Pika: So I am making a part two of this!

Sans: So, more of me fighting a killer?

Pika: Yeah. And more. They certainly aren't KILLING it, or you.

Pap: *comes in* PIKA DO NOT START. *Turns to the camera* PIKA DOES NOT OWN ANY OF US LIKE ME, THE GREAT PAPYRUS. NYEH HEH ENJOY THE STORY!

Both: PAPYRUS WHY ARE YOU HERE THIS IS TOO DANGEROUS FOR A CINNAMON BUN LIKE YOU!!! *gets a papyrus out of any vicinity of killers*

{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}

(Y/C/N) - Your Creepypasta Name.

(W/C) - your weapon of choice

These are random ones that will be needed in this story to know as it will pop up quite a bit.

{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}

For the next month, you would randomly attack the skeleton, trying to surprise attack him and finally END HIM. Nothing you did would work against him, however, no matter what you did. You were slowly getting more and more agitated.

"You know, you're starting to tickle a funny bone with how frustrated you keep getting when you try to kill me (Y/C/N)." Sans, aka smiley trash bag, said as he pinned you to the wall with some bones. You growled, wanting to wipe that smile off his face.

"Why the hell can't I kill you?! I haven't ever had this much trouble killing someone! Just die already you smiling trash bag!" You yelled as you threw (W/C) at him, making him teleport out of the way and dropping you. You rushed at him with your knife, slashing at his chest.

Sans simply backstepped and grabbed your wrist, twisting it in a way to cause you to drop your knife. Suddenly you were on the floor under the skeleton, making you struggle in annoyance as the skeleton's grip held firm.

"You're not going to get out. Now, I'll let you go if you promise to not attack anymore this visit. and just so you know, you're not leaving right after either." He said, grinning down at you. You growled annoyed, struggling more, just hoping to be able to get that extra inch towards your knife-.

Sans magic suddenly developed it, making the knife and (w/c) float through the air. "Don't even try it. Now, do we have a deal?" He told you, glaring at you. All the while smiling, making you more pissed off.

"Fine." You growled out annoyed at being beaten by him yet again. He seemed satisfied with that, letting you up and letting you have your weapons back. You eyed him warily, taking them, not wanting to piss him off at the moment. Once you had the chance you would strike-.

Sans suddenly summoned the skull thing again, having it watch you. "Just to make sure you don't go back on our agreement, he'll be watching you." He said offhandedly, making you slightly wonder if he could read your mind.

"Whatever smiley pants." You grumbled out, crossing your arms annoyed. He seemed satisfied as he went and sat on the couch. You eyed the floating skull thing warily as it did the same to you. What the hell even is this thing?

"Well miss killer why don't you come and sit with these lazybones?" Sans said as he patted the seat beside him. You growled lowly, turning and starting to walk to the window, not wanting to stay and be humiliated any longer. Of course, as soon as you reached the window, a blue glow surrounded you and made you float over to the couch to sit beside the smiling skeleton. You glared at him, annoyed. He only smiled wider at you. "Nuh-uh. You aren't leaving just yet. I want to ask you some stuff. I looked up your name online." He told you, making you blink a bit and snort.

"So?" You replied, glaring at him as he watched you, the floating skull hovering behind the couch, waiting for you to make a wrong move so he could blast you to bits.

"So. I want to know what a creepypasta is. That is what you are right?" He asked, making you want to laugh a bit. "All I got is that they're a bunch of stories about different killers and stuff but that doesn't make a lot of sense since I've seen several of you and the stories say you guys are make belief first off. Not to mention that you guys seem to have more abilities than what is otherwise stated in the stories and even seem to sometimes differ in appearance in some parts based on what version you read and then the real-life version. There is you, Laughing Jack who I assume is the one that tried to go after monster kid, BEN Drowned, who is the one who went through electronics, Eyeless Jack who tried to cut the kid while they slept, along with a few others I read and have seen try to attack my friends. So what are you guys?" He explained and for a moment you were kinda impressed at what he had learned just based on your Creepypasta name.

"I can't exactly just tell you unless I get to kill you after, then in which case, I gladly will." You told him with a crazed smile, making him seemingly sweatdrop and the skull thing growl at you warningly.

"You are obsessed with killing me aren't you?" He replied, making you giggle as your insanity started to take hold of you for a few moments.

