Judge 1: iamzaffa

1. The Terror by SuryanshDubey
2. Isaiah's Story by SethAMott
3. Selling My Soul to the Devil by grudgeme
4. I Spit On Your Grave by grudgeme
5. Dove Maxi by SAFern24

Judge 2: grudgeme

1. Not All Boys Are the Same by iamzaffa
2. The Last Philosopher by NickfEast
3. In Love With a Wildflower by lilistalls
4. All She's Ever Wanted by lucid_epiphanies
5. Dead End by --Everleigh--

Judge 3: SAFern24

1. My Hot Bodyguard by Victorie5802gal
2. Maybe Just Maybe by @-WordAddict
3. The Kiss List by @WriterKidWhiz
4. The Love Untold by DDibashini1999
5. Heart Beats by DDibashini1999

Judge 4: @-WordAddict

1. Alina Nivar: The Moonstone by MarteenaRV
2. Loving You, Always by Selly1010
3. Sakura Eyes by naeomiiii
4. Mirror by ur_favouritexx
5. Zanilla by heartofemotion

Judge 5: MarteenaRV

1. My Best Friend/Husband by @ElaidaMaria
2. Silence by urfavouritexx
3. Who is She by Tanziaprapty
4. The Sea Thief by ray_of_sunshine9
5. No Sanctuary - A Sims 4 Story by simsfan478 (nobody objected)