There's horror music and a wolf howls on the TV. "Hello? Anyone there?" Billy asked. The movie shows an abandoned donut factory on a dark and stormy night. "I don't like it Billy, I was excited when you won those all-access passes to this donut factory. But now that we're here, it seems to be completely abandoned." Maria said. "Shh, you're right, something's fishy. There's not a donut in this place." Billy said.

"Everything's going to be fine, Billy." (Y/n) said jokingly, and her friends snicker. "Uhh, if there are no donuts, why do I smell...frosting?" Maria asked. A man in a donut suit appeared behind them. "Aaahh!" The donut slices the screen and it shows the title of the movie, Donut Factory Holiday; (Y/n), Mordercai, Muscle Man, Hi Five Ghost and Rigby all cheer together. "Donut Factory Holiday!" Mordercai said. "Best worst movie ever!" Rigby said. "Definitely." (Y/n) said. Benson comes to the scene and sighs.

"Again? Why do you guys make such a big deal about this movie? You've seen it a thousand times, it's terrible!" Benson said. "Dude, we know, that's why it's funny." (Y/n) said. "Yeah! It's kind of like that solo album you recorded last year if people have liked it." Rigby said. "And Benson For All was criminally misunderstood!" Benson leaves, and the movie scene shows that Maria and Billy are now in a sewer. "Billy, are you sure this sewer is the only way out?" Maria asked.

"If you can't think of a better way to escape an evil donut, I'd like to hear it. Wait! Look out! Sewer gator." The movie shows a bird landing on the crocodile's open mouth. "Pfffft!" Mordecai said. Back in the movie, a man in an alligator suit walks upright towards Maria. "Aahh.. .Ahhh... ahh... ahh... ahh... ahh." She screamed. "Oh now? He arrhhhgg!" Donuts are being thrown at the TV while Muscle Man and High-Five Ghost are laughing, and then Muscle Man eats a Donut.

"Mr. President, Sir. Prototype 58 has escaped." An officer said. "Great Scott. This is what we get for playing... uh... line?" The screen then shows a donut in the city with his hands up while they hear automatic gunfire. (Y/n), Mordecai, Rigby, Muscle Man and High-Five Ghost laugh. "Why does he get huge for that one scene?" Rigby asked. The screen then shows a man whistling and putting a bin down by the curb. "Shh! Here comes the best part!" (Y/n) said. "Reduce! Reuse! Re-est in Peace!" The donut grabs a bazooka. "What? No!" The donut then shoots a rocket at the man. Then it moves slowly as it is being held by a piece of black string.

As soon as it touches the man, he explodes, along with the rocket. "I don't know how but it keeps getting better every time!" Rigby said. "I read somewhere that the guy in the Donut Suit is the director because he runs out of money to pay the actors." Fives said. "I heard the crocodiles in the swamp scene were four iguanas taped together." Muscle Man said. "Wasn't that just a guy in a suit?" Rigby asked.

"Uh, your thinking of the alligator scene. You got to brush on your taxonomy, bro." Muscle Man said. "Well, we find out for sure next time we rent it. We should get back to the store though. There's probably people waiting for it." Mordecai said. "Ugh! That stupid waiting list. I miss when we were the only people who knew about this." (Y/n) said. "It's due back at the video store by five o'clock. That gives us half-an-hour." Fives said.

"Plenty of time. All we got to do is eject this puppy, hop in the cart, cruise over to the... I said eject this puppy." Rigby presses the eject button and then turns his head around. "Guys, the tape is stuck." He said. "No, it isn't. Let me get it out." (Y/n) opens the tape inserter and tries to pull out the tape. "Yeah, it's stuck." She said. "Bros, I can't afford a late fee." Muscle Man said. "Okay, okay. We've got this. All we've gotta do is find some way to pull out that tape and as long as we do within the next..."

Mordecai points at High-Five Ghost to check the time. "28-minutes." Fives said. "We can return it to the store and bam! No late fee." (Y/n) said. "Sounds good." Rigby said. "Let's do that." Muscle Man said. In the kitchen, (Y/n), Mordecai, Rigby, Muscle Man and High Five Ghost are waiting for Skips to arrive. Skips later arrives. "I've got my tools. What's the emergency?" He asked. "Donut Factory Holiday is stuck in the VCR." Mordecai said.

Skips skips away. "Damn Skips." (Y/n) mumbled. "Now what?" Rigby asked. "Can you use your powers to get it out, (Y/n)?" Rigby asked, and she sighs. "I told you Rigby, I'm still learning how to use them right now. I can only use them on command sometimes and even then they'll spiral out of control." (Y/n) said. "Oh, like that time you almost killed me with a tree?" Muscle Man asked. "What?" Fives asked in slight panic, and (Y/n) sighs and face palms. "You scared me dude, that was your fault." (Y/n) said. "Let me try something." Mordecai shakes and knocks the VCR three times and looks into it to see if the movie has come out. "It's never gonna come out." He said.

