(this is gonna be a two shot)

"Y/N? Are you alright?" Jonathan asked waving a hand in your face. You quickly snapped out of your thoughts and turned your attention to him.

"Why of course Jojo! Why wouldn't I be?" you chirped.

"You just seemed a tad bit stressed out. If you don't mind me asking, are you alright?" he asked. The truth was you were a little stressed. Jonathan was your best friend ever since you could remember. He would always defend you and protect you and it made you fall for him. You two were sitting on the small hill watching the sunset with Danny.

"Oh it's nothing Jojo I am....um... just thinking about s-schoolwork." you tried to come up with an excuse but failed.

"Are you sure (y/n)? You know that you could tell me anything. I will always be here for you." he said in a sweet tone.

Your face started to heat up. This is one of the reasons that you are falling for him. What are you supposed to say?! You like Jonathan and you don't want to scare him off by revealing your feelings. Danny started to notice that you looked really flustered and started to poke your dress.

"Oh Jonathan I think that Danny wants to head back to your manor." you said quickly changing the subject.

"You are right" he said standing up "do you mind if I take your hand my lady?" he asked with such politeness.

"Of course my lord." you replied with mock curtsy. You let out a small giggle. "I say Jojo you are so close to becoming a true gentleman." He scratched the back of his head while a light pink blush spread across his cheeks.

"Th-Thank you (y/n)" he stuttered. Soon you two arrived at his mansion. "(y/n) would you please allow me to walk you back home?"

"Yes Jojo! You are acting as if you don't always walk me home!" you joked.

"S-sorry I must have forgotten."

"There is no need to apologize Jojo. Lighten up a little!" you said playfully punching his arm. The two of you continued chatting until you reached your mansion.

"Goodbye Jojo! I will see you tomorrow!" you said giving him a small hug. He returned the favor and then left.

The Next Day

You walked over to hang out with Jonathan. School was canceled due to some problems with the teachers so you decided to spend the day with Jonathan. You reached your destination and saw a carriage in front of the estate. You didn't know that anyone was coming to see the Joestars today so you were a bit curious. Soon a blond boy jumped from the carriage and started talking to Jonathan.

"Hello Jonathan!" he turned to face you and his face immediately started smiling even more.

"Why hello (y/n)!" he cheered while giving you a small hug.

"Now Jojo who is this?" someone asked. It almost sounded like they were mocking him. You turned to see the blond boy talking to Jonathan.

"Oh (y/n) this is Dio Brando. He will be living with me for the time being." Jonathan explained. It almost sounded like he wasn't that excited anymore.

"Hello Mr. Brando my name is (y/n) (l/n). It is a pleasure to meet you!" you said extending you hand for him to shake it. Instead he knelt down and gave your hand a small kiss.

"The pleasure is all mine. Please call me Dio"

"O-Okay."

"(y/n) you should go inside I will be there in a moment." Jonathan said interrupting your little "moment". He sounded a bit jealous but you brushed it off. You nodded and left. Actually you left right before Dio kicked Danny. Things seemed fine. Dio seemed nice and you still had a great relationship with Jonathan. Things can't go that bad can it?

7 Years Later (deal with it)

It's been seven years now. You became a mature young lady. To most you seemed like the perfect woman. They would see you as quiet, obedient, respectful, and sweet. Haha no. Actually you were pretty smart, and enjoyed reading which was something no man wanted. No man would ever marry a woman that was smarter than him. Although you were very kind you always stood up for your opinion. You liked talking and being social but you were a bit lazy. Dresses that you had to wear always made you a bit uncomfortable. That's just who you were and what you felt like. You try to be what everyone want you to be but you just can't. Nobody ever really saw the real you. Well almost everybody. There are only three people knew who you really were. The first one being Jonathan Joestar your bestfriend. Then there was George Joestar. He became like a father to you and you were more comfortable being yourself around him than your own parents. He loved you like you were his own daughter and secretly hoped that one day you would marry Jonathan or Dio. And finally there was Dio Brando you other bestfriend. Dio has been living with the Joestars for a little over 7 years. At first he was kind and respectful towards you but soon you found out about the abuse he was putting Jonathan through. You called him out on it and after that you hated him. But that was the past. One night your parents were murdered while you were staying over at Jonathan's mansion. You remembered crying the whole night and Jonathan comforting you until it was time for you to go to bed. You couldn't sleep and kept on crying until Dio came into your room and comforted you until you fell asleep into his arms. You got to know him better after that. You two would talk about personal things and he always found a way to make you smile. The two of you had common interest and you cared about him the way you cared about Jonathan. Now here's your problem. When you were 13 you had a crush on Jojo but now you didn't know who you liked. Well you knew who you liked you just didn't now who you liked more. Jonathan or Dio.

