Yeah....lots of mixed feelings about Fireterd.

"He was a kittypet,but he was let into the Clan,no fair!"
I can understand this,but he was let into the Clan because he could have been the cat in Spottedleaf's prophecy!

"He was made a warrior before Sandstorm and Dustpelt"
I think the explanation before this one will work.The faster he's a warrior,the faster he can do his duty.

"He was the fourth cat!"
Yep,this is why I dislike him.Erin Hunter,of all the cats you could have picked,WHY FIRESTAR!!? He already saved SkyClan and  defeated Scourge!Whhhhyyyyyyyyy!
I mean I love him,and yet I hate him at the save time!!!
Rating:7