Seth woke up the next morning to the sound of glass shattering. He jumped out of bed and stormed into the bathroom to find Dean staring into a broken bathroom mirror.

"Dean." Seth said as he observed his bloody fist.

Dean looked up at Seth with tears in his eyes.

"Come here, man." Seth said as he wrapped his arms around him.

"I really fucked up this time." Dean cried.

"It's going to be okay. Whatever it is, it's going to be okay." Seth said as he held Dean.

Roman was passed out in his bed when he heard someone unlock the front door. He was too hungover to move so he just waited, hoping to god it wasn't an intruder.

"Roman?" Aj yelled through the house.

"Aj?" Roman mumbled.

She searched the house for several minutes until she finally reached his room.

"There you are." Aj said.

"What are you doing here?" Roman asked.

"Sasha put me on babysitting duty for the day." Aj said.

"I don't need a babysitter." Roman said.

"Get out of bed." Aj said.

"What?" Roman asked.

Before Roman new it, Aj had pulled the blankets out from underneath him and dragged him onto the floor.

"What the hell?" Roman asked.

"I said get your ass up." Aj said.

"Okay, okay. I'm getting up." Roman said as he stumbled to his feet.

"I brought coffee and donuts." Aj said as he followed her into the kitchen.

Roman looked at Aj in confusion as he looked at the coffee.

"It's coffee, you drink it." Aj said.

"How do I know there isn't like poison in here or something." Roman joked.

"You don't." Aj said seriously.

The smile quickly faded from Roman's face as she smiled back at him. Instead, he reached for a donut.

"On second thought, I think I'm just going to jump in the shower." Roman said.

Aj took a sip of her coffee as Roman walked into the bathroom.

Back at Seth's loft, Dean was still trying to calm down after the incident that morning.

"Here, put this on your hand." Seth said as he handed Dean an ice pack and joined him on the couch.

"So what happened?" Seth asked.

"You have to promise you won't punch me." Dean said.

"Why would I do that?" Seth asked.

"Because I slept with Mandy." Dean said.

"What do you mean you slept with Mandy?" Seth asked.

"The night I left town.." Dean said.

"You didn't." Seth said.

"I knew it was a bad idea but I was hurt and angry and I just didn't give a shit." Dean said.

"Fuck, man. What are you going to do?" Seth asked

"Hell if I know." Dean said.

"Is that why you have been sleeping with all these girls? It's some kind of way of punishing yourself?" Seth asked.

"What? No, man. I meant everything I told you when I got back." Dean said.

"Even about your relationship with Bayley being a joke and love not being real? You honestly believe all that shit?" Seth asked.

"Yeah, I do." Dean said as he looked into Seth's eyes.

"That doesn't mean I don't care about my friendship with you and Roman." Dean said.

"Then you can't tell him." Seth said.

"What? Why not?" Dean asked.

"Because this isn't the first time you slept with his girlfriend.." Seth said.

"Shit, you're right." Dean said.

"Or mine for that matter." Seth joked.

Dean tried to laugh as Seth patted him on the back.

At Roman's house, Aj waited as Roman finished his shower.

"You're still here?" Roman asked as he walked out of the bathroom.

"Sasha told me to stay here until she got home." Aj said.

"Of course she did." Roman said as he walked into the kitchen and grabbed himself a beer.

"It's nine in the morning, dude." Aj said.

"And I just found out my girlfriend cheated on me." Roman said.

"Okay, fair enough." Aj said.

Roman took a sip of his beer and looked at Aj as she drank her coffee.

"You seem to have Seth occupied a lot." Roman said.

"Well I'm his girlfriend, shouldn't we spend time together?" Aj asked.

"No, you should.. but maybe not as much." Roman said.

"If you have something to say then just say it." Aj said.

"You just seem kind of clingy, that's all." Roman said.

Aj's face turned red with rage.

"You think I'm clingy? What about you and Sasha?" Aj asked.

"What about it?" Roman asked.

"I saw the way you looked at her at the party the other night, you clearly have feelings for her." Aj said.

"You don't know what your talking about." Roman said.

"That seems to be a problem for you doesn't it? Falling for literally every girl you lay eyes on." Aj said.

"Fuck you." Roman said as he took another sip of his beer.

"I don't even know why I'm here." Aj said.

"Me either." Roman said.

"Here's the keys to the house." Aj said as she threw them at Roman and walked away.

Roman rolled his eyes as Aj slammed the front door on her way out.

At school, Sasha, Bayley, Finn, and Mike were having lunch in the courtyard.

"It's the four musketeers!" Mike said.

Sasha and Bayley laughed as Finn high fived Mike.

"So I need to tell you guys something." Bayley said. 

