story will be disqualified as per the rules. [the first judge and I left some feedback to check out!]

The Jeon Twins Book-01 by ggukie_69 (35)
- Review done by me. Please check it out!

That Coffee Guy by Poutinghamburger [M] (first judge - 64) {re-judge - 43}
- Review done by the judge and I, please check it out!

Any questions? Let me know!
Round 3 will include Honorable Mentions!

What You Need For The Goodbye Check
1- Anything you'd like to say about the
scores/awards/hosts/judges/participants.

GOODBYE CHECK — (✨)

QUESTIONS — (✨)

~ shooketha ~