AN: Hello! I have this planned as a one shot for now. New Puckleberry story.

Disclaimer: I own nothing but storyline.

Warning Rated M

Enjoy!

Puck was hanging out in the Choir room. It had been a year since they had graduated from this Hell hole.

What? He isn't lying.  Puck thought. He spent four long years at this school. He was a BAMF and owns that. He was a sex shark and Cougar magnet. He was a Football god. He tossed many in those dumpsters, although he had been dumped in those himself plus Porta Potty. Thanks to Lauren Zizes for rescuing him.

He thought of the one he let go of.

Beautiful, strong, annoying, bossy, and a star. His star 🌟.

Her.

His Hot Jewish American Princess. Rachel Barbra Berry.

Back in the day he was cruel to her. He got to be with her for a week. Truth be told... It was the best week of his life.

He remembers singing Sweet Caroline to her because she said she needed a leading man.

No one questions Puckasaurus when it comes to leading man material.

He quit football for her. He chose Glee over Football. He didn't do that for Quinn or Santana. He did it for Rachel.

She called him Noah. Her Noah. He didn't let anyone outside of his mother and sister call him Noah. He took the Glist off of her locker. He took a freakin slushy for her. He sacrificed his Second chance with her because of loyalty pact with Finn.

Finn was his brother, but hated how he hurt Rachel over and over again. He didn't deserve her. But, Puck was too chicken to do anything about it.

And now, he is sitting there watching her perform in front of Glee club with him next to her.

Brody Weston.

Puck didn't trust him. Something not adding up with that douchebag. Santana filled him in about Brody's extracurricular activities.

Back in the day Puck would've high-fived him. Puck was a player too. But, when it came to Rachel... Sorry your ass is mine.

Rachel looks sexy as hell...

Gone were the animal sweaters and toddler clothes. Rachel was a Full woman.

He thought back to their first makeout session.

To seeing her with Finn.

To his mistake with Quinn. But his daughter Beth is the one good person to come out of that mess. Rachel still forgave him. She didn't judge him.

To Rachel washing the slushy off of him and she forgave him.

So...why did he let her walk away? It hurt that she chose Finn. He didn't join Glee for Quinn. He joined to keep an eye on Quinn since she was pregnant with his child. He joined because he wanted her...his first REAL girlfriend, Rachel.

After Rachel finished, Puck decided that he was done staying in the background. Rachel is going to listen to him. That he misses being her Man.

"Hey guys, I want to sing this song for one girl. The one i let get away but telling her now... I love you Rachel. I've never stoppedl"

Rachel was stunned.

Brody was pissed.

Puck grabbed his guitar.

(AN: When I Was Your Man by Bruno Mars)

(Puck)

Same bed but it feels just a little bit bigger now
Our song on the radio but it don't sound the same
When our friends talk about you, all it does is just tear me down
'Cause my heart breaks a little when I hear your name

It all just sounds like ooh, ooh ooh hoo hoo
Mm, too young, too dumb to realize
That I should have bought you flowers

And held your hand
Should have gave you all my hours
When I had the chance
Take you to every party 'cause all you wanted to do was dance

Now my baby's dancing
But she's dancing with another man

My pride, my ego, my needs, and my selfish ways
Caused a good strong woman like you to walk out my life
Now I never, never get to clean up the mess I made, oh
And it haunts me every time I close my eyes

It all just sounds like ooh, ooh ooh ooh ooh
Mm, too young, too dumb to realize
That I should have bought you flowers
And held your hand
Should have gave you all my hours

When I had the chance
Take you to every party 'cause all you wanted to do was dance

Now my baby's dancing
But she's dancing with another man

Although it hurts
I'll be the first to say that I was wrong
Oh, I know I'm probably much too late
To try and apologize for my mistakes
But I just want you to know

I hope he buys you flowers
I hope he holds your hand
Give you all his hours
When he has the chance
Take you to every party
'Cause I remember how much you loved to dance
Do all the things I should have done
When I was your man
Do all the things I should have done
When I was your man

Rachel was stunned.

When Puck was done, he looked at Rachel. "I'm sorry Berry. If only I could take Back yesterday. I lied when I walked away. My heart was broken. I never truly got MY chance. I love you, Rachel." He proclaimed
 
Brody glared at him. Puck glared back. "You. You may think your secret is safe but trust me Secrets will come put and kick your sorry Ass." He said.

Puck gathered his things and walked out the door.

Rachel watched him leave. And she felt sick to her stomach. As much as she cared for Brody, her heart wasn't fully his. She gave it away a long time ago.

"So Diva what are you going to do?" Kurt asked.

Rachel looked at Brody. "I'm sorry Brody. I should've listened that you're a manwhore. And my heart was never yours." Rachel said.

Brody grabbed her arm. "Rachel what the hell are you saying?! I love you!" He begged.

"I love HIM." Rachel admitted. She looked at her fellow Glee clubbers who smiled back.

Rachel stormed out of the room.

Kurt did a happy dance. "Ding dong the ass is gone. And no more bareass on my furniture. Unless it's Blaine's." Kurt proclaimed.

Brody was pissed and embarrassed. He left the room.

Rachel saw Puck walking out the front doors.

"Noah! Wait!" Rachel yelled.

Puck turned and was surprised to see Rachel.

"What is it Berry?" He asked.

Rachel walked up to him, pulled him to her, crashing her lips on his. Puck was stunned but kissed her back. Quickly became heated and more passionate.

After a few minutes they pulled apart. Puck caressed her hair, face, and body.

"What do you want Rachel?" He asked.

Rachel smiled.

"I want my man back. Can you help me find him?" She said with a smile.

Puck smiled. Not a smirk but a real smile.

"I'm right where I've always been. Took you long enough." He teased.

Rachel grabbed his hand, swaying her hips, leading him out the door.

"Well looks like I have some catching up to do. Think you're up for it?" She asked, flirtatiously.

"Pffst I'm Puckzilla. Always ready baby." Puck said.

Rachel kissed him again.

"For starters, don't ever say Puckzilla again. Not if you want to fuck me." She said.

"Whoa did Rachel Berry say "fuck"?! Hot!" He answered.

"I can say the word. You don't own it. Fuck..Fuck." Rachel taunted.

Puck picked her up, tossing over his shoulders. Rachel giggled. "Noah!!!!"

"Save that for bedroom baby. If we make it that far. I can't wait." Puck said.

"I love you Noah." Rachel admitted.

"I love you too." He said with a smile.

Meantime, the rest of the Glee club watched.

"Puckleberry is back!" They said in unison.

Yes they were...

AN: Hope you enjoyed. ❤

Dedicated to dramaqueen0123 alex_Corney96 Pugsbunny88 ShannonCataldi DanielleJackson379 love you all