♡ w e e k 9 - c r i t i q u e ♡
This week's critique will be for karinarule18's "My MyStreet Life." This book will be little bit different compared to the others, with the addition of OC's, and not to mention a LOT of them.
This story also contains mature language and a lot of OC x canon. If you don't like that, then I don't recommend this book.
But! Before we get to that, we need this week's paired activities! If you were not aware, this book club has weekly activities consisting of pairs or trios. The activity is to critique your partner's book within the remaining days.
We've also edited the pairing system. Now, the partners can choose which of their partner's books they'll critique.
For more information, please visit the first few chapters of this book. So, let's move to the pairings/trios!
---
thisisNXCXLX → _missingpiece and since the two of you are Filipinos, no need to translate them into English for the other to understand → -niightdreeamer
SkyStormer_→ AKAMagicKitty if you two are still up for it, even though you're admins now.
KittyKawaiiFT→ @OnlyStormyNight (for some reason, I am unable to tag you.) → KawaiiLumosityDreams
iiCaptainBubbles → Toolouseave
SkylarSkullRider → lilyanna4569
AriaZeShipper → Burpilicious → AnimeIsTakingOver
EvThePurpleMeifwa → Purplekitty05
JustAnotherDream_15 (congratulations on a thousand followers!) → NikkiBunny816
the_superherotrash → TheDerpyUnicornGamez
Man, it was painful to list down all those names.
But at least, now we can move onto writing the critique!!
---
➵ c o v e r
I enjoy the self-drawn cover, but I do believe it could use brighter colors; maybe try to scan the image instead of taking a picture?
Also, there seems to be a part of the illustration that got cut off. If this seems like a problem, maybe you should try to digitalise the cover and insert it into a template to have the perfect fit.
Other than that, the cover is okay and far from bad.
➵ b l u r b / d e s c r i p t i o n s
The blurb is very well-written and self-explanatory. It has some of the elements that truly make a good description, such as some type of questions that would lure a new reader in.
There is also proper credit given to Jess for the characters, as well as for the original characters. There are also proper warnings about the maturity of the book, which is always good for this generation (even though I highly doubt that they'll heed your warning.)
➵ t i t l e
The title "My MyStreet Life" isn't too creative, and I think you can do better.
It doesn't pertain much to the plot, other than the fact that the story contains OC's. This title were to make more sense if the story had character POV's, and specifically one character's POV, due to the use of "my" in the title.
The title "My Characters' MyStreet Life" would make more sense, but that wouldn't really draw someone in, would it? I recommend thinking up a unique title that can draw the reader in, at the same time have a connection to the plot.
➵ s t o r y
It is very enjoyable, with the sane amount of shipping fuel, as the characters tend to do something productive with their lives instead of just being all lovey dovey with each other; it also has various conflicts, which I don't want to spoil.
I also find humor in the numerous cameos and fourth wall breaks in the midst of all the drama happening between the characters (especially Garroth and Aphmau.)
*I also approve of your choice of ships.
➵ s u m m a r y
1.) a brighter cover would be desirable.
2.) have a title that is connected to the plot, as well as be interesting enough to lure in new readers.
3.) add more tags to increase the discovery of your story, seeing as the only pairing you tagged was #garmau. I suggest adding #travcinda, #vyladlyn, and #dantechan to the tags.
---
Please remember that critiques are for improving and not for personal attacks! But, I'm sure this user understands that, since she was the one who requested a critique in the first place.
For the remaining critique requests, please wait until next week. Thank you.
Enjoy your day and thanks for stopping by!
Signing off,
Bạn đang đọc truyện trên: Truyen247.Pro