Olivia stood in her room looking in her mirror at her costume. She had a tradition of being Tinkerbell ever year, and that would not stop. She smiled and pressed on the fluffiness of her skirt. Her phone beeped and she saw a message from one Brooke Maddox 'Hey, I know you're kinda still pissed off at me, but if the dance blows, which it will, come to my party. I love ya bunches. 😘'

Olivia sighed. She didn't even know if she had forgiven Brooke yet. She probably had just gotten over it. It was a while ago, and that shouldn't mess with their friendship now. Right? 'I'll be there.' She texted back.

She grabbed her party clothes because she knew she would want to change after she left the dance. "Someone looks hot." Olivia looked and saw Emma standing in her doorway. "Are you trying to impress Noah?"

"Please stop with all this Noah stuff." Olivia smiled at her sister. "I like being single."

"That was you're reason to why you didn't want to date Jake, and look what happened." Emma let out a laugh as she walked into Olivia's room. "Kieran has to do something, so I was thinking that we could ride together. Save gas."

"It would be like when we went trick-or-treating." Olivia giggled.

"Exactly." Emma smiled. "I'm happy that you're happy."

"I'm happy that I'm happy, too."

*

The two sisters walked into the dance. Olivia looked around and she spotted Jake wearing a Peter Pan costume. She frowned. "Yeah. I don't think I do this." She looked at Emma. "I'm sorry."

"I get it." Emma nodded. "Say hi to Brooke for me." Olivia kissed her sister's cheek before walking out.

Emma made her way over towards the punch bowl where her mom was. "Hi mom, how's chaperone duty?"

"Uneventful."

"Where's Clarke?" Emma asked her mother.

"I don't know." Maggie answered her. "He's not returning my texts. Must have gotten hung up."

"Well, that seems to run in the family." Emma smiled slightly at her mother. "Kieran is also very late."

"Mrs. D, looking lovely, as always." Jake stated as he appeared next to Emma.

"Flattering will get you nowhere, Jake." Maggie glared at the boy in front of her.

"But I can always try." Jake smirked. "One non-alcoholic drink, por favor."

"Of course." Maggie stated as she poured him a glass of punch.

He took the punch as Emma dragged him off. "What's up with that costume?" Emma questioned him.

"I thought that when Olivia would see it that she would be like 'Oh, we have matching couple costumes. It's meant to be'. She's always Tinkerbell. It was easy. Where is she anyways?

"She's not coming." Emma sighed. "She bailed on me."

"What?" Jake frowned before taking off the hat. "I wore this stupid costume for her."

"She's at Brooke's party." Emma told him as she walked off.

"Thank god, because this drink is undrinkable." Jake called after him as he took a sip of the punch. He made a face of disgust, and spit the punch back into the cup.

*

Olivia walked into Brooke's party and groaned as she watched the football players run by her. She walked by several people almost fucking against the wall. Where the hell was Brooke? She grabbed a bottle of vodka from some random table, and started drinking it.

Olivia came to a halt as she spotted the love seat near Brooke's pool. She smile and sat down. About ten minutes later, Audrey popped in, sitting next to Olivia. "Is Noah pissed at me?"

"A little bit, but not as much as Jake." Audrey chuckled a bit.

"Oh god." She laughed. "Why did you leave?" Olivia asked her.

"I showed Emma a video of Kieran with Nina that Rachel had filmed." Audrey explained to her. "It shows that he could be the killer, and she didn't want to listen to me."

"Olivia, hey." Olivia looked and saw Brooke walking over to them. "Audrey, I didn't expect to see you here."

"That makes two of us." Audrey sighed.

Olivia noticed a Brandon James mask in Brooke's hand. "Nice mask." She winked at Brooke. "Does someone have plans later?"

"It's tempting." Brooke chuckled. "I mean, some psycho wears this to kill our friends, and people treat it like its a joke."

"That's because people generally suck." Audrey mumbled, wondering why Brooke was even talking to her.

"I know." Brooke nodded. "Even the ones I like. Emma bailed on me, Jake spied on me, and everyone else, well, they're gone, so..." Brooke paused. "Looks like the two of you are officially my favorite people at this party."

"So, not exactly a banner day at the Maddox household." Audrey stated.

"Nope." Brooke shook her head.

"Well, I'm honored." Olivia smiled as she hugged her best friend.

"Well, Audrey, what brings you to my pity party?" Brooke asked her.

