"Congratulations."

Everyone turned around quickly, tensing when they saw Kirstie standing there. Genevieve stood behind her, hiding herself from the others. Kirstie had a big smile on her face, one that was indescribably evil. Genevieve, however, looked...

Guilty?

"You found it out," Kirstie told them, walking into the room. She smirked at her band, shaking her head. "You now know that I am the one who did. Happy ending for all while the murderer and the accomplice are arrested. That's how every mystery story ends. Only this time, I'm the writer and I'm changing everything around."

"Why did you kill everyone we loved?" Scott hissed, standing in front of Mitch. Genevieve was about to answer but closed her mouth from saying something wrong. Kirstie laughed as she stood behind the police officer, shaking her head.

"Jealously, of course. I was jealous that Avi didn't love me so I killed Esther and Darien."

"Then why did you try to kill me?" Mitch asked, try to figure everything out. Kirstie looked at him, angry brewing throughout her body.

"Because the day you told me you were gay and broke up with me was the day I plotted revenge on you. I just did it now so all of you will suffer at the same time."

"How dare you?" Scott hissed, pushing Kirstie back. "Why did you kill Alex?!"

"Same reason I almost killed Mitch. You just broke up with me one day because you decided that I wasn't good enough. It only made things worse when you two decided to stop hanging out with me and with each other."

"Why did you kill Esther?" Avi practically growled, glaring at Kirstie. She laughed hysterically, scaring everyone in the room. "Why Darien?"

"Like I said, jealously. I told Esther how I felt about you having an attraction towards Kevin and she did nothing. She told me to give up, that he did not love me and there was no way he ever will. I decided then that she didn't deserve to live."

"How about Darien?! What did he do?!"

"He told me to get over my schoolgirl crush," Kirstie admitted, her eyes widening a bit. She wrapped an arm around Genevieve, laughing more. "Gen here was the only one who wanted me to love Avi and get with him. It was then when we decided to kill everyone who hurt us.

"We had a list an everything. We killed the bus drivers because they would have had been suspicious. Here, I have the list. Read it."

Kevin took the piece of paper and read through it, widening his eyes. He couldn't believe all the names on there!

Esther

Alex

Darien

Mitch

"Why are there only four people? Why isn't Scott on here if he hurt you too?"

"Because all of these people stole something from me that I wanted or they said I should just give up because nobody will love me," Kirstie answered, laughing still. She looked at Genevieve and snapped her fingers, her eyes full of evil. "Gen, you know what to do."

Genevieve sighed as she took a gun on of her bag, causing everyone to gasp. The police officer stood up, hoping to get the gun from the accomplice.

"Put it down so no would get hu-"

BANG

The police officer fell on the ground, the bullet going into her chest. Mitch screamed, relieving the moment in the bedroom while Scott thought back to Alex being shot. Kirstie shook her head, laughing once more as she watched Genevieve go back to her bag and take out a bat.

"Sweet dreams."

In that moment, all Kevin saw was Avi being hit with a bat and darkness met him immediately.

~~~

"Scott? Mitch? Avi? Kevin? Jake? Oh my gosh, you guys are okay. I thought you all died!"

Avi woke up, hissing at the pain in his head. He sat to find Jeremy siting in front of him, worry encased on his face. Avi looked around to find his boyfriend, band members, and Jake all passed with blood trickling down their temples. Avi gasped as he went to wake them up, but the pain in his head prevented him from doing so.

"Where are we?" Avi asked Jeremy, his voice shaking. The tall male shrugged his shoulders, not knowing where he was either. "How long have you been here?"

"I don't know. Oh, Mitch is waking up!"

Avi turned quickly, watching Mitch wake up. The tenor rubbed his eyes, hissing at the pain radiating from his head. He widened his eyes when he saw Jeremy in front of him, wanting to get away from him as far as possible.

"Stay away from me!"

"Mitch," Jeremy whispered, shaking his head. Mitch nodded, a fearful tear running down his face. "I did not want to pull that prank on you. Kirstie made me do it."

"Why would she do that?"

"I don't know. That's what I want to find out."

One by one, the others woke up. Scott almost beat Jeremy up, but Mitch stooped him. Jeremy might have some evidence with him.

"Did Kirstie seem weird to you before all of this happened?"

"She was starting to develop a weird attraction towards Avi again. I'm not even kidding. She had a lock of his hair, a shirt of his, a beanie, pretty much anything you could think of. She was obsessed with him."

"Why does she like me so much?" Avi wondered out loud, shaking his head. Kirstie barely explained in the hospital so he was without a doubt confused. "She knew from the beginning it would never work between us."

"What I don't get is why she didn't have me, Avi, or Scott on the list but Mitch was. He never hurt her and from what I heard, the breakup was good between them."

"I knew I should've never broken up with her," Mitch murmured, shaking his head. He bit his lip from crying suddenly, looking up at Scott. "Why did I ever do that?"

"You were figuring yourself out at a young age and that's okay. You should not have to feel guilty for being who you are. Kirstie can't do that to you."

The door opened, showing Genevieve. She still had the same facial expression from earlier as she sat down in front of everybody, their glares watching her every move. She sighed once and looked at lap, trying to figure out what to say. She bit her lip, revealing what she wasn't supposed to say. Kirstie told her specifically not to, but it happened anyway.

"I have a lot to tell you. Kirstie will kill me if I say it, but I deserve it. You guys deserve to know the truth."

"Tell us then," Jake commanded quietly, trying to get the look of Gen's face in the car. "Tell us what happened!"

"Okay...here goes."

A/N: This has two to three more chapters and all will be over! What do you think Genevieve has to say about the murders? Anyways, I hope that you all enjoyed the chapter and remember that I love you all.:)

-Maddie🐧🐧🐧