Requested by MothGoji

Both Connor Kenway and Shay Cormac are students of Achilles. But which student is the most prominent one?

Connor Kenway

Close Range Arsenal

Tomahawk

Dagger

Twin Hidden Blades

French Cutlass

French Boarding Axe

Gunstock War Club

Long Range Arsenal

Bow and arrow

Throwing knives

Coated in highly toxic water hemlock poison

Pistols

Flintlock

Double-barrel

Duckfoot

Pitcairn-Putnam (pair)

Misc. Arsenal

Rope darts

Smoke bombs

Trip mines

Shard of Eden

Ring-like Piece of Eden

Protects from stray metallic projectiles

Formerly used by William Kidd

Eagle Vison

Sixth sense

Can sense the emotions and intentions of those around him

Used to distinguish friend from foe

Able to find key targets, objects, and hiding spots

Alternate Reality abilities

Wolf Cloak

Turns invisible

Wolf Pack

Summons three wolves

Eagle Flight

Transforms into bird and flies at incredible speed

Bear Might

Creates large shockwave

Feats

Became an assassin at the age of 13

Defeated a group of bandits before his Assassin training

Quickly mastered sailing and commanding a ship

Turned the tide of battle against the British on multiple occasions

Helped rebuild a wiped out colonial Assassins Order

Defeated Haytham

Survived an alternate timeline created by an Apple of Eden

Weakness

Sometimes lets his emotions get the best of him

Somewhat naïve

Stubborn

Lacks armor

Alternate Reality abilities drain him with overuse

Shay Cormac

Arsenal

Dual-wielding Sword And Dagger

Hidden Blades (both hand)

Air Rifle (with grenade launcher)

Flintlock Pistols

Rope Darts

Smoke Bombs

Eagle Vison

Sixth sense

Can sense the emotions and intentions of those around him

Used to distinguish friend from foe

Able to find key targets, objects, and hiding spots

Feats

Killed Adéwalé

Killed Charles Dorian

Considered the Assassin's second best sailor

Escaped Lisbon during a massive earthquake

Killed Liam O'Brien and Hope Jensen

Weakness

Weak power base due to Connor's time of being away

Fight

Village, night

Connor walks through the alley, staring at the Wanted Posters on the wall.

Unknown to him, a figure slipped through the shadows, watching him.

As Connor walks through, he stops as he watches a man wearing a red spandex suit talking to a pink pony.

Deadpool: Look, I'm telling you there's a good place for cakes here.

Pinkie Pie looks around and she points and said.

Pinkie Pie: How about we ask that guy?

Deadpool turns and he glowers as he saw an old man greeting him.

???: Hey there Deadpool.

Deadpool points a finger at him and he shouts.

Deadpool: Zip it Stan Lee!

Deadpool turns and he said to Pinkie Pie.

Deadpool: C'mon. I'm sure it must be that way.

Pinkie Pie: Okay

Both Deadpool and Pinkie Pie walks away, leaving Connor watching them in confusion.

Connor: That's an odd pair.

Connor remarks to himself as he walks away.

Just then, Connor heard a voice saying.

???: You.

Connor turns and he saw a man approaching him.

He questions.

Connor: Who are you?

The man draws out his dual swords and he introduces himself.

???: I am Shay Cormac and I am here to kill you.

Connor questions.

Connor: Kill me? For what?

Shay answers.

Shay: For stealing one of my kills.

Connor draws out his Tomahawk and he said.

Connor: I do not care for your little games. But if you dare to stand in my way, I shall make quick work of you.

Both Connor and Shay stares at each other intendly before the two charges towards each other.

Conner swung his Tomahawk but Shay blocks the attack with the dual blades before knocking him back.

As Shay charges forward, Conner swerved aside and he delivered a kick, knocking back Shay.

Connor throws his tomahawk at Shay.

But Shay swung his sword, deflecting the projectile.

Connor whips out two of his pistols and he opens fire at Shay, forcing the assassin to hide behind a barrel.

Shay whios out his flintlock pistols and he opems fire at Connor, pushing him back.

Connor hid behind a wall and the two continues to shoot at each other.

When the Flintlocks runs out of ammo, Shay tosses them aside before whiping out his air rifle.

Shay opens fire at Connor, forcing Connor to hide behind a wall.

Connor draws out Pitcairn-Putnam and he hesitates before launching himself out.

Connor dodges the grenade explosions as he fires at Shay.

One of the bullets grazes Shay's elbow, causing him to hiss in pain.

Connor sprints forward and he rams into Shay, throwing him down before punching him three times in the face.

Shay draws out his dagger and he slams it into Connor's side, causing him to scream in pain.