"Interception! The ball is plucked out of the air by our hero, Jonathan Joestar!" the announcer yelled. You quickly snapped out of your thoughts and turned your attention back to the game. You were currently at one of Dio and Jojo's football games cheering them on as usual. You aren't a big fan of football but you always came to support them. You watched as Jojo raced across the field with the ball in his hands. The way his big muscular body moved made you blush. His pecs, his big strong arms, his thighs, and his.......NO. He is your friend and you can't think of him like that. What you didn't know was that Dio saw you staring at Jonathan. Lets just say he wasn't happy. At all. You watch as some men tackle him slowing him down.

"Come on Jojo. You can do it!" you yelled in hopes that he would hear you. Thankfully he did and kept on walking towards the finish line (idk how sports work) But then two more guys jumped on him. The weight was too much for him to handle so he threw the ball to the other side of the field. Thankfully Dio ran up and caught the ball.

"Go Dio! Run!" you shouted. The women stared at you in disgust. No woman should be behaving like this. But you really didn't care and kept on shouting with the men. Dio crossed the line and won the game for his team. You got up from your seats and picked up the layers of fabric from your dress and started running towards them.

"You two did amazing!" you said while jumping into Jojo's arms giving him a hug and doing the same for Dio. However when you hugged Dio he wrapped his arms around you very tight as if he never wanted to let go.

"I don't think we would have been able to win without your encouragement (y/n)!" Jonathan stated.

"I must agree with Jojo on that one" Dio said. You started blushing. I mean, are they really thanking you for helping them win the game. They did all of the work so why are they thanking you?! You pushed away your thoughts and continued talking.

"Oh please! I didn't do anything. It was you two who made this victory happen! Why don't you two go tell your father the big news!" you exclaimed. They nodded in agreement got in a carriage because it was the fastest way to their house. You let the two be alone with their father because you know, it was their father. When they were done talking to him they left the room. You entered it to see Mr. Joestar laying on his be coughing.

(for the sake of this oneshot Dio didn't poison him. George just has a cold.)

"Hello Mr. Joestar" you greeted.

"Why hello (y/n). It's a pleasure to see you again. Please do not come near me. It would be awful if you were to catch my cold." he said.

"Why of course. That reminds me I brought you this from London. It is a medicine that I'm sure will help you." you said gently placing the medicine on the table.

"You are too kind. I am grateful that you would do that for me. I am afraid that if this cold worsens it could end the time that I have on this earth. I just wanted you to know that you have always been like a daughter to me. I would love it if you would ever marry Jonathan or even Dio but I could never force you to do something like that. Please try not to let my sickness worry you"

"Thank you Mr. Joestar. The fact that you consider me as a daughter to you makes me feel better. You don't have to worry about anything. I will be fine" you said.

"If you don't mind I will take a small nap."

"It's okay I will leave the room so you can rest. Goodbye Mr. Joestar" After than you left the room. You decided to head to the library to see if there was anything interesting to read. You walked around the bookshelves looking for something. You noticed that Dio was sitting in one of the plush chairs reading a book.

"Dio you never told me that you had that book. It's one of my favorites!" you chirped. Your sudden appearance made him jump back a little.

"I know that this is your favorite. I never read it so I wanted to see why you enjoyed it so much" he stated.

"Well do you like it?" you asked.

"I've read worse. It is not that bad but I don't see why you would like it." he said. The book you two were talking about was Frankenstein by Mary Shelly.

"I find it interesting by the way it is told. The fact that the author would express the monster's emotion so deeply really interests me." you answered.

