A/N: The song Y/N sings in the story is included above. 

~~~~~~

 It's a beautiful evening when you go over to the Mystic Grill. There's some kind of karaoke night going on tonight, and everyone seems to be going, so you decide to go. Maybe you'll even get a song in yourself, you think. 

 A few faces there don't surprise you. Alaric Saltzman, a teacher from the high school, is often at the Mystic Grill. Jeremy Gilbert, Matt Donovan and Tyler Lockwood are all there as well, so you spend a little time talking to each one of them. 

 Soon, you hear a voice you recognize say, "Hello there, Y/N. Fancy meeting you here tonight." 

 You turn around. "Enzo. I didn't think karaoke night would be your kind of thing." 

 "I hadn't thought so either," he answers. "But I thought you might be here, and decided to stop by. From the looks of it, I was right." 

 You smile, and are about to say something else when the two of you are greeted by Damon Salvatore. 

"Nice to see you, Y/N," Damon says to you. "Enzo. I wouldn't have thought you would be here for karaoke night." 

 "I would have thought the same thing about you," Enzo replies. "You must have some other reason for being here tonight." 

 "Don't worry about that." Stefan Salvatore, Damon's younger brother comes up behind him. "If he is up to something, I'll be keeping an eye on him." He gives you a smile. "Hi, Y/N." 

 "Hey, Stefan. Why don't we all just find somewhere to sit down?" you suggest. "We can relax and enjoy karaoke night." 

 As soon as the four of you sit down together, someone else enters the Mystic Grill: Klaus Mikaelson, the last person you would have expected to show up for karaoke night. 

 "Y/N!" He walks over to your table and gives you a charming smile. "So nice to see you." 

 "What are you doing here?" Damon asks him. "I doubt anyone invited you to show up, or any of your relatives." 

 "Well, it's not an 'invite only' event, Damon," Klaus points out. "Everyone's welcome." 

 Looking past Klaus, you see that his brothers Elijah and Kol are also with him. 

 "Hi, you two," you say to them. "What are you doing here?" 

 "Just here to look around and have some fun," Kol answers, giving you a wink. 

 "And it seems I'll have to keep an eye on both my younger brothers." Elijah sounds a bit annoyed, but he gives you a kind smile. 

 "Why don't you go up and sing something, Y/N?" Damon suggests. "You've got some vocal talent." 

 "Do you?" Klaus asks you. "Well, I think you would certainly make this event a little more interesting." 

 It is true that you do sing sometimes. You don't think your voice is too outstanding, but you're not afraid to go up on stage and sing a song. 

 "Okay." You stand up. "I'll be back in a few minutes." 

 You decide to sing the song "All Tonight" by Midnight Memories. You feel confident while up there singing, despite the intense stares from all the men you've spoken to tonight. When the song is over, you're greeted by applause and cheers. 

 As you walk back to your table, you pass Alaric, who lifts his glass and says, "Great job." 

 "Thanks, Alaric," you say. 

 You're then greeted first by Jeremy, then Matt, and then Tyler, who all tell you how great you sang. You smile and thank them all. 

 "You were excellent, Y/N," Elijah says to you. He takes your hand and kisses the top of it. "Well done." 

 "I agree," says Kol. "Well done, indeed." 

 "Well, thank you, both of you," you say. "But I think I'll go sit down." 

 Klaus is now sitting at the table with Stefan, Damon and Enzo, and it looks like there's been an intense conversation going on. You don't even have to ask to know that it must be about you. 

 "You were perfect on that stage, Y/N," Klaus says as soon as he sees you, immediately switching to that smile of his. 

 "Yeah, you were great," says Damon, keeping his eyes on Klaus. "Why don't you join us?" 

 "Um...you know what, I'm going to the ladies' room," you say quickly. "I'll be back, I guess." 

 You use that excuse to make your way to the bathroom as fast as you can and quickly shut the door behind you. You know they all like you, and they've all been in pursuit in a relationship with you. You don't want to have to choose just one of them, but you know you might have to eventually. You just wonder who you would end up with in the end.