SS (Short Stories)Results-First Round
Here are the results of the First Round of SS (Short Stories).
Thankyou sunshine-in-disguise and CrystalPandit for judging the nominated books of SS category.
*Dear contestants please do follow your judge,else your book will be disqualified.*
1)Book :- Born To Save Us by chocolategirlj26
Title :- 3.5/5
(Could have been better)
Cover :- 3/5
(The fonts and colors are not appropriate. It could have been better.)
Blurb :- 7/10
(Could have been better.)
Grammar & Spelling :- 5/10
(In the first chapter 9th line there were typos like '' Sameer who is busy in his smartphone mesmerized seeing her ''
Which should be ''Sameer who was busy in his smartphone got mesmerised seeing her ''
In the 20th line , there was spelling mistake . You have written ''chok'' there , which should be ''Chalk''.
There were much more typos , and grammar mistakes so i guess 5/10 is apt. )
Originality of Plot & uniqueness :- 15/20
(The plot could have been more unique.)
Flow :- 5/10
(Everything happened in a rush. Though its a short story but still you should have carried the story smoothly.)
Plot & Character Development :- 15/20
(Like I said earlier , everything happened in a rush so with the character development. And plot seems to be nice despite of few mistakes. )
Overall :- 6/10
(I think you should correct the mistakes . This book has the potential to be become a very good one . )
So this book is Not Accepted.
2)Book : Bachpan ke dost se lekar Jeevan Saathi tak by chocolategirlj26
Title : 4/5
(A bit too long )
Cover : 5/5
(Perfect.)
Blurb : 3/10
(Too short . You should have given some details.)
Grammar & Spelling : 8/10
(Minor mistakes are there . Mixing up of Past & Present Tense .No quotation comma rules . )
Originality and Uniqueness of Plot : 17/20
(Good Plot . But these types of plots are used widely so 17/20 is apt .)
Flow : 8/10
(In my opinion , it's a bit fast. )
Plot & Character Development : 18.5/20
(Plot is good . Problem is in with character development . It seems that the characters have no control on their characters themselves (funny i guess). Feelings seems to be rushing .)
Overall : 8/10
(The story is not completed yet so you can rectify your mistakes and make it a wonderful story. Its really good. )
So this story is Accepted.
3)Book : Kiss Me by chocolategirlj26
Title : 3/5
(It could have been better)
Cover : 4/5
(Cover is good . But you can make it even better.)
Blurb : 2/10
(Too short for description .you could have added details . )
Grammar & Spelling : 6/10
(I found a lot of typos , spelling mistakes here , and also the mixing up of past & present tense.
No quotation comma rules. )
Originality and Uniqueness of Plot : 14/20
(Umm i found nothing unique .)
Flow : 5/10
(The story was breaking in between . No flow. )
Plot & Character Development : 15/20
(Although plot was good , it lacks in character development .)
Overall : 6/10
(A good plot though. But i suggest you to write or edit it again. )
So this story is Not Accepted.
Better luck next time.
4)Book : Dard by Radhika_Pareek_10
Title : 4.5/5
Cover : 3/5
Lacks creativity
Blurb : 2/10
No explaination. Nothing . Too short.
Grammar & Spelling : 7/10
There is line in the second chapter in which you have written "Restro" which should be "Restaurant".
In the same chapter there is another mistake, you have written "at saying" which should be "are saying" .There are typos.
Originality & Uniqueness of Plot : 18/20
Yes its unique but a bit .
Flow : 8/10
I experienced few breaks while reading this.
Plot & Character Development : 18/20
It's good but can be better.
Overall : 8/10
I had a good time reading this. The more you read this , the more you got curious to know what happens next. I felt a connection with the female lead of the story . Good job !
So this book is Accepted.
5)Book : Contract Love by chocolategirlj26
Title : 4/5
It was good but can do better.
Cover : 5/5
Perfect
Blurb : 8/10
Lack of details.
Grammar & Spelling : 7/10
No quotation comma rules .Typos were there. Spelling mistakes were there.
Originality & Uniqueness of Plot : 17/20
This topic is widely used but its good.
Flow : 6/10
Breaks were there .
Plot & Character Development : 17/20
Plot was breaking . Character development was good.
Overall : 7/10
Overall it is a good story . Few mistakes are there but can be read positively. Good time reading this.
This book is Accepted.
6)Book : Pyaar Ek Tarfa by Radhika_Pareek_10
Title : 2/5
Though you've selected a nice title but the title is not fitting well with the story plot.
Cover : 2/5
Font color and size could've been better. Also the name of the cover artist and the author isn't properly displayed.
It could have been more smooth.
Blurb : 2/10
No proper description , one small phrase isn't enough.
Grammar & spelling : 7/10
There are minor grammatical and spelling mistakes.
Also please check the proper use of punctuation at certain places.
Uniqueness of plot : 14/20
The plot is unique but you've not described things in detail. It has scope.
Plot & Character development : 15/20
Characters are described nicely in the start but some of them are suddenly striked out from the picture. For example you could have shown more about munna his feelings for naina I mean suddenly she calls him munna bhaiya and there is a clean chit like he just let her go. I am not telling that you did wrong. No, but you could have shown more.
Flow : 5/10
No proper transition and as you've used short short sentences the flow is disturbed.
Overall : 5/10
So this book is Not Accepted.
7)Broken without you by Radhika_Pareek_10
Title: 3.5/5
Kind of common. The words 'without' and 'you' didn't start with capital letters.
Cover: 1.5/5
No efforts at all.
