»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

requested plot: reader breaks up with her girlfriend AJ Lee after she thinks April is cheating on her with CM Punk

trope: lovers to ex lovers to lovers again with AJ Lee

pairings: wrestler reader x AJ Lee / reader x (platonic) Alexa Bliss

a.n: okay so i will be going off their plot they gave me the best I can and obviously will include things I think will fit the plot. italics are gonna be flashbacks! April = AJ Lee / Phil = CM Punk / Trinity = Naomi

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

Y/N ran a hand through her hair, already annoyed with her opponent. She was teaming with her girlfriend AJ Lee (they were not publicly out about it yet) against The Bella Twins. Brie had continued to kick out of the spear by Y/N and it really annoyed her. Y/N stood up and grabbed Brie by her hair, ignoring the referee telling her to let go. Y/N shoved Brie into the corner, pointing directly at Nikki, signaling she wanted Nikki in the ring. Brie tagged and Nikki and a small smirk appeared on Y/N's lips but you couldn't tell unless up close. Nikki grinned and stepped in the ring, Y/N ran at her but Nikki quickly went to the ropes which made the referee pull Y/N back.

Y/N rolled her eyes at Nikki who smacked her bottom and blew a kiss at Y/N. Nikki got herself fully back in the ring and Y/N immediately hit her with a closeline, annoyed at her previous antics. Y/N grabbed Nikki and turned her around, performing a German Suplex. Then suddenly she heard a shout in the corner, "Do my submission!" AJ shouted to her. Y/N didn't respond except pulling Nikki up and they fought once more, both countering each time until Y/N locked in the Black Widow submission. Not noticing Brie go to step in the ring only AJ also got in and knee'd her in the face before also locking in the Black Widow submission on Brie.

Both women finally tapped at the same time, making Y/N and AJ let go and get the win. Y/N stood to her feet and AJ raised her hand but Y/N suddenly stiffened feeling AJ wrap her arms around her. Then AJ pressed a peck to Y/N's cheek, making her stiffen and her widens widened slightly. The crowd cheered but Y/N just awkwardly patted AJ's shoulder.

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

Y/N groaned as Cameron kicked her in the face and tagged in Naomi. Y/N wasn't planning on tagging out until suddenly she felt a tap on her shoulder. Y/N turned to look at AJ who responded by making a silly face at her. A small smile was shown on Y/N's lips and the crowd busted in cheers. That was probably the most emotion anyone could get Y/N to show. AJ cheered as she got Y/N to finally break character. Then Y/N went back to blank face and stepped out of the ring to let AJ take care of Naomi.

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««
(2020)

Y/N let out an breath, feeling defeated when Sasha Banks had just defeated her. Y/N sat in the ring all by herself, and ran a hand through her hair in frustration. That was until she suddenly heard that music. The music of Alexa Bliss who was currently going through some weird psychotic break. Everyone was terrified of her and Alexa didn't like anyone anymore, and was mean and rude to everyone. Y/N frowned in confusion seeing Alexa walk down the ramp with a grin, spinning and twirling with Lily in her hands. Y/N furrowed her brows, the crowd silent as they were confused about what was about to happen.

Alexa slid in the ring and crawled over to Y/N who didn't back down or crawl away. Alexa smiled and leaned forward, hugging Y/N with a smile and the crowd cheered. "You're mine now," Alexa spoke, the cameras and mics picking up what she said as planned. "I won't let anyone hurt you anymore."

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

Y/N ran and hit Sasha with a Tornado DDT, pinning her to the three count. Alexa cheered and pulled Y/N up, immediately hugging her then she leaned up and pecked Y/N's cheek. Y/N immediately stiffened and patted Alexa's shoulder awkwardly. Everyone in the crowd got deja vu and so did Y/N. She licked her lips and looked down, remembering a time when her ex girlfriend AJ did the same thing. "I can't be the only one getting deja vu," Michael Cole spoke.

𓆩♡𓆪

Y/N ran and hit Bayley with a running knee, knocking her into the corner where Sasha tagged herself in. Y/N got up and went to run at Sasha but suddenly felt a pat on her shoulder. Y/N blinked and turned around, looking at Alexa who stuck her tongue out, doing the same silly face AJ used to do to Y/N. "I swear I've seen this before," Corey said. Y/N blinked but got distracted which gave Sasha the time to perform a backstabber onto Y/N. This clearly making Alexa mad who stepped in the ring and screamed at a stunned Sasha. Alexa tackled Sasha to the mat and everyone's eyes widened at how protective she got.

