Kiernan Shipka as Maddie Creston

"I'm not cut out for this. Everyone knows that."

Nina Dobrev as Mabel McBride

"Oh baby it's the end of the world... Let's dance."

Bob Morely as Theodore McBride

"Everything was fine until he showed up to play hero."

Jensen Ackles as Dean Winchester

"We? No there is no we. You made that pretty clear."

Jared Padalecki as Sam Winchester

"I believe you, I believe in you."

AUTHOR'S NOTE: okay y'all so i literally just started the first chapter and i'm hoping it won't flop. sending love! - your friendly neighborhood writer