Blurb: 5/10
Didn't mention the essentials to hook a random reader.
Grammar and spellings: 12/20
No punctuation marks used except full stops.
Originality of plot: 15/20
Characterisation: 5/10
I know that this is a fan fiction, but if we are gonna include the characterisation aspect, then you should have at least outlined every character's sketch. From the eyes of a random or general reader, they won't be able to figure out the true personality of the characters.
Flow: 7.5/10
Development: 16/20
Overall: 7.5/10
•So this book is Accepted.
8) samaina's pure love by the_fantasy_world__
Title: 2/5
Cover: 1.5/5
Blurb: 4/10
Grammar and spellings: 13/20
Originality of plot: 14/20
Characterisation: 6/10
Flow: 6/10
Development: 10/20
Overall: 5/10
Using emojis is a big mistake. Formal writing norms of literature don't allow that. Capital letters are missing, even from the title. It's fun to read for sure. Cover needs efforts.
So this book is Not Accepted.
9) Suman: A Bundle Of Fortune by samaina_fan_samaina
Title: 4.5
Don't mention your story type (ss) in the title.
Cover: 3/5
Depicts the story but the font is not good. The text is not much visible.
Blurb: 7/10
Grammar and spellings: 7/10
Originality of plot: 15/20
Characterisation: 7/10
Flow: 6/10
Development: 13/20
Overall: 7.5/10
It was a sweet story. However, this isn't a dialogue book so you should not express the emotions or mention the adjectives in bracketd in between or in the starting of dialogues. This has good potential, work a bit and you'll do great.
So this book is Accepted.
10) Tashn-e-ishq by the_fantasy_world__
Title: 3.5/5
Cover: 2.5/5
Blurb: 7.5/10
Grammar and spellings: 13/20
Originality of plot: 12/20
Characterisation: 5/10
Flow: 7/10
Development: 13/20
Overall: 6.5/10
Again, you don't need to state your story type or even the fandom in the title. It can be adjusted in the blurb or disclaimer. It's nice but needs editing and a bit of plot or characterization changes. Those are getting common. Otherwise, nice story.
So this story is Not Accepted.
11) first and last best friend forever by the_fantasy_world__
Title: 3/5
Cover: 3/5
Blurb: 7/10
Grammar and spellings: 15/20
Originality of plot: 14/20
Characterisation: 6/10
Flow: 7/10
Development: 16/20
Overall: 7/10
The title was great if you didn't forget the capital letters and didn't mention the story type of status. Cover needs efforts. It doesn't depict the storyline. Overall, it's a common plot but still you did a good job. Keep a check at the grammar and literature rules.
So this story is Not Accepted.
12) samaina short story GALTI by shambhavisontakke
Title: 2.5/5
Cover: 3.5/5
Blurb: 7/10
Grammar and spellings: 15/20
Originality of plot: 15/20
Characterisation: 7/10
Flow: 7/10
Development: 16/20
Overall: 8/10
Title mistake again. Cover looks decent but can be better. The story is great. Look out after the grammar plus flow and you're all set.
So this story is Accepted.
13) Main Phir Bhi Tumko Chahungi by shambhavisontakke
Title: 5/5
Cover: 4/5
Blurb: 6.5/10
Grammar and spellings: 15/20
Originality of plot: 17/20
Characterisation: 8/10
Flow: 8/10
Development: 17/20
Overall: 8.5/10
Liked the idea of the plot. I'm glad you mentioned briefly, or gave a hint about from the scene the story takes place, keeping in mind the general readers. My suggestion to make this even better is to check the grammar.
So this story is Accepted.
14) The Incomplete Life 💔 by KavyaKa2800
Title: 3.5/5
Cover: 2.5/5
Blurb: 8/10
Grammar and spellings: 16/20
Originality of plot: 16/20
Characterisation: 6/10
Flow: 6/10
Development: 16/20
Overall: 8/10
It's great. My suggestions to make this even better are, don't use emojis and look after title and cover. Provide spaces between paragraphs.
This story is Accepted.
15) I can't love you by Doraashi
Title: 4/5
Cover: 3.5/5
Blurb: 8.5/10
Grammar and spellings: 18/20
Originality of plot: 19/20
Characterisation: 8.5/10
Flow: 9/10
Development: 19/20
Overall: 9/10
It's unique and had a great plot. My suggestions to make this even better are to look after the title (capitalization and story status) and the tense in the story. I noticed it changing somewhere or the other. The cover is great, but the white portion and the font makes it a little less attractive.
This book is Accepted.
Not Accepted Stories
1)Born To Save Us by chocolategirlj26
2)Kiss Me by chocolategirlj26
3)Pyaar Ek Tarfa by Radhika_Pareek_10
4)Tashn-e-ishq by the_fantasy_world__
5)first and last best friend forever by the_fantasy_world__
6)samaina's pure love by the_fantasy_world__
Accepted Stories
1)Bachpan Ke dost se lekar jeevan saathi tak by chocolategirlj26
2)Contract Love by chocolategirlj26
3)Dard by Radhika_Pareek_10
4)Suman: A Bundle Of Fortune by samaina_fan_samaina
5)I Can't Love You by Doraashi
6)samaina short story GALTI by shambhavisontakke
7)Main Phir Bhi Tumko Chahungi by shambhavisontakke
8)Broken without you by Radhika_Pareek_10
9)The Incomplete Life 💔 by KavyaKa2800
Important Note:-
This is just a Contest dear Contestants! Do not make Fake Accounts to win the Voting Contest.
Bạn đang đọc truyện trên: Truyen247.Pro