THANK YOU FOR @CEJWNCJ for this idea!

PONYBOY:

You were still angered that Ponyboy said that to you. He told you not to even try to be because you never will be.

You walked into class one day and saw Ponyboy looked really glum. You didn't want to feel bad for him, but he looked really sad.
Being the better person, you walked up to him.

"Hey, what's wrong?" You asked. He looked up at you.

"Why are you asking?" He asked a little confused. "Because, you look down. So what's wrong?"

"Nothing, ok? Just drop it." You decided to keep pushing.

"No, tell me what's wrong?" He looked suprised.

"My girlfriend dumped me because she thought I was ugly. Now I know how I felt when I told you that, and I'm sorry."  He actually sounded like he meant it. 

"It's ok, Ponyboy," You smiled. "I forgive you." His eyes widened. "You do." You nodded. "Yes, God tells us to forgive so I forgive you." He smiled at that.

"Thanks, Y/N."

SODAPOP:

You took his advice and spent some money on some makeup. Not for his advice, but for your own self. You wanted him to see what you looked like in makeup so you could figure out his character.

You walked into the DX and when he looked like he didn't expect you to take his stupid advice.

"Hey, pretty boy, just want a Pepsi and some cancer sticks." You smiled. "Uh ok." He went and got your items.

"So uh, you look really good with makeup on."

"Look, you told me to use my money on makeup and now I did. I think I look just fine without it. I don't need someone like you to tell me how to be pretty. I may not be pretty on the outside, but I damn sure am on the inside. Maybe you should get to know more girls then just look at their faces. That's a tip. You gave me advice, so now I'm giving you advice. Take it or leave it. I don't care".

He looked at you in awe. Most girls don't have the nerve to say something like to him because they're too lovestruck by his looks. You saw right through it.

The next day at school, Soda picked up his brother Ponyboy and you walked home while he drove home. He saw you and rolled down his window.

"Hey, I'm sorry Y/N. I took your advice and I want to be a better person."

DARRY:

You avoided Darry ever since that time he told you all you did was slow down the business. You hated him.

A few weeks went by, and you did a ton of work. You worked on at least 50 houses in one week. That was something no one has ever done there. You were pretty proud of yourself.

You all had a meeting and Darry was there. He kept looking at you but in more of an interested way.

"Alright, I've called you all here today to congratulate  all of you on your hard work.
I especially want to congratulate Y/N Y/L/N for completing the most houses this week."

Everyone clapped for you and you smiled.
Even Darry clapped.

"Hey, Y/N, I guess I underestimated you. I'm sorry. You really are a hard worker." He smiled at you.

"Thank you, Darry. I appreciate that. You aren't too bad yourself."

TWO-BIT:

You went to the Drive-In and inwardly scowled when Two-Bit walked over to one of the seats with his friends.

The movie was kinda funny and you were laughing. All of the sudden you look to your right and saw Two-Bit. You gave him a dirty look.

"Hey, look, I'm sorry for telling you were ugly last time I saw you. That smile I just saw proved otherwised."

"I guess I can't be mad at you. Girl can't hold a grudge forever." You giggled.

JOHNNY:

You were still completely shocked that Johnny would say that to you. You couldn't figure out why he said that to you.

You decided to take the same way you used to since you haven't seen him in a while.

Well, you went and saw him alone by a stop sign. He ran up to you and stopped you.

"Hey, look I'm sorry for calling you ugly, Dallas kinda told me to say that to you."

"I knew you wouldn't say that for no reason."
You said. "But don't do what he says, ok?"

STEVE:

You went to the Dingo again. You went there with your friends. They were the same ones you went with when you encountered Steve.

You got up to get more water. You walked back to your table to hear Darry whispering something.

"Now you go apologize to her right now."" He scolded someone. Then you heard footsteps.

"Hey, uh. I'm Steve and um," He was stuttering like crazy. "I just wanted to apologize for calling you ugly and whatever and so does the rest of the gang." He smiled sadly.

You were suprised.

"Well, let this be a lesson in the future. Calling others ugly makes you look ugly." You put youe hand on his shoulder and hung out a bit.

DALLAS:

You grew a profound hatred for Dallas. He called you an ugly bitch and that was suppose to make him happy?

You were walking towards the Drive-In, when you saw somebody following you.

"Dallas, what the hell do you want?" You glared at him. He suprisingly looked taken aback.

"I'm sorry, it's just, do you remember me calling you ugly?" You scoffed. That had to be the dumbest question ever.

"How could I not?" You stared at him.

"I'm sorry! Ok? I never apologized to a girl before but I'm sorry!"

"Yeah, whatever," You tried to walk away, but he grabbed your arm and slammed his lipsnon yours. You tried to pull away but you couldn't.

"I thought I was ugly."

"If you were ugly would I do that?"