"Yes! You are the reason we are having so much trouble lately. We usually have competitions on who can make the top headlines and now we can barely even get on the news anymore because it is always about monsters this, monsters that. Then whenever we try to find out what it is like to kill one of you, you always stop us!" You growled at him. Everyone was getting even more pissed off over the fact the news STILL wasn't over the arrival of the monsters to the surface, making you want to hurry and get rid of this smiling trash bag and get him out of the way for everyone.

He laughed. "Seriously?! That is why you are so obsessed with me?! Because you guys are jealous that the monsters are on the news more often than you guys now?! Damn toots I honestly thought you had a crush on me. You come to see me every other day. Sorry (Y/C/N/) I ain't into boning killers." He said with a wink, making you flush bright red in anger.

"Fuck you and your stupid puns!" You yelled, jumping up and rushing out pissed.

As you rushed away from the house, you could him laughing more, making you see red.

There were going to be quite a few bloody houses after tonight.

_TIMESKIP_

"Hey (Y/N). Where have you b-been so much l-lately?" Ticci Toby, someone who you were quite close to at the mansion, asked as you walked in covered in blood.

"Trying to destroy a smiling trash bag." You muttered, exhausted. Jane walked by at that point and looked over curiously.

"Who? Jeff?" She questioned getting the attention of said cut face killer.

"No it isn't Jeff, he's even more annoying and won't stop cracking puns and never seems to stop smiling to the point I don't even think he can. It's a freaking skeleton monster. No matter what I do I can't kill him! And every time I try it seems like he has a new trick up his sleeve and I'm getting my ass handed to me!" You growled out, falling onto the rug in front of the couch since Slenderman had a rule about getting on the couch while being bloody and you didn't want to head up to your room just yet for a shower.

Toby raised an eyebrow. "How long have you been h-hunting him? A week? Two at most r-right?" He asked, his neck cracking towards the end.

You groaned out into the rug. "A monthhhhhhhhhhhh." You could hear Jeff laughing at you, making you want to curl up into a hole and disappear.

"Jeff shut up no one wants to hear your idiotic laugh. (Y/N) have you tried having someone come with you?" Jane snapped at Jeff before looking at you, making the smiling killer glare at her. You looked at her before shaking your head.

"No. I want to get rid of him myself. The kill wouldn't be as rewarding if I had help." You answered.

"Well my child, it seems like soon you will have no choice but to have someone come with you if you are having this much trouble with a kill. You should have brought someone with you the first time you went against him, he is strong enough to withstand several of us and yet you still tried to take him on your own." Slenderman's voice rang out in your heads, making you all look at the faceless being. You hung your head in shame.

"I just wanted to get rid of the one causing everyone so much trouble lately Slender. He is extremely powerful though and always seems to have a new trick up his sleeve. Every time I think I will have the upper hand or I've learned all of his tricks, he suddenly has me pinned against the wall with his magic bone attack or his blue telekinesis abilities." You answered him ashamedly. Slender looked at you or at least seemed to.

"I know you are trying to (Y/N) I have seen your thoughts about this skeleton and his abilities. However, I do not even think I could completely fight him on my own. I was thinking about turning him into a proxy of mine at some point. He would be a very strong member." Slender admitted, making several Creepypasta, who had came into the room to find out what the commotion was about, look at the faceless being in surprise. You stared at him wide eye surprised.

"What?! There is no way that skeleton would join us! He's too concerned about protecting his precious friends from us to ever want to join us Slender!" Jeff yelled out in slight rage, shocked at what he had said as well. Slender turned to him.

"Not necessarily Jeff. Anyone could technically be persuaded if given the right circumstances. (Y/N) it is up to you to get close to the skeleton named Sans and find out about him, see what could be used to turn him into one of us. I will have others follow in case something happens whenever you do go to see him. Do not do anything that might make you suspicious to him." Slender ordered you, making you nod as you stood up. "Also, take a shower before you stain the floor. This place is hard enough to keep clean as it is without you all dirtying it up more." He added, making you blush slightly in embarrassment as several of the others laugh.

"Alright, Slender I will." You answered with a smile on your face. You weren't given many missions yet, so one that felt as important as this one made you feel important.

Slender nodded back before leaving the room as you rushed upstairs to your room to take a shower.

You had to befriend a smiling trash bag tomorrow.

_THE NEXT DAY_

You glared at Sans as he made you pinned to the ceiling, your weapons on the floor beside him. He only grinned up at you as the skull from yesterday glared up at you, annoyed that you attacked its master again.