"I can try my family's technique." Fives floats to the tape. "You're right. Mordecai's right! The tape's a goner!" He shouted. "I've got this." Muscle Man shakes the VCR. "WHOO! WHOO-OO-OO!" (Y/n) snatches the tape from Muscle Man's hands. "STOP! You'll break the tape! The video is impossible to replace!" She shouted. "No one has ever complained about my techniques before." Muscle Man said. "Guys, guys, calm down. I'll just reach in and get it out. Just like how for prizes I reach out of the cereal box." Rigby puts his hand in the VCR. "He-he. My arm's not coming out. MY ARM'S NOT COMING OUT!" He shouted. "I got ya, I got ya." (Y/n) tries pulling Rigby out rather roughly. "OW, OW! OWWW! (Y/N) STOP! STOP THAT HURTS!"

Rigby shouted, and she quickly stops pulling. "Sorry Rigby!" She said, and he sighs. "I've got this." Muscle Man grabs the VCR and throws it, along with Rigby, onto the kitchen floor. "We've gotta do something bros." He said. At the VHS (Very Happy Service) store, the phone rings. "V.H.S. the home of Very Happy Service, how may I help you?" A VHS employee asked. "Oh, hi. Is there is a grace period for returning Donut Factory Holiday late due to..." (Y/n) looks at Rigby. "Unavoidable VCR mishaps." She said. "You need to have the tape on time or you'll have to pay the fee." The employee said. "Which is?..." (Y/n) said. "Same as the budget of the movie. Two. Hundred. Dollars." They replied.

"What?! Nobody can afford that." (Y/n) covers the phone with her paw. "Guys, the fine is like two-hundred bucks." She said. "Also, there are some people waiting for it, but they don't really care." The employee said. "Donuts are forever." A fan said. "You have seventeen minutes to get it back here." The employee hangs up. "We need to get that tape out now." (Y/n) said. Rigby groans, lying on the floor with the VHS player stuck in his paw. "We should also get some serious help." Mordecai said. Later at the coffee shop, Eileen is watering a plant named Tumurra. "Ooh, you're getting big there, Tumurra." She said. "EILEEN!" (Y/n) shouted.

"Guys? What's going on?" She asked. "Rigby needs your help. No time to explain!" Muscle Man said. "What?! Is he hurt or what happ- Oh. Steffan!" She called. "Yes, Ma'am?" He asked. "Warm up a tub of butter from the pantry stat!" Elieen said. "On it." He said. "Lay him down on the table." (Y/n) and Mordecai put Rigby down on the nearest table, while Rigby is groaning. "Hey, buddy. How are you holding up?" Elieen asked. Rigby weakly coughs. "Eileen. It's pretty much over for me. I'm so glad I got to see you... before... the end." Rigby said. "Rigby, you know you're not." (Y/n) said. "I'm gonna miss your face. Your (E/c) eyes, your small bun, From now on, I'll be known as "Old Man VHS Hand". Rigby said to (Y/n). "That's creepy." She said.

"Here's your butter, ma'am." Steffan said. "Don't worry Rigby. We're gonna get you out of here." Eileen pours the butter into the VHS. "Well? Can you get it out?" (Y/n) asked, and he tries to get it out. "No. Now it's stuck and it's making me feel weird." He said. "There's no time, bro. We're out of options. We have to go nuclear." Muscle Man said. Rigby whimpers. "(Y/n)?" He asked. "I don't know. It could work." Muscle Man grabs a hammer and then uses his arms to grasp it and smash the VCR

Rigby screams as soon as he goes near the VCR. Suddenly, Mordecai grabs the hammer in order to stop Muscle Man from smashing the VCR. "Wait? Huh?" Rigby asked. "Don't smash it. I didn't wanna have the resort to this... but... we have to go to the VCR Repair Shop." Mordecai said. "Woah, dude. You don't have to do it for me. It might be easier just to break my arm." Rigby said. "Let's just do it. Maybe he won't be creepy this time." (Y/n) said. (Y/n) and Mordecai pick up Rigby and run out towards the door while he is groaning. "Have you just tried letting go of the tape or - ?" Elieen asked, and the group ran out the door. At the VCR Repair Shop, the trio, along with Muscle Man and HFG, walk into the store.