"What is it?" Finn asked.

"Becky's back." Bayley said.

Sasha looked at Bayley in surprise.

"What do you mean she's back?" Sasha asked.

"I saw her on my run yesterday." Bayley said.

"We were together all day yesterday and you didn't think to tell me that your assasin, ex-girlfriend is back in town?" Sasha asked.

"Our." Finn corrected her.

"What?" Sasha asked.

"Well technically she is both of yours ex-girlfriend." Finn said.

Sasha stared at Finn in disbelief.

"Never mind, carry on." Finn said.

"We were having a nice time, I didn't want to ruin our day." Bayley said.

"You could have told me after." Sasha said.

"Is James back too?" Mike asked.

"I don't know." Bayley said as Sasha got up and stormed off.

Bayley got up and followed Sasha.

"Sasha wait!" Bayley yelled.

"Why didn't you tell me?" Sasha asked as she turned around to face Bayley.

"I kissed her." Bayley blurted out as she looked into Sasha's eyes.

Suddenly, the anger in Sasha's eyes turned to disappointment. Before Bayley could explain herself, Sasha walked away.

On campus, Becky met with Charlotte in her dorm.

"So she knows your back?" Charlotte asked.

"Yeah, she knows." Becky said.

 "What happened?" Charlotte asked.

"What makes you think something happened?" Becky asked.

"You soul looks more tortured than usual." Charlotte joked.

"She hates me." Becky said.

"And you're still in love with her?" Charlotte asked.

"I'm not.. I was never in.." Becky tried to say. 

"You can lie to Bayley and you can lie to yourself all you want but don't lie to me. I know you had feelings for that girl." Charlotte said.

"It doesn't matter. I'm here to talk to you and Roman." Becky said.

"He never showed." Charlotte said.

"You couldn't have text me that? Why am I even here?" Becky asked.

"Because I wanted to see you." Charlotte said.

Becky looked up at Charlotte with hesitation.

"I have to go." Becky said.

Charlotte stood there as Becky hurried out of her dorm room.

Back at Seth's  loft, he and Dean were watching twilight.

"I can't believe you are making me watch this man." Dean said.

"I'm not making you watch anything." Seth laughed as Aj came barging in.

 "Aj?" Seth asked as he scooted away from Dean.

She walked in and sat down on the couch between Seth and Dean.

"Roman is an asshole." Aj said.

"Wait, what?" Seth asked.

"Sasha asked me to keep an eye on him today so I tried but he is unbelievable." Aj said.

"What happened?" Seth asked.

"He's an asshole, I just told you that." Aj said.

"Is he doing okay?" Dean asked.

"I honestly don't care." Aj said.

Dean looked over at Seth with concern.

"I should get going." Dean said.

"What? Where are you going to go?" Seth asked.

"I just.. I have to go do that thing I told you about." Dean said.

Seth looked at Dean in confusion as he walked away.

After school Bayley barged into the school newspaper room.

"Bayley I can't talk right now." Sasha said as she began typing on her laptop.

"Someone tried to kill me." Bayley said as she leaned against Sasha's desk.

"What? Are you okay?" Sasha asked.

"On my run, a man tried to kill me. That's when I saw Becky." Bayley said.

"You didn't tell me that." Sasha said.

"She saved my life." Bayley said.

"That's not a reason to kiss her." Sasha said.

"Well I slapped her first is that makes things better." Bayley said.

Sasha looked up at Bayley and tried to fight a smile.

"Okay..that makes it a little better." Sasha said.

"Sasha, I swear to you that it meant nothing. It was like I was angry that she left then I was happy that she was back then I was just really confused. I know I shouldn't have done it but please know that it meant nothing." Bayley said.

"I believe you." Sasha said.

"You do?" Bayley asked in surprise.

"I'm sorry I stormed off like that, you just caught me off guard. I wish you would have told me before you told Finn and Mike." Sasha said.

"I'm sorry, I didn't think this through. I know I messed up." Bayley said.

"So next time you will talk to me first?" Sasha asked.

"Yes, I promise." Bayley said.

"Okay, then." Sasha said.

"Are we good then?" Bayley asked.

"Of course." Sasha said.

"Hey." Bayley said as she held up Sasha's chin.

"What?" Sasha asked as she looked at her.

"I love you." Bayley said.

"Yeah, yeah.. I know." Sasha said with a smile on her face.

Bayley leaned down and kissed her on the forehead.

"I'll see you later, babe. Have fun with the paper." Bayley said as she walked away.

Seth had his arm around Aj while they finished watching the movie. Aj was focused on the movie while Seth tried getting a hold of Dean.

"Who are you texting? You have been on your phone the entire movie." Aj said.