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««
(2013)

April wipes her tears, watching as Y/N was packing up her things. "So you're just gonna leave? Over some lie that you yourself probably don't believe!" April said.

Y/N sighed and turned around, "As much I don't want to believe it, it's pretty damn hard to not believe. Do you see the way you act around Phil? The way you two look at each other?? It's pretty damn obvious that there's something going on there so I'll make it easier for you and let you go first." Y/N went to walk out but April grabbed her wrist and Y/N turned back around.

April looked at Y/N with pleading eyes, "Please don't go. I love you, okay? I said it. I love you."

Y/N sighed and shook her head, "I'm sorry but I just don't believe that. Goodbye, April." Y/N walked out and April ran a hand through her hair and wiped her tears that she couldn't keep from falling.

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««
(2020)

Y/N ran into the ring when Alexa tagged her in and closelined Asuka. They went at it before Asuka managed to tag in Charlotte who obviously kicked down Y/N and took her time to showboat. Y/N shoved Charlotte into a turnbuckle and backed into her corner with a groan. Alexa tapped Y/N's shoulder and Y/N turned around with raised brows. Alexa smiled widely at her and Y/N couldn't help but let a small smile come across her face. But she was also in the state of deja vu.

"Did Y/N just smile?! She never smiles! Last time she smiled was in 2015!"

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

Y/N sat in catering scrolling through Twitter, a lot of people tagging her in edits and such but she didn't really have time to look at them so she'd look at them when she got home. Trinity and Sasha walked over and sat next to her with smirks on their faces. "What's with the creepy smirks?" Y/N raised a brow, a bit weirded out by them.

"Oh my god, girl please don't tell me you haven't seen them!" Sasha exclaimed, her mouth agape at her co worker. Y/N squinted her eyes in confusion, "See what?"

Trinity rolled her eyes, "Do you not check your Twitter? Tiktok? Socials? Anything???"

"Not really a fan of social media...so no..not really," Y/N shrugged, not finding it super important. Social media was a horrible place and she had no interest in it. Sasha sighed, "You're so old minded. But, here, I'm sending you these edits so watch them," Sasha said.

Y/N clicked on the links and leaned back in her seat as she watched them. This one had been April praising Y/N in an interview Y/N had yet to watch. And it turned into a edit showing clips of AJ and Y/N when they teamed together. Trin and Sash smiled as they noticed a smile tug onto the corner of Y/N's lips. She continued onto the next ones and all of them where about Y/N/Alexa/and AJ.

"There's this other post on IG that's so good," Sasha said and Trinity nodded, catching onto what Sasha was doing.

"What's it about?" Y/N sighed, wanting to get this over with.

Sasha grinned and pulled up the post and sent it to Y/N. She clicked on it and it was an edit, the first clip being when Alexa had made a funny face at Y/N and she smiled and it flashed to when AJ did the same thing back in 2015 with some kind of background music. Trin and Sasha pointed out that it can't be a coincidence but Y/N was in her own little world. Her mind went all the way back to the argument she and April had.

Sasha snapped her fingers bringing Y/N out of wherever her mind had drifted off to. Y/N looked in between Trin and Sash with raised brows at their cheesy grins. "What?"

"You still love her!" Trin and Sash exclaimed in unison. A few people looked at them but Y/N just blinked, not knowing where this was going. "We broke up five years ago. I don't love her. She's in the past," Y/N mumbled. Trin went to speak but Y/N cut her off, "Drop it. Please, just drop it." Y/N stood up and walked off, leaving Trin and Sasha with visible frowns.

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

Y/N groaned as she sat on the couch in her locker room, holding ice to her sore muscles. She had just finished up a tag match against Liv Morgan and Ruby Riott, The Riott Squad, and to say it was painful was an understatement. It had been a week since her conversation with Trin and Sasha and she couldn't get it out of her head. She didn't know why some stupid edit was making her actually start to question if she ever really stopped loving April.

Y/N let out an annoyed groan when her phone went off. As she picked it up she squinted her eyes at the contact name.

Incoming call from
apricot wifey 🍩🍦

She raised a brow, not sure if her vision was fucking with her or if this was real. She had yet to change the contact name when they broke up as she did have some hope that they would get back together. Y/N ran a hand over her hair compensating on if she should answer or not.

Impulsively she picked the phone back up and pressed answer. A few seconds of silence or more like just breathing was heard before April decided to speak up first.

"You answered."

"You called."

April fiddled nervously with the wine glass in her other hand as Y/N had paced the room back and forth. "How have you been?" April asked, trying to get the conversation going.

