Still reapers pov

When we got back to the mansion, I went strait to logan.

"How did you guys know Nightmare? You all seemed different around her, especially Jean, it was like you all had some weird hatred for her, like worse than the rest of the brotherhood." I asked.

"Sorry kid, I wasn't here for all that. I only know bits and pieces of what happened." He said not looking up from his news paper.

"Well who does know?"

"Most likely phoenix and cyclops. They were close to the kid, they also are the only ones who know exactly what went on."

I decided I was going to get answers and find out who exactly this girl was. I walked up the stairs to Jeans room, and knocked on the door.

"Oh, hi Greyson." She looked slightly suprise that I was here.

"Um...I actually have some questions Jean and I was hoping you could help me answer them." I asked.

"Ok, shoot."

"Who is Nightmare, why do you all act so differently to her and how does she know your real names?" I could see different emotions swirl through her eyes, sadness, pain, anger, and hurt, until they finally landed on anger.

"All you need to know is don't trust her. Ever. Better yet, stay away from her." Jean growled, and then slammed her door.

I decided to go to one more person. Scott.

I knocked on his bedroom door.

"What's up Greyson?" Scott asked opening the door. When he saw the look on my face he must've understood what I wanted.

"Oh....come in." He said sounding emotionless.

We sat down on his bed and sat in silence for a while.

"Her name was Andrea Charlotte Stellar." He paused and took a deep breath.

"She had just figured out she was a mutant, and accidently let loose on her school. She was provoked, a few kids were bullying her, pushing her around. No one but Jean and shadowcat went in, kurt was supposed to just in case she was stronger than we thought and tried to hurt one of them. No one else knows for sure what happened in there that day.

"She moved in here, at the institute after that. Jean and Andy kept getting closer and closer till they were almost inseparable. They told each other everything and never went anywhere without the other.

"Until January, 23rd, 2010. The entire team went in that day, planning on taking Magneto and the brotherhood down, it was me, Jean, kitty, kurt, rogue, Evan, logan, storm, Megan steele, and of course Andy, her name was shadow at the time. We had taken our positions and ran inside but they were ready.

Flash back third person pov

"You guys ready?" Evan Daniels asked exitedly into the Com - link. There were a chorus of  'yea's and 'definitely's, yet only eight people responded.

"Andy! You ok?" Scott asked the fourteen year old girl.

"Oh!...uh yea, yea I'm fine." She said nevously. Meg turned to the young girl who became sort of like a younger sister to her.

"Andy were gonna be fine." She said with a warm smile in the blonde's direction.

"Yeah, yeah I know." She replyed. Everyone just shrugged it off as nerves, but Andy almost wished they didn't.

They all rushed inside the old warehouse expecting shocked faces of the brotherhood and acolytes, but we're met with the knowing evil smirks across the enemy's faces.

"Well well well, look who decided to join the party!" Magneto taunted. A huge fight took place but none of the X-men were completely focused on the fight, they were all wondering who would betray them?

As they got back to the mansion everyone sat down in the sitting room, they were all silent but in their heads was anything but.

Soon Scott gasped and shot forward grabbing Andy by her X-suit. She sucked in a breath as Scott picked her up harshly by the collar. Teats rolled down the small girls cheeks.

"How could you!?" Scott roared. Andy shielded her face and head with her hands as she started screaming

"I'm sorry I'm so sorry I didn't mean to I'm sorry!" She sobbed. They all looked up with shock and hurt in they're expressions.

"You traitor! How could you! You got Meg killed you idiot!" Scott threw the small girl onto the floor and stomped off. Andy curled into herself as she lay on the cold wood floor crying.

Soon all the X-men were standing up, looking at her with pure hate in their eyes. When Andy saw this she clamored to her feet and ran as fast as she could, with only one thought on her mind.

'Magneto was right, they did hate me.'

"We never saw her again after that, I made a mistake, I'll admit that, but she basically killed Meg, I couldn't let her get away with it, friend or not."

I laid my hand on his shoulder.

"You did what you believed was right, no one blames you for that."