The Previous Night

*Trigger Warning for SA*

"What the hell are you doing, Carrie?"

The moon was barely shining through the clouds. Lily was glad Caroline called her after their argument the other day. They agreed to meet by the park, where they used to spend a lot of late nights talking after work.

But now, Lily wished to get as far away as she could from Caroline.

"I'm done with you!" Caroline was holding a knife. "You slept with my husband, you fucking whore! On my birthday!"

Lily froze. She had no idea what Caroline was talking about.

"What? I slept with Dean! Not Scott!"

"Look at this!" Caroline held her phone out for Lily to see. 

*A video was played*

They could hear Scott's voice as he was filming. Lily appeared in front of the camera. She was staggering.

"Alright, my little whore. Hop into the truck." Scott had his hand on Lily's bottom as he pushed her up into the back of Dean's truck.

"Did you like that drink I got for you? I put a little something special in it." Scott laughed.

Lily was slurring badly. "Yeah, it was yummy! Where's Carrie?"

Scott was annoyed with her mentioning his wife's name.

"She already left, remember? She had a headache."

"Oh yeah. But why am I getting in this truck? I don't wanna leave yet."

"You're not going anywhere, sweetheart."

Scott climbed into the back of Dean's truck and shut the door. He placed the phone on the dash and faced the camera toward the back seat. In the frame, Dean is shown taking Lily's clothes off. She was losing consciousness.

It didn't take long for Dean to finish violating her. He pulled his pants back up and grabbed the phone. 

*The video ended*

"What the fuck? But I woke up next to Dean! And didn't you see that Scott must have drugged me?" Lily didn't understand why Caroline was upset with her. Lily couldn't believe Scott would do that to her.

"Wait." 

*Caroline started to play another video*

Scott was filming again. This time Dean was in the frame.

"Dean! One more?" Scott shouted.

"Okay, one more, and I gotta go. I don't want Elizabeth mad at me." Dean stumbled by the bar.

Scott laughed. "Oh no, we can't have that." Scott handed Dean a drink.

"I made this special for you. You deserve it!"

"Awe, thanks, buddy!" Dean smiled and chugged it down.

Scott pulled Dean outside and whispered to him.

"I got a present waiting for you in your truck."

"Oh! What is it?" Dean could barely keep his eyes open.

"It's a surprise."

Scott had to carry Dean to his truck. Dean couldn't stand up on his own.

"Here you go, buddy." Scott laughed as he lifted Dean into the truck and shoved him in the back seat. Lily was still passed out naked.

Scott then pulled Dean's pants down.

"There. You're welcome. Maybe now you'll leave that bitch and be my friend again."

*The video ended.*

"Oh my god, Caroline! Can't you see what Scott did? They were both wearing the same red flannel shirt! I couldn't tell who was who. I was drugged! You can't blame me for this!"

Caroline was furious. "This all started at that Christmas party! You shoved your tongue down my husband's throat! He's been wanting to fuck you since then! Then you try to steal Dean and stick a baby on him! Why would you think Dean would ever sleep with a whore like you? He never even slept with me!"

Caroline started to cry.

"What are you talking about, Carrie?" Lily slowly reached for the knife in Caroline's hand.

Caroline snapped up. "Stop calling me fucking Carrie!"

Caroline screamed and lunged forward with the knife. It slid into Lily's belly like butter. That was a lot easier to do than Caroline thought.

Lily was beyond shocked. She looked down at the knife and couldn't believe how far the blade was inside her. She collapsed as Caroline took the knife out.

Caroline was filled with rage and adrenaline. She ran to her car and sped off as she saw Lily's body lying on the ground. She pulled up to Dean and Elizabeth's house a little later.

Caroline grinned as she realized Elizabeth was home alone. She knocked on their door with the memory stick in her pocket and a knife behind her back.