Requested by: Dream__Dork
Cheater! Sting x reader
~2 years ago~

I was walking down the street if Crocus from another day at the guild when I heard someone walking behind. I turn to see Sting Eucliffe walking behind me. It confused me because I know for a fact Sting has never been on this street before, because it leads to certain houses almost outside of Crocus and he lives in the Sabertooth dorms.

"Are you lost, Sting?" I asked looking at him and for the first time of being in sabertooth, Sting Eucliffe isn't acting confident.

"Yes Y/n, I am lost." He said. He started walking towards me, he started to make me uncomfortable by the way he was looking at so I started to back up. I wasn't paying attention to where I was heading and hit a wall. Before I could run, Sting trapped me between his arms so I couldn't do so.

He started to move his face closer to mine and he put his mouth by my ear, almost touching it.
"I am lost, and I need you as my guide so I stick to the right path~." He said in a flirtatious manner. Wtf. What is he talking about.

"Be my girlfriend." Sting asked, more like told me. I looked at him and I saw there was a light blush in his cheeks. A very hard to notice blush.

"Are you asking me, or telling me?" I asked with  confidence. He looked at me and straight in to my eyes. How can someone eye's be such a forget-me-not blue. After coming back to reality from his eye like trance I saw that he was smirking.

"You pick. Either way your going to be my girlfriend." Sting said radianting confindence. He was  still smirking and he started to nibble on my ear.

~present~

I was at the store looking for something I could make for dinner the next few nights and also get some snacks for Lecter. Sting and I been dating for about two years and we started living together a year aga.

I was thinking about making Stings favorite food for dinner tonight since he's been acting kinds distant. He's the guild master if sabertooth now so it make sense that he's been distant. I was going to make Miso soup, Onigiri, Tofu,  and sushi for Lecter.

After getting groceries I walking home when I heard moans in the alley way. I look over to the direction of the moans and my heart broke. My guild master. My boyfriend. The love of my life. Sting. He was making out with some blonde girl. I just need to.....walk away.

It's been five hours since I saw Sting cheat. I made dinner a hour ago. Lecter is at Rogue's and Sting hasn't come home yet. I ate dinner by myself and Stings dinner is on the table, cold. I wrote a note to Sting that he could sleep anywhere except the bed tonight. I can't be next to him.

I woke up at 3:26 in the morning... holding on to a... hand? I look down at the body attached to the have to find Sting sleeping on the floor holding my hand. I could smell the fresh perfume scent on him. He just got home.

"Sting, you awake?"  I asked feeling his hand move so he could stand up. He was awake. He must of got home from cheating on me.
"Sorry I'm late love. I was just thi-" He stopped in the middle of his sentence to see that I was glaring at him

"I was thinking about you and how much I need your touch, this drunk slut try to force herself on me." Sting said before kissing. He didn't cheat on me. It was that hoes fault. Sting still loves me. I move over so Sting could get in bed and he did. He didn't cheat on me.

I was wrong. It's been two months since the incident and I saw Sting cheat on my six different times on accident. I was packing up my stuff. I bought a new house so I wouldn't have to live with a cheater anymore. He comes home in 6 minutes and I'm going to break up with him and leave Sabertooth so I can join fairy tail.

Once I was finishing packing my stuff, I heard the door open. Sting. Is. Home. I heard a muffled "what the fuck". He must be surprised that my stuff is packed up and ready to go.

"Y/n! Where are you, baby!" I heard I desperate cry from sting. I walked to where sting was. What I saw broke my heart. Sting had an angry look on his face with tear running down it. The was part was he was un-packing my stuff.

"Sting! Stop!" I yelled. He looked at me and before I knew it I was pinned to the wall. Just like the day he asked me out. The poor man that broke my heart was crying. He just looked at me like I was a ghost.

"Where are you going baby girl." He said wrapping his arms around my waist. He's like a little boy who's acting like his favorite toy will get taken away.

"Away from a cheater like you." I said glaring at him.

"Baby girl, list-" "No you listen Sting. I gave you my everything and then you cheat in my with seven different girls. And I bet you cheated on my more than just seven times! I don't know what I did, but all I food was love you. I gave my virginity to you and then you probably slept with several woman! I did nothing wrong, but you took my heart and stomped on it! We're over." I yelled at him and he just wouldn't stop crying. U was about to leave, but he grabbyef my arm.

"Please don't leave me, I can't live without you. I was blacked mailed please believe and I will stop it all. I live you. Please stay with me?" He begged.

He broke me , but we still love eachother. Should I stay or should I go.