I will detract points due to issues like cliches, plot holes, ect. If you can justify why you used a cliche (or other causes for negative points), I'll consider changing my review. That being said, please do not be rude. I acknowledge the reviews are my opinion of your story. I will not remove a review simply because it is negative or does not say what you wish it to say.

Cover 5

Grammar 10

Plot 5 (for originality)

Plot 10 (for flow, plot holes, ect)

Characters 5 (name (kinda hard to read about a character named Luna Redstar Moonmoon if it's murder, get me?), realism if applicable, ect)

Character Development 10

A total of 45 points are possible.

35 out of 45 points is an A.

25 out of 45 points is a B.

15 out of 45 points is a C.

Anything less... well, that's an F.