Shay kicks Connor off and he pushes himself up.

Connor pulls out the dagger and he throws it onto the ground.

He growls.

Connor: That's it! Now I'm mad.

Connor whips out his Gunstock Warclub and he got into a fighting stance.

Shay draws out his dual swords and he charges forward.

Both Shay and Connor began clashing, trading swings with each other before Connor swung his club, knocking Shay back.

Shay recovers and as Connor swung his club, he ducks underneath the attack before slashing his sword upwards, causing Connor to scream.

Shay swung his blade across Connor's hand, disarming him before delivering a kick.

But Connor quickly catches Shay by the leg and he throws him into a wall.

Shay screams as he slams backfirst into the wall.

Connor whips out an axe and he throws it at Shay.

But Shay dodges the attack before grabbing the axe and throwing it at Connor.

Connor whips out Duckfoot and he fires it at the axe, shooting it down.

Shay wipes the blood off his mouth and he complimented Connor.

Shay: Not bad. Let's see how you handle this.

Shay drops a smoke bomb onto the ground, engulfing the entire streets in smoke.

Connor drops a smoke bomb and he quickly runs into the shadows.

Connor quickly set several trip mines near a wall before running out.

As smoke engulfs the streets, one could hear the sound of punching and screaming as both men runs around the battlefield, clashing with each other.

Shay suddenly notices the trip mines and he halts in his tracks.

Just as Connor charges forward, Shay dodges and he throws a kick, causing Connor to step onto the mine.

KABOOM!!!

The mine explodes, blowing both Shay and Connor back.

The two men grunts as they pushes each other up.

Connor pushes himself up and he began using Bear Claw, punching the ground hard to enough to create shockwaves.

As Shay staggers back, Connor uses Wolf Pack, summoning three wolves.

Three wolves jumps in and they growl at Shay.

Shay whips out his air rifle and as the wolves charges, he opens fire, shooting one of them down.

Another wolf swung it's claws at Shay.

But Shay draws out his hidden blade and he swung it across the wolf's eye, causing it to roar in pain.

Shay opens fire at the wolf, killing it before facing the last one.

Shay grunts as the wolf pounces on top of him.

As the wolf bites down, Shay narrowingly dodges it's jaws before kicking the wolf off.

Shay stood up and he throws his rope dart at the wolf, causing it to howl in pain.

Shay grabs the fallen tomahawk and he throws it at the wolf, instantly killing it.

With the wolves disposed off, Shay looks around, looking for Connor.

Just where is he?

Just then, Shay felt something knock into him, causing him to look.

But to his horror, there is nobody there!

As he looks around, all of a sudden, a bird suddenly swoops down, slashing it's talon across Shay's face.

As Shay screams in pain, the bird reverts back into Connor.

Connor throws his throwing knife at Shay, causing Shay to scream in pain.

All of a sudden, Shay felt his vision blurring and his head swimming.

Confused, Shay pulls out the knife and he questions.

Shay: W...what did you do to me?

Connor answers.

Connor: You have been poisoned. The blades have been coated in highly poisonous hemlock water. You won't last long.

Angered, Shay screams out in anger and he opens fire with his air rifle.

Connor hid behind a barrel and he readies his bow and arrow, launching an arrow into Shay's shoulder.

Shay screams in pain as the arrow struck him, causing him to drop his gun.

Shay draws out his blade and he looks around.

Shay heard the sound of running and he shouts.

Shay: Come out and face me coward! Ack!

All of a sudden, Shay felt a blade stab right through his chest, causing him to cough out blood.

Connor stood behind him and he said.

Connor: It's over.

Apparently, Connor has used his Wolf cloak to sneak past Shay in order to perform his ambush.

With Shay weakened, Connor began finishing him off.

Connor whips out his Double Barrel and he fires repeated shots at Shay, killing him.

Shay screams in pain before he collapses onto the floor, dead.

Connor looks down at him and he coldly said.

Connor: I warned you.

Connor then walks away, leaving Shay's corpse lying in the streets.

As Connor left, both Deadpool and Pinkie Pie steps out and upon seeing the destruction around them, Pinkie Pie questions.

Pinkie Pie: Okay....what just happened?

KO!

The winner is

Connor Kenway

Advantages and disadvantages

Connor Kenway

More experienced

Stronger

More weapons

Not very strategic

Has never fought well trained soldiers

Shay Cormac

Smarter

More strategic

Better skills

Weaker

Has never faced the enemies Connor has faced.

Victory quote

Connor Kenway: My enemy is a notion, not a nation

Up Next

Alien X vs Beyonder