How the crap did this tom get two she cats trailing after him?

Poppyfrost
She treats him well, she's kind, and she even waited for her sister to die before taking her mate away. Everyone feels bad for her, why? Yeah, her sister and brother died, but think about what Honeyfern is going through. She said she accepted them, but we all know there's still going to be leftover feelings. I don't like her for some reason, but Honeyfern must be devastated. Although, they still make an okay couple, and I have small sympathy for her because of her feeling like a replacement, which she kinda was.
2.5 stars

Honeyfern
This she cat never got on his nerves, always loved him, appreciated him, and he did the same to her. Rumors have said that she was expecting his kits, which we never heard about in StarClan. Could someone please tell me what she saw in him? She deserved a good mate, and she got one, but then, here she goes and dies. Stop the drama, Honey. I personally ship this shipping because the simple fact that she was there first.
4.5 stars

Which sweet cat deserves this bossy furball?

Don't forget to post your arguments!!!!