"Lazy Dave?" Mordecai asked. "Mordecai? Did your mom come with you?" He asked. "No, just me and my buddies." He replied. "Ah, dang. Still? Did you know Mordecai's mom and I used to date. Until that fateful night, when the rain started to fall and..." he stares at the VCR. "Uh oh. A Rewind King X2. This thing is unbreakable." Lazy Dave said. " Can you just try to get it out?" (Y/n) asked. "Only if you put in a good word with your mom for me." Lazy Dave said to Mordecai. "Ugh, creep." (Y/n) said. "No." Mordecai said. "Fine. We'll start off by popping the face off the VCR." Dave grabs a screwdriver to remove the case, but during the process, the screwdriver snaps in two. "You sure your mom's still married?" Mordecai groans. "Wait! We don't have to get the tape out. I know how we can get the store on a technicality."

Muscle Man said. Later they're at the VCR Repair shop. "Here you go. One tape as agreed upon. And I believe nowhere in the contract does it state that the tape has to be watchable." Muscle Man said. "It's the first line!" The employee shows the contract, where it says "I must return the tape in a watchable condition," along with some signatures made by (Y/n), Mordecai, Rigby, Muscle Man and High Five Ghost. "And you can't return a tape stuck in a VCR.

It also has a dude's arm in it!" He said. "Actually, I've been waiting for so long, I don't mind if there is an arm stuck to it." The fan from before said. "The customer gets what the customer wants. Wait here until I get the arm removal shears." The employee looks for the arm removal shears. "Where did the shears go?" He asked. "Let's get out of here." The group backs away quickly from the counter while the VHS employee finds the shears. "Here they are. Wait. We've got runners!" He shouted. There's a sign for a person named Tape Hunter. Coming out of a hiding hole,

The Tape Hunter stands there with his hands by his shoulders. "The customer is always responsible for all lost and damaged tapes." The Tape Hunter gets onto a bike called "My Friend, the Motorbike" "Yay! Tape Hunter." A second donut fan said. "We're never going back to that store." Rigby said.  The front of the store is blown up by Tape Hunter's grenade. "I'm coming for that tape." He grabs a gun. "Step on it, bros!" Mordecai drives the car at a super fast speed, along with Tape Hunter on his motorbike.

"The video store has its own bounty hunter?" (Y/n) asked. The Bounty Hunter drives his motorbike. He eventually drives over to the left-hand side of the golf cart. "Give me the tape and no one gets hurt!" He shouted. "Dude, we want to give you the tape!" Rigby shouted. The Bounty Hunter grabs his gun and tries to shoot the side of the golf cart. Mordecai swerves the golf cart to another part of the road. Mordecai and Tape Hunter find themselves on different sides of the road. "What now?" Mordecai asked. "Step on it!" (Y/n) shouted. Mordecai drives the cart, along with Tape Hunter on his motorbike. "What's the plan, Rigby?" Mordecai asked.

"Stay on target!" The bounty hunter uses his gun to shoot the group in the cart. Rigby stands up and prevents that from happening by using the VCR as a shield. The laser eventually hits the front wheel of the motorbike. "Argh! A Rewind King X2?! Try blocking this!" The Tape Hunter throws a grenade, which turns out to be a dumb idea as Rigby uses the VCR once again as a shield. The grenade hits the motorbike, exploding, leaving Tape Hunter flying in the air and falling into a garbage bin. "Reduce, reuse, re-" Rigby said. "TREE!!!" (Y/n) shouted.  Everyone in the golf cart screams as they hit the tree. The VCR comes flying out of Rigby's hand and smashes into a nearby wall.

"There's no way the tape survived that. Maybe we can pay for the tape on a plan fee." (Y/n) said. "Argh! I knew I should've never put my hand in the VCR!" Rigby hits himself with the tape, which he doesn't notice. "Stupid! Stupid!" He scolded. "Bro, the tape!" Muscle Man said. Rigby laughs and then kisses the tape. "Mmm... Buttery." He said. Later they're back at the V.H.S. store. "Well, you win some and you lose some. You did blow up our staff bounty hunter, but you did return Donut Factory Holiday on time. Let's call it square. Normally, I would have to pay you a tape washing fee because... the thing's... covered in butter but those guys don't mind so whatever."

The employee said. "We're even happier this way. Actually, we are huge butter fans." Donut Fan #3 pulls his shirt up showing us a layer with an image of butter. "Well, I'm ready to go." Mordecai said. "WAIT!" Rigby said. They see a tape for the movie Donut Factory Holiday: Spring Break. "Movie night!" The five friends shouted. "DFH! DHF! DFH DFH! DF-" (Y/n) walks up to the TV to play the movie, but doesn't notice that there is no VCR. When (Y/n) thinks she put it in the VCR, the tape falls onto the table. "Oh, yeah. We smashed the VCR." She said.