"Uhh, I've been good. How have you been?" Y/N asked. She stopped her pacing and finally sat down but her leg bounced up in down nervously.

"I've been pretty good, I'm working on a new women's wrestling promotion. I actually just finished watching your match, sorry if I called at a bad time." April bit her lip nervously after she spoke. "No, it's okay. Perfect timing actually, I just got to my locker room."
Y/N responded. "Let me know if I can do anything to help with the promotion. I'm gonna have a lot of free time when I get written off for Mania season."

"I'll be sure to let you know." April mumbled, a bit surprised that Y/N was willing to help her even if it went against her contract.

"So...is there a specific reason you called?" Y/N hesitantly asked.

"Yeah, actually there was. You know, I've been seeing a ton of those posts, like the ship ones of us back then and those ones with you and Alexa being similar to us. So uhm, it got me thinking, maybe, I was just wondering if you wanted to come over? We could talk, hangout, watch movies, doesn't really matter, I'm up to anything." April shrugged barely even though Y/N couldn't see. Y/N ran her hand over her mouth, contemplating whether it was a good idea or not. After a minute of thinking, she didn't know what came over her to say yes, but she did. "Yes, I mean sure. I can be over there in an hour or two."

"That's great, don't rush. I'll send you the address, in case you forgot." April said, smiling to herself. Y/N nodded and hung up quickly, immediately cursing at herself for saying yes. I mean, what do you say to your ex that you broke up with five years ago and haven't been with anyone since? That would be extremely hard and embarrassing to even confess to her.

"Fuck my life." Y/N walked out of her locker room, her duffle bag around her shoulders as she fiddled with her keys. "Y/N!" Y/N turned around at the call and spotted Trinity jogging over to her. "Everything all good?" Y/N asked.

"The girls and I were gonna go out for dinner, wanted to know if you wanna join us?" Trinity said, now noticing Y/N's very flustered appearance. "Aye, you good?" She asked in concern.

"Yeah, I'm good. I would love to join you but I have to get somewhere, it's important." Y/N said, tapping her foot against the floor impatiently. "Girl, where you goin'?" Trin questioned, slighly amused.

"Out." Y/N smirked slightly as she walked down the hall. Trin simply shook her head in amusement and walked back to the locker room.

》* 。 • ˚ ˚ ˛ ˚ ˛ • 。* 。° 。* 。 • ˚《

Y/N pursed her lips in thought, her mind flickering to the donuts and ice cream on the passenger seat, contemplating this entire situation. She kinda didn't wanna bring up old feelings with the donuts and ice cream, as they used to eat them every time they got home after a wrestling show but, she also wanted to reminisce on the old memories. Honestly she didn't even know how this whole 'hangout' would go. Hopefully it didn't end up with an argument, that's the last thing she wanted.

After sitting in the car for five minutes, she finally decided to suck it up and get out of the car, mostly because the ice cream was gonna start to melt. After knocking on the door, she considered taking off but before she could even turn around, the door opened. April smiled at her old girlfriend who hadn't even aged a day from the looks of it, but her attitude was definitely more different. She held more confidence in herself that she definitely didn't have before.

Obviously the confidence was lacking a little bit cause she immediately grew nervous under April's stare. "Hi, you look amazing. Like you literally have not aged a day." April spoke up first, breaking the awkward silence. "Hey, I can say the same for you." A smile tugged at the corner of Y/N's lips.

"Oh please, I look completely different from when we last seen each other." April denied, gesturing to herself with a small huff.

"Still as beautiful as ever though," Y/N shrugged, and April blushed at the compliment, feeling those old feelings begin to rise. "Do you wanna come in?" April opened the door wider, letting Y/N step inside with a small nod. "So uh, I brought donuts and ice cream, kinda like old times. Thought we could relax and have a chat?" Y/N said, trying to conceal her nervousness.

"Yes, I'm all for it. I've been craving those for so long. I assumed you needed to relax anyways after your match." April walked to the kitchen and grabbed some spoons as Y/N sat down on the all too familiar couch. April passed a spoon to Y/N with a smile and sat down next to her, turning her body to face Y/N's. "So, what have you been up to?" April asked, taking the ice cream and opening it up.

"Well, I asked for some time off, which was granted as they didn't really have anything for me. I figured I'd go back to Japan for a little bit, I've got some friends there with a dojo so I can train and learn the joshi style of wrestling for a few months until Wrestlemania season. Plus it'll be good to get away and relax." Y/N had it thought out for months, she wasn't in any important storyline's so she figured she'd take the time to improve and get better so she could be added to an important fued.