"(Y/N) you have no idea how happy I am to have someone to talk about books with. Most woman do not no how to read and they wouldn't think of telling others their opinion."

"Well reading won't exactly find me a husband" you joked. You looked at Dio and saw that he had a serious expression.

"(Y/N)"

"Y-Yes Dio?"

He came close to you and now his face was a few inches away from yours.

"There was something that I have always wanted to tell you"

"W-What might that be?" you nervously asked nervously asked. He grinned at you and opened his mouth so he could answer your question.

"I always wanted to tell you that I l-"

"Master Dio and Ms. (L/N), I am here to inform you that dinner is ready" the butler announced. Man, if looks could kill that butler would have been dead in an instant. He let out a heavy sigh.

"Yes thank you we will be there momentarily." You two walked to the dining table in silence. Dinner was quiet. Very quiet. Too quiet.

After dinner you walked towards the front door only to have Jonathan grab your wrist.

"Oh I-I'm sorry I didn't mean to grab your wrist. I was just wondering if you could stay the night." you agreed to stay over instead of going home. Being honest there wasn't really much of a home to go back to. Sure the butlers and maids were there but you got tired of being alone. It was getting late so you walked to the guest bedroom. Jojo once made a joke that it was your own personal bedroom because you stayed at their house so often.

The Next Day

You ate breakfast with Jonathan and Dio and decided to continue reading your favorite book. Jonathan followed you until you sat down and opened his mouth to say something but no words came out. So he tried again.

"(Y/N) w-would you care to go on a w-walk with me?" he stuttered. Why is he so nervous? You two took walks together plenty of times.

"Of Course!"

He took you to the garden and you had your arm linked to his. Things were silent but it was a comforting silence. The view was breathtaking. The flowers bloomed leaving a beautiful sight. The sun was shining but not to brightly. The wind was nice and breezy and not to harsh.

"H-Hey (Y/N), I need to tell you something." He said.

"What is it Jojo?" You asked with your voice filled with concern. Jonathan wasn't always this nervous. He was acting so weird towards you today. Did you do something to upset him?

"N-Nothing! Oh who am I kidding. Look (Y/N) you are the most incredible woman I have ever had the honor of meeting. You are smart, sweet, confident, and beautiful. You are always there to help those you care about and others. I love you for who you are and not what you try to pretend to be. I-I love you" he finished. You just stood there not knowing what to say. You loved him but some part of you also loved Dio. Either way your face became really red. Like you kinda looked like a tomato.

"Jonathan I-"

"(Y/N)! Thank goodness you are alright! You left without saying anything. You had me worried sick!" Someone shouted. You and Jonathan turned around to see the one and only Dio Brando.

"S-sorry I w-"

"Dio, do you mind leaving me and (y/n) alone. I was talking to her about an important matter." Jonathan butted in.

"Well Jojo if it involves (y/n) than it involves me. I have something I need to tell her too!" Dio stated. Their voices seemed to slowly grow more anger in them when they were talking to each other.

"Dio this does not concern you" Jojo growled.

"I believe it does Jojo" They started arguing and you were just kinda there. Watching two beefy men argue about talking to you.

"Aright that's enough!" you yelled. The two stopped talking and both faced you at the same time. "Just say whatever needs to be said. You two are acting like children!" you scolded placing your hands on your hips.

"Okay then" Jonathan said regaining his composure.

"I believe that I should speak first. After all you had time to talk to her before I got here" Dio spoke "(Y/N). I love you. I love you for everything you do. You are smart, caring, and gorgeous. Please tell me you feel the same."

"Well (y/n). Who is it going to be?" Jojo asked.

"Uh I choose......"

To be continued

Oooh Cliffhanger. I'm gonna make a part two I promise. However here is the catch. You people can vote on who you want. If Jonathan gets the most votes then part 2 will be for Jonathan if Dio gets the most votes than part 2 will be for Dio. The second part will be a lemon chapter. Ooh la la. However if enough people vote for both of them well then I guess I am going to be writing a threesome >:3. I'll let your dirty minds decide what you want (aka kinks). Let the voting begin!

(2730 words)