RE-RECORDINGS:

Mine: 6/10 I'm not sure how to feel about this it felt slower?

Sparks Fly: 3/10 It feels a lot slower and the vocals got pushed out and feel so far away from the actual lyrics and my baby what was done to you.

Back to December: 8/10 Got better! I liked the changes. Team Jeremiah (In the show. In the books on Team Conrad)

Speak Now: 6/10 Proud to say I liked this song before the TV. This actually felt like a re-recording. Just wish it was more snobby. The background vocals just felt so far away. You could barely hear them.

Dear John: 9/10 IT GOT SO MUCH BETTER!! I didn't like the original that much but I like this. I just wish there was more emotion. That was an overall problem with this TV. The emotion fell flat

Mean: 2/10 Oh no. This was one of my favorite songs in the original but—oh no. No country accent? I am scared for Debut TV. Mean, you deserved so much better than this I am so sorry

The Story of Us: 5/10 "I never heard silence quite this loud" felt so flat, it was my favorite part of the original song. The "next chapter" and "the end" we're good though

Never Grow Up: 8/10 I liked this one. Not much to say about it but I liked it in her mature voice

Enchanted: 8/10 I didn't like it, then I did, then I didn't, then I did. The bridge was good, the verses weren't

Better Than Revenge: 4.5/10 "Now go stand in the corner and think about what you did" was awesome and gave me high hopes but the rest was...meh. The lyric change was poetic and all but...RIP the mattress. Someone on Tumblr said Taylor should have released two versions of this and she was right. Like, you hung out with Matty Healy, opening racist and problematic in general but we're silent, but change this because you're afraid of backlash? Are you joking?

Innocent: 6/10 I never really liked this song but it was good I guess. Stayed the same to me

Haunted: 4/10 WHAT HAPPENED? THE ECHOS I THOUGHT THE SONG WAS GLITCHING. Maybe it's echoing because ghosted and stuff she's haunted? Idk. I didn't like it. Once again, there was no emotion. Still, points because its Haunted.

Last Kiss: 6/10 good I guess? Stayed the same

Long Live: 10/10 ACTUALLY GOOD. THANK YOU TAYLOR, THIS WAS A RE-RECORDING

Ours: 7/10 Don't have anything to say really

Superman: 8/10 I don't really like this song but it was a good re-recording! This should've been what the rest of the album was like

VAULT TRACKS:

Electric Touch: 9/10 THIS SONG GOES SO HARD I LOVE IT. Somehow it was Taylor and Fall Out Boy at the same time it was really good.

When Emma Falls In Love: 10/10 Aiden Acharya coded

I Can See You: 6/10 TAYLOR HOW HORNY WERE YOU??

Castle Crumbing: 5/10 Wasn't bad but wasn't good it was just kind of...there

Foolish One: 6/10 Nothing really stood out to me, I can see why this didn't make the original album

Timeless: 3.5/10 Catchy but...why the romanticization of war? What was the point of that? Didn't feel very Speak Now-y

OVERALL:

6/10 it could have been so much better and had so much potential. It didn't feel like the same vibe at all. WEFIL is a masterpiece though, two points just for that. I liked the original so much better

Ok, now I am going on No-Taylor-Music boy/girlcott