"That's so cool, I wish I could go back to Japan so bad. There's just so much I have to do here so I have literally no time for a vacation. But I'm so glad you wanna improve your moveset." April leaned her head on the couch as she eyed Y/N shyly. "Thanks. I think I have a lot more to accomplish in wrestling before I retire. And I'm still pretty young so that also helps." Y/N shrugged, her eyes focused on the ice cream rather than April out of nervousness.

"I'm sorry, I know you probably don't wanna open up old wounds, but I feel like we should talk about what happened between us." April spoke nervously, looking for Y/N's reaction and she got nothing as Y/N went basically blank. "But if you're not comfortable with it, we don't have to," April quickly added, not wanting Y/N to leave.

Y/N cleared her throat, "No, no it's fine. As much as I wanted to avoid that subject, we can't really move on unless we do." Y/N nodded to herself, sucking her teeth as she looked back at April who had a relieved expression.

"Can I tell you my side first?" April asked, getting a small nod in response.

"I just really wanna clarify that nothing, and I mean absolutely nothing happened between me and Phil. I promise you, anything that happened between us was simply just our characters on TV at the time, but nothing else happened that you weren't aware of. I never once cheated on you, and it hurt me so much that you would think I would hurt you like that." April wiped a few tears that fell during her explanation.

Y/N blinked away her tears, partially feeling guilty about the way she acted in the past. "Obviously, I never intended on making you feel that way. But at that time, I was having my own insecurities, and the way the media was portraying you two together hurt, a lot cause it felt like I was forgotten, in a way. I think I just let my insecurities and jealousy get in the way of how I really felt about you. And I'm really sorry for how I handled things in the past. I should have listened to you instead of jumping to all these conclusions." Y/N sucked her teeth, tears falling during her words.

April wiped her tears and nodded slowly with a small smile, "I completely understand and I forgive you. Do you think we can start over?" April moved closer, setting down her spoon, she reached over to take Y/N's hands in her own. Y/N mustered up a smile, "Yeah, I think we can."

April squealed and leaned over to engulf Y/N in a tight embrace. "Also, I have something to confess." April mumbled shyly as she pulled away. Y/N raised her finger, "Hold on," she shoved a donut in her mouth, "Okay, continue."

April chucked in amusement, "Okay so, this is like extremely embarrassing but I kinda, sorta haven't been with anyone since our breakup." April admitted, running a hand through her hair seeing Y/N's eyes widen ever so slightly. "Like zero contact with another person's body type of anyone?" Y/N raised a brow.

"Yeah, like I've never even kissed anyone and it's so stupid cause its been like five years-" April rambled only to get cut off by the sudden pair of lips attached to hers. She immediately kissed back, feeling Y/N move the ice cream and donuts onto the table with her free arm. Y/N leaned April back down onto the couch, deepening the kiss. After a few seconds they were forced to pull away for breath.

"Same. I haven't been with anyone either." Y/N breathed out, looking down at April who was still processing the entire kiss. "Good. Cause you're mine only," Was all that came out of April's mouth before Y/N was pulled back in.

》* 。 • ˚ ˚ ˛ ˚ ˛ • 。* 。° 。* 。 • ˚《

Y/N grimaced, squinting her eyes at the light that shone through the curtains. "I still hate mornings," Y/N mumbled. April smiled into her bare chest, moving closer to Y/N with steady breaths. Y/N moved the covers off of her and April groaned as Y/N stood up from the bed. "Quite the view," April mumbled, staring at Y/N's ass whilst the girl shut the curtains completely.

"I know right? I'm hot." Y/N smirked, rubbing a hand over her abs as she walked back over to the bed and climbed back under the covers. Y/N pulled April on top of her and she went in for a kiss but Y/N's phone going off, clearly stopped that.

She groaned in annoyance and reached for her phone on the night stand, pressing answer and putting it on speaker for April to hear. "Hey, I just wanted to check in, you didn't answer anyone's calls so we all got worried." Trinity's voice came through and April couldn't help but smile at the familiar voice.

"Thanks for the concern but I'm all good. I just stayed at a uh friend's house?" Y/N furrowed her brows, her statement coming off more like a question which caused April to raise her brows slightly. But Trinity knew that excuse all too well.

"You and April fucked, didn't you?"

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««

a.n: also like to clarify that the reader will have no specific race described unless stated in the beginning so you can picture her as whatever race you like with any kind of appearance!!

but if you want to request a specific race, body, profession, i can do that for you ♡

»»────── 𓆩♡𓆪 ──────««