Olivia, walking around in a drunk phase, trying to find her boyfriend to give him that beer he wanted, snapped out of it when she heard someone in the lake screaming. She ran over to the dock and saw Kieran pulling Noah out of the water. She also, watched as Jake was laughing his ass off. "What the hell did you do?" Olivia snapped as she knelt down next to Noah. She pushed the hair out of his face and looked into his eyes to make sure that he was okay.

"Kiss him, Ollie." Jake joked, using the nickname Tyler had made for her.

"Jake, shut up." Olivia scowled at him.

"How could you?" Riley asked and she pushed him.

"He was the first one to pass out!" Jake explained himself. "It's a Wren Lake tradition."

"What was it that grabbed me?" Noah asked as he breathed heavily.

"No one grabbed you, spaz." Jake answered. "We just dropped you off."

"You were stuck on fishing line." Emma stated as she removed it from his foot.

"It didn't feel like fishing line." Noah sighed. "It felt like someone was pulling me down."

"Noah?" Audrey's eyes widened as she saw him.

"I'm fine. I'm fine." He stated as he started to stand up.

"You're friends are great, Emma. Thank you for the invite." Audrey stated sarcastically before walking off with Noah.

Olivia looked up at Jake and shook her head. "Come on, babe, it was a joke." She grabbed her sister's hand and walked away from the group. "Babe, come back!" Jake called after her.

*

Olivia sat in the back of Kieran's car while Emma sat in the passenger seat. They arrived at their house. "So, I'll see you at school." Emma stated awkwardly.

"Seems likely." Kieran nodded. "Why is my dad at your house?" Emma and Olivia's eyes shifted to the doorway and saw Maggie and Clark talking on the front porch.

"Sheriff Hudson is your dad?" Emma sighed. "As if this wasn't awkward enough already." Emma quickly got out of the car.

"Bye, Kieran." Olivia smiled before getting out of his car. She felt her phone continue to vibrate as hundred of messages from Jake started flooding in.

*

Olivia heard her sister's sobs, and entered her room. "Hey, Em. You alright?" Olivia sighed as she sat on the edge of the bed.

Emma shook her head. "Will cheated on me with Nina." A look of pure shock appeared on Olivia's face. "You didn't know."

"Don't you think I would have told you." Olivia pulled her sister into a hug. "I may be a bitch, but I'm not ruthless."

*

Olivia walked into the school the next morning, and was immediately bombarded by Jake. "Babe, can we please talk? Didn't you get my messages."

"Yeah, every single one." Olivia sighed as she walked over towards her locker.

"Why are you acting this way? It was just a joke." Jake leaned against the lockers.

"When will you get that it wasn't a joke?" Olivia snapped at her. "Noah could have gotten seriously hurt. He could have died, and his blood would have been on your hands."

"It would have been an accident." Jake stated.

"No." Olivia shook her head. "You put his body out on that dock. It's your fault he was out there, and his death would have been your fault, as well."

"Please, can we just get past this."

"Sure, when you stop thinking that everything is a joke." Olivia shut her locker and spotted Noah. She smiled before walking over towards him. "Are you gonna finish what you had been saying before you past out last night? Are you going to tell me how it ends?"

"How what ends?" Noah asked as he looked over at Audrey with a smile on his face.

"The towns murder mystery. Did Tyler do it, or is Brandon James back?"

Audrey smiled and winked at Noah before walking away. "Well, you gotta remember that the who-done-it might not be as important in our story."

"So it's more of a motive thing." Olivia nodded as she continued to talk. "It's more of a why did they do it-"

"No," Noah laughed, "you gotta forget that you're in a horror movie. That someone might die at every turn. See, you have to care if the smoking hot lit teacher seems a little too interested in his female students." Noah stated as the y walked by Branson's classroom and saw him talking to Brooke. "You have to care if the team wins the big game." The basketball team walked by. "You have to care if the smart pretty girl forgives the dumb jock." Olivia watched as Emma ignored Will.

"And what am I?" Olivia smiled as Noah faced her.

"The gorgeous girl that rules the school." Noah smiled back.

"I always thought that was Nina." Olivia stated.

"Nope." Noah said before awkwardly scratching his neck. "Anyways, you root for them, you love them, so when they are brutally murdered, it hurts."

*

"Come on, you gotta tell me!" Olivia smiled as she spoke into her phone. "How does the story end."

"You really wanna know?" Noah shot back. "Alright." He sighed. "Everyone has secrets, everyone tells lies, and everyone is fair game until there's no one left."

AN: I'm sorry that this chapter is kind of all over the place, but I did the best that I could with the episode. Thank you all for reading! 

Please comment ideas for later chapters, or message me. Also, don't forget to vote!

Have a nice day, lovelies 💞💞