It was Sunset Shimmer. She had a sly smile on her face. Fluttershy was clearly frightened. "S...Sunset?" Was all Twilight was able to say. "What are we doing here?" Twilight continued. Sunset giggled before answering. "I'm here to study friendship,". Everypony gasped. "Wh...what do you mean? What are you gonna do to us? I thought we were friends," Twilight started freaking out. She seemed to be panicking , but she wasn't the only one. Poor Fluttershy looked like she was gonna faint in any moment. The room was silent but it was broken by Rainbow who had had enough. "Just answer us!!!"she screamed. "I wasn't! It was all just fake!" She screamed back with a blank face.

Suddenly, her sly smile returned. "But you've gotta admit I was good at acting," she chuckled. "It was all fake...?" the purple skinned girl's heart seemed to have broken into a million pieces. "How could you!? After all that we did for you..." Rarity sobbed. "But what about what happened at the friendship games and at Camp Everfree...that couldn't have been acting," Rainbow said. "Well...I'm not sure how that happened but ...I've got to tell you ...I really did fall for your friendship...but I kept telling myself that if I keep track with my plan, I'll have something far more better than friendship,"she responded.

"W...what are y...you go...gonna do...do to us?" Fluttershy asked. She laughed. "You'll see," and with that she left the room. The room was once again dark and cold. Everypony stared at each other.

"Wh...what are w...we go...gonna do?" Fluttershy looked at Twilight who could barely even move. "I...I dont know," she murmured. Her words were lost in the cold wind. "Wh...what was that, darling?" Rarity asked. "I DON'T KNOW!!!" She screamed.

The room was silent. No one dared to say anything. They all just stared at the stressed girl who was trying to think of something. "Why don't we just try to get out of here," the rainbow haired girl pointed to the door. "Good idea, Dashie," Pinkie smiled. Despite everything, Pinkie still had her happy and bubbly personality. Rainbow, AJ and Pinkie headed to the front door as Fluttershy and Rarity comforted her friend, Twilight.

"Do ya think ya can kick the door down, Rainbow?" AJ asked, sounding concerned. "Don't worry this is gonna be easy!" she said before kicking the locked door multiple times. She was having a hard time. "You can do this, Dashie!" Pinkie cheered. Rainbow began sweating after a few minutes had passed by.

"It's not gonna work," Twilight said without even facing them.
"Wait...Just give me a few more tries-" Rainbow started but was cut off by Twilight. "This place has magic all over it. I can sense it,". "But how did she get-" Pinkie asked but stopped when Twilight looked at her. "I don't know,". "Can't you just use your magic?" Rainbow asked. "Its not gonna be that easy and I doubt I can," she said standing up. "We...we're gonna die here..." Twilight sobbed before she unleashed a loud cry. "She's...she's gonna trap us here and we'll starve to death or maybe she'll feed us but we'll be stuck here forever. She might even add some fun by killing us gruesomely. Then she'll go back to Ponyville and say that something bad happened to us. I'm not sure what she's gonna do next but it's not gonna be good," she hyperventilated and got on the ground again covering her face.

Everyone looked down, thinking of what Twilight said. "Well then, we can't give up. Ah know ah won't. Not even a tad little bit. Sunset better know what's coming for her," AJ helped Twilight up. "You're right," she smiled gently. "So, do ya have a plan?" The country girl grinned. "Y...yes," Twilight wiped of her tears. "I'm thinking we should go find Sunset Shimmer and put...put an end to her," she looked down as if she was upset.

"So, let's split up and since we all have our cellphones, we can call each other if there's trouble or if you found Sunset. Remember, do not interact with Sunset if we're all not together there. I think we should go in pairs since it's more safer that way," she said. "I wanna go with Dashie!" Pinkie smiled grabbing Rainbow's arm. Twilight looked at Fluttershy, who still seemed to be crying. "Who would you like to go with, Fluttershy?". "I would like to go with you, if you don't mind," she sobbed. "Sure!". "So that's settled, AJ, you and Rarity head there, Rainbow, you and Pinkie head over there and me and Fluttershy head here," she pointed to multiple places.

That's where it all started. That's where their nightmare came to life.