"Uh.. Roman, I'm just checking in on him." Seth said.

"Wait.. where is my phone?" Aj asked.

"I haven't seen it." Seth said.

"Shit, I think I left it at Roman's." Aj said.

"Oh." Seth said.

"If George or Mellie call me and I don't answer they are going to kill me. I have to go get my phone, you want to come with me? You can check on him in person." Aj said.

"I can't." Seth said.

"You can't?" Aj asked.

"No, I have to do something." Seth said.

"Okay, weirdo." Aj said as she left the loft.

Seth watched from the window as she got in the car and drove off. He grabbed his car keys and rushed downstairs to his bike.

Aj walked into Roman's house and grabbed her phone off the counter. Her plan to go straight in, get her phone, and leave went to hell when she saw Roman in his room.

"Are you serious?" Aj asked as she stood in his doorway.

"You're back? God why are you doing this to me?" Roman asked.

"Are you drunk already?" Aj asked.

Roman scrolled through photos on his phone as he laid there in bed.

"Please tell me you aren't looking at photos of you and Mandy." Aj said.

"I'm not." Roman mumbled as Aj took his phone from him.

"You know this is pathetic, right?" Aj asked.

"You know your bossy, right?" Roman asked.

Aj folded her arms and stared at Roman.

"I'm getting up, chill out woman." Roman said.

"You have to pull your shit together and stop feeling sorry for yourself." Aj said as she opened the refrigerator door and grabbed a beer. Roman sat down at the counter.

"This is the second time this has happened to me." Roman said.

"Wow, that's sad. Who cheated on you before?" Aj asked as she took a sip of the beer.

"Your sister." Roman said.

"I didn't know you and Bayley were together." Aj said.

"It was pretty much over before it started." Roman said.

"Who did she cheat on you with?" Aj asked.

"Who do you think?" Roman asked.

"Dean?" Aj asked.

"I caught them making out on the football field." Roman said.

"Shit, I'm sorry. I can't believe Bayley would do that to anyone." Aj said.

"That whole situation was too complicated for something to not go wrong so I don't really blame her anymore." Roman said.

"And you blame Mandy now?" Aj asked.

"Well yeah. She and I were doing great then out of no where she just decided to fuck another dude?" Roman said.

"You have a name? We can go do some damage." Aj said.

Roman looked at her and laughed.

"Hey, I'm sorry I called you clingy earlier." Roman said.

"I'm sorry I said you fall for every girl you meet." Aj said.

"Well.. I mean you were kind of right." Roman laughed at himself.

"You were kind of right about me being clingy too. I've always been that way." Aj said.

"It's not necessarily a bad thing you know." Roman said.

"It's not?" Aj asked.

"It's better to have someone clinging to you then cheating on you." Roman said.

Aj laughed and grabbed a beer from Roman.

"I think I might no what will make you feel better." Aj said.

"You do?" Roman asked.

"Let's go." Aj said as she grabbed her car keys.

"Where are we going?" Roman asked.

"You'll see." Aj said as they walked outside.

As they got in the car Aj looked at Roman skeptically.

"Okay, I'm going to help you but only under one condition.." Aj said.

"Okay, what is it?" Roman asked.

"You can't fall in love with me." Aj joked as she looked into Roman's eyes.

Roman looked at her seriously for a moment. Aj smiled and stared to laugh.

"I doubt that will be a problem." Roman laughed.

Across town, Seth pulled up to the high school and walked onto the football field. As he predicted, Dean was sitting on the bleachers watching football practice.

"How did you know I was here?" Dean asked.

"I had a feeling." Seth said as he walked up the bleachers and sat next to Dean.

"If he finds out he'll never forgive me." Dean said.

"You don't know that." Seth said.

"He barely forgave me last time." Dean said.

"So what if he doesn't forgive you? You still have me." Seth said.

Dean looked at Seth for a moment and smiled.

"Thank you for all of this man. For bringing me home, for letting me stay with you.. and now sticking by my side.." Dean said.

"I'll always be by your side, no matter what." Seth said.

"It's kind of funny to think it was just a little over a year ago that we were fighting on this field." Dean said.

"All over a girl." Seth said.

Dean looked up the bleachers to the spot he and Bayley used to meet to work on their school project.

What are you guys doing here?" Bayley asked as she approached.

"Talking about you actually." Seth laughed.

"Nothing bad I hope." Bayley said.

"Not at all." Dean said as he smiled.

Bayley smiled and sat down next to Seth.

"Have you guys heard about Roman and Mandy?" Bayley asked.

Seth and Dean were silent.

"Sasha said Roman's a mess." Bayley said.

