Sam and Dean arrive at Dani's house after their little scuffle. "Wow, Sam. I knew you would look good in that costume." said Dani. She gives Sam a hug. "So this is your little boyfriend, huh, Dani?" Max teased. "Shut up, Max!" yelled Dani smacking her brother's arm. Dani and Max's parents steps out onto the porch. "Ohhh, so adorable! I'm gonna take a picture of you and your little friend, Dani." said their mom. She takes out her camera and snaps a few photos of Dani and Sam together. "Sam, honey, where's your dad?" she asked Sam. "He's working tonight and won't be home until late. My brother, Dean, is taking me around." Sam answered her. "Okay, well, you kids stay safe." said Mrs. Dennison before walking back into the house. "So, little dude here is a cowboy and you are...?" Max said to Sam and Dean, trying to figure out Dean's costume. "I'm a rock star, man." Dean replied putting on a pair of 80's style sunglasses. The four kids walk to the house next door to begin their trick-or-treating journey.

After a few houses, Max gets bored. "Can we go home now?" groaned Max. "No." replied Dani. "Your sister's right, dude, chill out." said Dean. They then see two teens and their friends terrorizing a bunch of kids. "Jerks." scoffed Sam. "Let's just go this way." Max said trying to lead Dani another way. Dani ignores her brother and heads towards the teens. "Come on, Sam." she said grabbing his wrist and pulling him behind her. "Ding ding. Ding ding." said the chubby guy, blocking Dani and Sam's path with his leg. "Stop and pay the toll, kid. You, too...sheriff." said the boy with long hair. "Ten chocolate bars, each; no licorice." demanded the chubby one. "Dump your sacks!" commanded the long-haired one. "Drop dead, moron." Dani said. "Yeah, leave us alone." added Sam. "Yo, twerp. How'd you like to be hung off that telephone pole?" threatened chubby teen. "What about you, pacos bill, wanna join her?" threatened long-haired teen. Dani crosses her arms and scoffs.

She looks at the two teens, fearless. "I'd just like to see you try it. Cause it just so happens we've got our big brothers with us. Max! Dean!" Dani said. Max and Dean walk up to their younger siblings. "Hollywood. Oh no." said the chubby teen, Ice, sarcastically. "And look, it's the other new kid; Dean 'Lose'-chester, right?" said the long-haired teen, Jay. "So you're doing a little trick-or-treating?" he asked Max. "I'm taking my little sister around." replied Max. "That's nice." said Jay. "Woah, I love the costume. But what are you supposed to be? A New Kid on the Block?" he mockingly asked. "For your information, he's a little leaguer!" Dani said. "Woah, little leaguer!" laughed Jay. Him and Ice pretend to play baseball to make fun of Max.

Dani gets annoyed and leaves with Sam beside her; Ice stops them. "Wait a minute. Everyone pays the toll." said Ice. "Stuff it, zit face." Dani snapped back. Ice makes a move to try and hit Dani, but Sam kicks his shin before Max could intervene. "Ow! You brat!" he shouted. He picks Sam up off the ground by his shirt and raises his fist. Dean then socks Ice in the jaw knocking him to the ground. "Leave my little brother alone, pilsberry dough boy." he said to Ice. Dean turns to Jay. "Do you want one, too, Rapunzle?" he asked. Jay helps Ice to his feet. "You're a freak, man!" he said. The two run off. "You okay, Sammy?" Dean asked his brother. Sam nods. "Come on, lets get to the next house already." grumbled Max. He takes Dani's hand and heads for the next stop.