First off, let's make sure we understand everything before we get to the story. I do NOT own Yu-Gi-Oh or any of the characters. JUST Rebeka and Natalie. This is based off of a dream I had. And in this story, the counterpart boys will be of different ages, which I will list here in a moment. (Pic above is Rebeka)(Yes I drew that)(Ignore the random dot on her cheek. That was an accident). Now I might not be able to really put their personalities into the story, but I will try my best.

Yuya = 15
Yugo = 16
Yuto = 18
Yuri = 18

Now for Beka and Nat.

Rebeka = 18 (honestly that's me in two years)
Natalie = 16

Now, both girls will get a guy, but who you ask? You'd have to wait and see!