(I know that Truth or Dare is the most common game to play to learn about crushes but it will be a good chapter even if it is basic) (one thing is that Salamander, Sky Maiden, and Black Steel are all cousins)

On Friday after school:

Lucy stands at the front gate for everyone to come. Salamander and Demon show up shortly after with a stoking Mermaid. Sky Maiden and a young boy show up momentarily after them. Levy and Black Steel show up with a redhead and another blue-haired boy. (Why do so many people in Fairy Tail have blue hair?)

The new people introduce themselves. "My name is Flame," said the young man. "My name is Titania," said the redhead. "My name is Nirvana," said the blue-haired man.

The group started to walk to Lucy's house and when they arrive they are greeted by a blonde man with a scar on his eyebrow. He introduced himself as Sting, Lola's brother.

"Rogue is coming over to pick me up in a few minutes so don't think I'm intruding on you and your friends." Sting explained to Lucy. (Interpret Rogue and Sting however you want. I am a Strogue fan personally, but you do you)

"We should play truth or dare!" Titania said happily once Sting had left.

"Flame, Truth or Dare?" Sky Maiden asked.

"Truth." was his response.
"Who do you like?" asked Sky Maiden
"I like..... Sky Maiden." was what Flame answered. Sky Maiden blushed to be redder than a tomato. Everyone all said "Awwww" in unison. 

"Lola, Truth or Dare?" asked Flame.

"I choose dare," responded Lola.
"I dare you to get something from the kitchen and give it to your crush." Flame really wanted to use that as a dare. 

When Lucy came back from the kitchen she held a glass of lemonade and gave it to Salamander. "Demon, Truth or dare?" Lucy asked.

"Truth," he answered.
"What are your true feelings for Mermaid?" The most difficult question he could have gotten but he answered either way.
"I have had a crush of Mermaid since she first transferred to this school." Mermaid rushed over to him and crushed him with a hug. When they released from the hug they kissed.

"Salamander, Truth or Dare?" Demon asked.

"Dare," he answered and was eagerly awaiting to do the dare.
"I dare you to hold your crush on your lap until you are asked again." Then he made a low laugh and grabbed Lucy and sat her down on his lap. 

(basically, this except without magic and she looks more shocked than happy)

Salamander spoke next, "Lola, Truth or Dare?"
"Truth," she spoke nervously about this.
"What is your real name?" 
"My name is Lucy Hearfilia." Salamander looks shocked. "Why do you look so shocked? It's not like you know me."

"Salamander, is she the one you told me about?" Demon asked

"Yes, she is the one." He looked like he was seeing a ghost. "So it looks like a hair change really does a lot."

"Salamander? Truth or Dare?" Lucy asked now really wanting to know who he is.
"Truth."
"What is your name?"
"My name... is Natsu Dragneel." (wtf? I never saw this coming)

Levy stood up and slapped Natsu on the face.

"What the hell Le-Athena?" Natsu exclaimed. He was so angry he almost said her real name. (since the three of them went to the same school before, he knew her name) Lucy stood up and started to run to her room and locked it and cried.

"What happened Sa-Natsu and do you know Athena?" Black Steel asked Natsu.
"My name is Levy McGarden and Lucy had a crush on Natsu four years ago and he turned her down. She joined this school just to see him. Now she fell for him again but not him." Levy said.

----------------------------:)---------------------------

How will the group respond to such a big reveal? please comment, I'm not sure what voting is but please vote. Bye.