"I found something that shows that Emma might be sleeping with the enemy." Audrey explained to Brooke. "But, she didn't want to hear it, and I didn't want to see it."

"No." Brooke smiled. "Kieran can't be the killer. He's too pretty."

"Well, honey, if you think of it, Ted Bundy proved that hotness doesn't cancel out crazy." Olivia smiled at Brooke.

"I just don't want to see her get hurt." Audrey stated, setting her drink down.

"I know." Brooke nodded. "You're just looking out for her. It's what friends do. Or at least what they should do."

"You know, I kinda like this whole real human thing you got going on right now." Audrey smiled at Brooke.

Brooke chuckled. "Are you flirting with me?"

"Oh you wish." Audrey smirked at her. Brooke let out a laugh.

"Wow," Olivia smiled. "Look at the two of you bonding."

"Well, chicks before dicks." Audrey nudged Olivia with her elbow.

"Oh, let's not get crazy." Brooke chuckled as they all tapped their drinks together.

"Oh snap! Just in time for the hot lesbian threesome action." Jake smirked, obviously drunk. He had his arm around a girl, and was wearing her bunny ears.

"Speaking of dicks." Olivia groaned.

"I got you, hon." Brooke smiled at her best friend before turning to Jake. "Jake, I don't remember inviting you to my party."

"Come on, Brooke." Jake whined. "I think the Jake is the party." He turned to the other people at the party. "Can I get an 'amen'?!"

"Amen!" Everyone in the party cheered, besides Brooke, Audrey, and Olivia.

*

"First he tries to get me with the matching costumes, then he shows up with her." Olivia glared at Jake and the idiot who he was making out with.

"Men are pigs." Brooke groaned.

"True." Audrey nodded.

"She is literally dumb as toast." Brooke groaned. "And plus, you're so much hotter than her, O."

Olivia sighed, staring at the two of them. "Olivia, it's obvious he had nothing for her." Audrey said to Olivia. "Except for the rise he gets out of you."

"Well, Ms. Duval here has been known to make things rise herself, isn't that right, O." Brooke winked at her best friend.

"You're right." Olivia nodded.

She looked around the party, looking for the perfect victim. She looked back at Audrey and smirked. "What?" Audrey asked her.

"Stand up." Olivia stated as she stood.

Audrey stood up, unsure of what was going on. "Why, exactly, am I standi-"

Olivia cut her off by smashing her lips on hers. She could practically feel Jake's glare burning through her. Audrey's hands moved to Olivia's waist as she kissed her back.

Olivia pulled away and looked over at Jake. She smiled and winked at him. "Well played." Audrey smiled at Olivia.

"Thank you." Olivia smiled back.

"Anyways," Brooke chuckled, "could the two of you do me a solid? Do not let the unwashed messes into my house."

Olivia looked over at Audrey. "Don't tell me you're leaving me, too."

"I just gotta pee, and then I'll be back out." Olivia smiled before walking inside. She made her way up to the bathroom, and heard the door open. "Come on, I just gotta pee!" She exclaimed as she saw Jake standing in the doorway.

"What the hell was that?" Jake snapped at her as he closed the door.

"It's called making you jealous. It's exactly what you were doing to me." Olivia smirked at him. "It's not very fun, is it?"

Jake rolled his eyes. "You could have kissed anyone, but Audrey?" Jake asked her, moving closer. "Why her?"

"What's wrong with me kissing Audrey?!" Olivia snapped at him.

"Because then, they're going to be rumors going around that you're gay." Jake snapped at her. "And then those rumors would turn into that I made you gay."

"First of all, I'm not gay. Second of all, can you not think of yourself for one second, please?!"

"Fine." Jake smirked. "Let's talk about you, and you're little slasher movie geek. He's going to hear that you made out with his best friend in the entire world." Olivia's eyes widened. "You didn't think of that, did you?" Jake chuckled.

"He's not going to find out." Olivia snapped at him. "And you're not going to tell him."

"My lips are sealed." Jake smiled before walking out the door. Olivia did not need to pee anymore. Olivia opened the door to the bathroom and saw the killer standing there with a knife. She felt a sharp pain in her shoulder and felt to the ground hitting her head. Her vision blurred until everything went black.

AN: this story is literal trash, but updating is my guilty pleasure. Jake and Olivia are my guilty ship, but Noah and Olivia are OTP. Also, Olivia and Audrey are BroTP. 

Please comment and vote. 

Have a nice day, lovelies 💞💞