"Well then. Nice of you to want to come to hang around again hmm (Y/C/N)?" Sans asked, making you want to do nothing more but stab your knife straight into his skull-.

No, wait you can't. You have a mission to befriend him. Slender had told you of things you could tell him to make him want to tell you more about himself. If all else failed, Slenderman himself was going to kill the skeleton as he would know way too much about them.

"Whatever. Put me down already ya smiling trash bag!" You yelled annoyed. He shrugged and complied.

Literally, as you slammed into the ground below you with a slight groan. You growled annoyed and glared at him as he was already walking to the couch. Sans turned on the tv and glanced back at you with a slightly bigger grin, patting the seat beside him. "Come on, let's talk some more. You did decide to drop in and all." He joked, making you roll your eyes but reluctantly sit beside him.

"So what questions are you going to ask me this time?" You asked annoyed, snatching the remote when offered and switching to your favorite channel. He just chuckled, leaning back and watching the tv beside you.

"Well... What caused you to become a killer?" He asked, making you freeze up a bit. He seemed to notice as he quickly decided to ask something else. "So what's your favorite color?"

You looked at him with a slight raised eyebrow. "(F/C). You?" You replied, making him smile a bit more than usual.

"Blue. Favorite food?" He shot back at you. You rolled your eyes before replying. "(F/F). Now back to you."

That is how the two of you spent the next hour, shooting back random trivial facts about yourselves to each other.

You will always deny that you were having a good time, but you will say that it is one way to stop a killer.

{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}

Pika: If you thought that I was ending it here, then you're incorrect! I just wanted to ask how your day was. Also, that I'm warning you guys now, this is going to possibly hit 4k words or somewhere close and I still think there will end up being a part three, so yeah!

{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}

_TIMESKIP_

Another month went by like this. Every time you would go to visit the skeleton, you both would grow slightly closer to each other. You eventually stopped attacking him and started to just hang out with him, telling him stories of your training and beginning days as a Creepypasta. He would tell you stories of his brother, who you had learned was named Papyrus, and stories from the time he lived in the underground. You were fascinated with some of the things he talked about, like echo flowers and how the place was cold in one area to the point of continuous snow while in another area it was so hot the heat could make you a smoked fish.

You would occasionally have a tag-a-long like Toby or Eyeless Jack, someone you were also close with at the mansion, come with you and talk with him. Jeff even came a few times.

... They instantly hit it off as the smiling duo they were, which made you dread the day the two of them and Jane were in a room together, alone or not.

Mostly however you just went by yourself to meet the smiling skeleton. Today was one of those days, though Toby wouldn't stop bugging you about going as well and ended up getting ordered by Slender to keep watch outside the house instead of getting to go inside, making the ticking boy pout the whole way there.

"Toby you knew you shouldn't have started annoying him. It is your fault." You told him as the two of you walked through the forest.

"B-But I want to see y-you and S-Sans flirting! Its f-funnier to watch close up!" He yelped out, pouting more as you stopped in your tracks, blushing, and turned to him.

"F-FLIRTING?!" You yelled blushing brightly. "We are not and never have flirted with each other! What are you even talking about Toby?!"

He blinked and grinned, his mouth guard being down while the two of you walked so you could see his grin. "You two so flirt with each other! Everyone in the mansion has noticed it, you guys like each other!~" He sing-song out the last bit, making you roll your eyes as you blushed more, walking ahead.

"We do not like each other. Maybe as friends but nothing more than that got it?!" You growled out, making Toby snicker and follow behind you.

"(Y/N) and Sans~ Sitting in a tree~ K I S S I N G!~" He sang as the two of you walked, making you groan out in annoyance.

'This is going to be a long walk.' You thought as you went ahead of the singing killer you called your friend.

He was insane for sure, you two didn't like each other more than friends.

Right?

_TIMESKIP_

The two of you arrived at the park that Sans was apparently at with some friends. He has left a note at his house to warn you of where he was, so you and Toby had switched to some normal clothes and made your way to the park.

Of course, Toby had decided that his friend, aka you, had to look nice for Sans, so he had made you dress up in an (F/C) semi-fancy dress shirt, light-colored skinny jeans capris, and black sandals. He himself was wearing a t-shirt, jeans, tennis shoes, and a patch to cover the gape on his face.

You were annoyed that you had to dress up, he even made you wax your legs before you two came! But you couldn't help but note that you DID look pretty nice.

