Why do we ship Keefe and Sophie? Because of their chemistry. They have a spark that's not there because Keefe was asked to be friends with her. In book 1, he could've walked away from her being lost. But no, he took her to Elwin. He stayed with her. In book 2, she trusted him to go to the Black Swan. Reminder: This was still when they didn't know if they were good or bad. In book 3, he was there for her. All through book 3, who knew about the notes? Sandor and... you got it. Keefe. She trusts him. Not because of his ability, but because of who he is. In book 4, their relationship was a bit messy. But every great relationship needs to be messy. A ship that both parties can break up with each other and forget is not a ship I can get behind. I get behind a ship that's messy and amazing and they can't break up since they have been through everything together and would sacrifice the world for each other. That's a ship I can get behind. That's a ship I can ship with all my heart. That's a ship that can win.