"Yeah, Aj was with him this morning." Seth said.

"Aj and Roman? Wow, that sounds like a disaster." Bayley laughed.

"Well I don't think it went too well if that's what you mean." Seth said.

"Yeah, apparently Roman's an asshole." Dean said.

"Babe?" Sasha asked as she approached.

"Hey, I was just waiting on you." Bayley said as she got up.

"What are you two doing here?" Sasha asked as Bayley walked down the bleachers to meet Sasha.

"Reminiscing." Seth said as he looked back at Dean.

Bayley greeted Sasha with a kiss.

"Okay, well we will see you guys at Joe's later." Sasha said as she put her arm around Bayley and walked away.

Dean looked down at his feet, trying to pretend like he was okay.

"Dean?" Alexa asked from the football field, getting Dana and Peyton's attention.

"Shit." Dean said.

"Wow man, I think there might be two girls on the cheer squad that you haven't slept with this week." Seth said.

"We have to get out of here." Dean said as he rushed down the bleachers.

Seth laughed and followed Dean to the parking lot.

That evening Aj and Roman parked outside Mandy's house and prepared to do their worst.

"I don't know about this." Roman said as he took a sip of a beer and looked at the hundred rolls of toilet paper in Aj's backseat.

"I promise it will make you feel better." Aj said.

They got out of the car and both grabbed a few rolls of toilet paper. Aj immediately went for the giant tree in front of Mandy's house.

"Why do I feel like you have does this before?" Roman asked.

"Revenge on the ex is kind of my thing." Aj said as she continued throwing toilet paper.

Roman shook his head and joined in. After covering Mandy's entire house in toilet paper they were almost done.

"Okay, now for the last part." Aj said.

"There's more?" Roman asked as Aj grabbed a can of spray paint from her car.

"You just happened to have that laying around?" Roman asked.

"Yes, yes I did." Aj said as she handed the paint to Roman.

"What do I do with this?" Roman asked.

"Whatever you want." Aj said.

Roman looked at Aj and smiled. He walked over to the bushes they covered in toilet paper and wrote "It's Over."

"You good?" Aj asked.

"Hey, thank you for this." Roman said.

"Like I said, this is kind of my thing." Aj said.

"I mean it Aj, this was a lot of fun." Roman said as he looked into her eyes.

Aj looked up at Roman with caution. They both just stood there, staring at each other. Suddenly, someone turned on Mandy's front porch light.

"Shit!" Aj yelled as she and Roman ran to her car.

They jumped in and sped off.

"Oh my god!" Roman laughed as he looked over at Aj.

"Did you think they caught us?" Aj asked.

"Yeah, I did actually." Roman laughed and looked over at a smiling Aj.

Everyone else was enjoying pizza at Joe's when Roman and Aj walked in.

"Where have you two been?" Seth asked.

"It's a long story." Aj said as she smiled at Roman.

"Okay, then." Seth said as Aj sat next to him and kissed him on the cheek.

"You seem to be doing a lot better then you were when I left you this morning." Sasha said.

"Yeah, I am." Roman said as he looked at Aj.

"I'll be right back." Finn said as Alexa walked inside with Carmella and Nikki.

"Can I help you?" Alexa asked.

"We were assigned partners in class today for that essay thing." Finn said.

"Yeah, and?" Alexa asked.

"When do you want to get together to work on it?" Finn asked.

"We can work on it tomorrow after school if you want. You can come to my house." Alexa said.

"Okay, I guess I will see you then." Finn said before walking away.

Alexa looked over at Dean but he wasn't paying attention to her.

Everyone watched as Finn sat back down.

"What was that about?" Mike asked.

"Mr. Stone assigned us as partners for that stupid essay project." Finn said.

"Good luck with that." Bayley said as she shot Dean a smile.

"Yeah, good luck." Dean said as he winked at Bayley.

Sasha looked out the window when she noticed blue and red lights.

"Guys." Sasha said.

Everyone looked out the window to find nearly a dozen police cars speeding down main street. It seemed like the entire town was coming out to find out what was going on. Everyone in the cafe cleared out and walked down the street. The police began putting up crime scene tape.

"Is that Mandy's father?" Mike asked.

"Yeah." Dean said as Roman walked closer.

"Sheriff Rose!" Roman yelled as he approached.

"Roman, you shouldn't be here." Sheriff Rose said.

"What's going on?" Roman asked.

"We found a body." Sheriff Rose told him.

Roman walked back to the others as they watched the officers load a body into the back of an ambulance.

"Who is it?" Sasha asked.

"He says it's Captain McMahon." Roman said.

"You mean Stephanie McMahon?" Bayley asked.

Thanks for reading! Please comment to let me know what you think!