Dean: Why do you hate me, Star?

Star: I don't hate you. I just really like to mess with people.

Ash: Star, I don't even like this kind of pie. *looks at the cherry pie on the table*

Star: Fine. Cas? Can you and Ash switch pies?

Castiel: Alright. *pushes key lime pie in front of Ash and takes her cherry pie*

Ash: oh. Thanks!

Castiel: That's alright.

Dean: I hate this. *tied to a chair in front of everyone*

Becky: *smiling happily as she eats a chocolate pie*

Sam: *unintentionally staring at Ash and Gabe*

Ash: Sam? Do you know I know?

Sam: I know.

Becky: What?

Ash: I know.

Gabriel: Know what?

Ash: Nothing.

Dean: Why must you all torture me?

Gabriel: Can I have another?

Ash: Did you turn your pie into cake, Gabe?

Castiel: We don't need to eat this.

Star: Just do it.

Castiel: ...Okay.

Chuck: I like pie. And Sam?

Sam: What? *takes a bite of pie*

Chuck: I know as well.

Sam: *chokes* *choughs*

Dean: This is Hellll! ;(

-Bonus for Sky-

Chuck: Come on Sky!

Sky: Yeah.

Chuck and Sky: *awsome mid air high five*