"Toby I am starting to wonder slightly if you have been around Slender's brother Trendorman a bit too much." You commented as the two of you walked into the park, Toby had a backpack that managed to carry all of your larger weapons without suspicion, along with your normal clothes, but you did keep your knife safely secured in your capris for safekeeping later, just in case.

Spotting Sans, the two of you made your way over to him, he himself being a bit away from his group seemingly taking a breather. "Sans!" You called out, waving at him, causing the skeleton to look over and his smile widening slightly at the sight of you two. You ignored Toby's comments as you rushed over to the short skeleton, hugging him lightly with a slight smile on your face.

"Hey (Y/N). Hey Toby. How's it going? Didn't expect you to come here." Sans told you both with a smile. "My friends and brother are over there at the other playground set, I just came over here to get a drink." He motioned to the soda machine beside him at the end.

"Well, we were already heading over and made the trip so we figured we could at least come and see you here for a bit. Toby got in trouble anyways on our way out so we gotta let the boss cool down before Toby gets his butt handed to him." You replied, making Toby pout and call out your name offendedly, making a chuckle escape the skeleton's mouth.

"Well, that doesn't sound like a killer time. Might want to lay low then Tobster, wouldn't want to be in for a bad time." Sans joked, making you bite back a smile as Toby snorted. You had grown used to the puns the blue skeleton seemed to love to tell.

"SANS. WHAT IS TAKING SO LONG-?! OH HELLO HUMANS! ARE YOU FRIENDS WITH MY BROTHER?" A voice called out behind you, making both you and Toby jump to alert and swing around, being greeted with the sight of a much taller skeleton.

You scanned over what he wore. A white chest piece covered his chest, along with an orange scarf around his neck and seemingly blowing in the wind, even when there wasn't any which made you confused. For his lower half, he wore a pair of blue shorts with a pair of orange boots that went halfway up to his ankles. A pair of orange gloves rested on his hands. He had twice the height of Sans but you could recognize this as Papyrus, Sans' brother that he had told you so much about. His little brother, though it certainly didn't look like it, at all.

You quickly relaxed as Toby did the same. Sans stood between the three of you. "(Y/N), Toby, this is my brother Papyrus. Papyrus these are two of my new friends I had told you about. They had decided to take a trip to the park and we ran into each other is all." Sans explained. Papyrus seemed to look at the two of you for an analyzing moment before gasping excitedly, making the three of you confused.

"SO THIS IS THE HUMAN (Y/N) THAT I HAVE HEARD SO MUCH ABOUT! YOU HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT THEM SO MUCH I WAS WONDERING IF YOU TWO WERE DATING YET BROTHER." Papyrus gasped out excitedly, making you and Sans both blushed while Toby grinned and gave you an 'I told you so' look.

"P-Paps! We are just friends is all! Her job keeps her too busy for stuff like relationships and stuff anyways! We just occasionally hang out is all!" Sans shot back at his brother. Toby on the other hand...

"I think I l-like you Papyrus! You k-know a good ship when you s-see one! I see (Y/N) as a s-sibling and h-honestly, the two would be g-great together! If only S-SOMEONE would stop d-denying their f-feelings and actually a-admit them." Toby told the tall skeleton, turning to look at you towards the end of his sentence, making you glare at him with a blush.

"Toby we are just friends! Nothing else! Stop filling your head with stuff!" You yelled at the ticking boy, making him roll his eyes at you.

All-time seemed to stop, however, as you heard one voice you thought you would never hear again. A voice of someone you had long thought to be dead.

"(Y/N)...?" Frisk's voice called out behind Papyrus, making you look at your lost sibling in shock before flight instincts kicked in, running off from the group, much to the confusion to them and worry of your little sibling.

{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}{|}

Pika: So a little plot twist there at the end, though I feel like it was fairly obvious. This ended up being about 3700 words? That certainly is a length that I do not hit often anymore! I honestly thought I was going to write it even longer but at that point, I would probably be putting in a lot more fillers. In other news! I will try to post the third and final part along with MAYBE, big maybe here, another normal Undertale Oneshot by the end of next week! Along with that, any of you guys that enjoy Creepypasta, I do plan on having a new book comes out in the next week or two called "Their Maid" which will be a creepypasta x reader story about the reader not being quite up the standards of a normal Proxy, so Slenderman ends up making her the maid of the mansion, which will cause a lot of different things to happen along with you trying to prove that you could be an actual proxy, or at least prove that you don't deserve to be a maid cause that would be a ton of work! Anyways, until then Chow for Now! Stay Shocking! Pika!