Josie Saltzman paced around her bedroom. Why was she so fucking stupid? She liked Justin. She really liked Justin, and he was right. She was making the situation much more worse than it had to be. She wanted to be with Justin. Being with him made her feel the happiest she's ever felt. She had never got that feeling with Zach.

She looked down at her phone and saw Hope Mikaelson's face pop up. "Yeah?"

"Lizzie told you?"

"Yeah."

"I'm sorry. She didn't want people to know. Otherwise, I-"

Josie nodded as she sat down on her bed. "It's okay. I get it." She looked down at her lap. "It kind of makes me feel weird, I guess."

"What do you mean?"

The girl let out a sigh, laying backwards. "I just thought we were all best friends, and then I find out that's not actually how things were. It's just making me think a lot."

"Yeah, I get that."

"How long have you liked her?"

"Since forever."

"Shit. Really?" Josie shook her head. "Hope, I'm so sorry."

"It's chill. That's my curse. I fall in love with straight girls."

Josie let out a chuckle. "Are you at Bryce's party?"

"Why would I be at that party? I hate Bryce."

"I don't know." The brunette smiled as she giggled. "You like to party."

"That is true."

Josie heard Hope's laugh through the phone, and she frowned. "I have to go."

"Okay. I'll see you at school?"

"Yeah." She spoke before ending the call.

*

Private message between Justin🤢 and Josie💕

Josie💕
Hey are you at Bryce's party
I really need to talk to you
Like a lot
Justin?
Helloooooooo
Where are you
Justin I want to talk to you please text me back
Wtf
Justin I've been texting you for like ten minutes
Where the fuck are you

*

Private message between Jess👅 and Jo👀

Jo👀
Are you at Bryce's party

Jess👅
Maybe

Jo👀
Is that a yes

Jess👅
Yes
I'm drunk
What do you want

Jo👀
Is Justin there

Jess👅
Yupity

Jo👀
Okay thanks

Jess👅
That's it?
No how are you doing Jess?
I guess that is it...

*

Josie frowned as she leaned her bike up against Bryce's house. Lizzie had took the car, so she was stuck riding her bike. She made her way into Bryce's backyard where she saw Jessica Davis and Hannah Baker sitting in the hot tub. "You never texted me back." Jessica whined, jumping out of the hot tub. She wrapped her arms around her best friend, hugging her.

"Jess, you got my all wet." Josie let out a groan as she lightly pushed Jessica away from her.

"Oops." Jessica giggled as she sat back in the hot tub.

Josie crossed her arms over her chest as she glanced around at the party. "Where's Justin?"

"I think he's in the pool house." Jessica spoke as she took a sip from her cup filled with alcohol.

The brunette nodded, making her way to the pool house. She opened the door and froze. A naked Justin Foley had a naked Lizzie Saltzman pinned up against the wall with her legs wrapped around his waist. They were having sex.

Josie's eyes widened as things began to register. She felt a tear run down her cheek. She watched as Justin's head turned towards her as he let out a moan. His eyes widened when he saw Josie standing in the doorway. "Fuck." He practically dropped Lizzie as he ran to his sweatpants. He slid them over the lower half of his body and turned back to the doorway. Josie was gone.

Justin rushed out of the pool house, and saw Josie on the front lawn. He ran over to her, calling her name. He tried to grab onto her hand, but she pulled it out of his grasp as soon as he did. "What the fuck, Justin?"

"Jo, I'm so fucking sorry."

"We had one argument, and you go and sleep with my fucking sister who still isn't over you?" Josie ran her hand through her hair as she cried. "What the fuck is wrong with you?"

Justin shook his head. "I was pissed off, okay? I thought you were going to take Zach back, and I didn't know what to do?"

"So you fucked Lizzie. Great idea, Justin."

The boy cupped Josie's cheeks with his hands. "I'm so sorry."

"I was coming over here to tell you that I wanted be with you. Not Zach." Josie spoke as Justin wiped her tears away with his thumb.

"I'm so sorry."

"Stop fucking saying that, Justin. It doesn't change what you did." She pulled his hands off of her face. "You can forget about us ever actually being together." She bit her lip, trying to hold back even more tears from flowing.

"Jo, please."

She shook her head, letting out a deep breath. "Don't talk to me, okay?"

*

Private message between Lizzie🐥 and Josie👻

Lizzie🐥
What the fuck was that
What just fucking happened
I was having sex
And now Justin's kicking me out thanks to you
What is wrong with you

Josie👻
What's wrong with you

Lizzie🐥
Why are you so upset
You hate Justin

Josie👻
I don't tho

Lizzie🐥
Jo
Please don't say what I think you're going to say

Josie👻
Then I won't say it

Lizzie🐥
How could you do that to me

Josie👻
It just kind of happened
Also you guys have been broken up for a fucking year
Get over it

Lizzie🐥
You should have told me

Josie👻
Well we all make mistakes

Lizzie🐥
I can't believe you would do that

Josie👻
You don't get to be mad at me right now
It's not my fucking fault that I like Justin Foley okay
He has been flirting with me all fucking year and it worked

Lizzie🐥
I thought you loved me

Josie👻
Lizzie come on
I do love you
So much
But Justin is a person and changes and you need to change and move on too
You can't just be hung up on him all of your fucking life

Lizzie🐥
Stfu

Josie👻
No
He only fucked you tonight because he was mad that I told Zach I would think about getting back together with him

Lizzie🐥
Fuck you

Josie👻
Fuck you