quick note: i havent seen the musical so this is going off the lyrics not the context/musical

"When he sees me" fits DC

he's afraid of being hurt and needs some amount of control

he needs to know the answer and know that he won't get used or hurt

he's afraid of letting the others in because of all the what ifs

"Never ever getting rid of me" fits Florida

in the sense of

he doesn't want to let DC/California push him away

he wants them to know he'll love them no matter what

he wants them to know he won't use them or hurt them

he falls a little flat on delivery but he tries