News Anchorwoman: This just in, PLASTIC-MAN GONE ROGUE? That's what have Metropolis citizens thinking as just this afternoon, the so-called "hero" was spotted robbing Metropolis Bank and leaving mass destruction all around Midtown. Police have issued a warrant for not only the arrest of Plastic-Man but also issued the reveal of his identity once he is captured. We'll have more to speak about this soon

You toss the remote at the TV causing the screen to break. After finding out about the whole "Fake Plastic-Man" news, you, the girls, Garth and Barry were hanging out in the base trying to figure out who was impersonating you

Y/n: Ugh! This can't be happening to me. It just can't!

Garth: Maybe it's an evil twin from an alternate universe?

Kara: If it was a Bizzaro Y/n, he would be doing everything opposite of him. It looks like this guy is deliberately trying to cause mayhem in Metropolis

Garth: Wait, you mean they actually do exist?!

Barry: Maybe he was brainwashed?

Y/n: How could I rob a bank and be with Zee at the same time?!

Zee: Guys, it's obvious. Someone is pretending to be Plastic Man and committing crimes all around Metropolis. We just need to figure out who

Jess: Zee is right, everyone, split up and start searching for any "Rogue Plastic Man" activity

Y/n: Great, count me in, I'll grab my costume-

You turn to leave only for Jess to construct a wall in front of you

Jess: Oh no you don't, you're staying here

Y/n: Aw what?

Babs: Sorry, Y/n, but it'd be confusing for us if you came along a hunt for...well, you

Zee: I'll stay with you so you don't get lonely

Y/n: Thanks, and you're right. I'm just so...angry!

Barry: Don't worry, we'll find them

Diana: No one attacks one of our comrades! Brothers and Sisters, let us make haste!

After everyone makes their way out to start scouting, you sit on the couch and reflect on the 8 months you've been in Metropolis and everything you've been through with your friends while Zee sits next to you and comforts you.

Zee: Are you gonna be okay?

Y/n: Yeah, yeah I'll be fine...it's just...I came to Metropolis for a fresh start and now it just looks like everything is coming to bite me right in the back...

Zee: What do you mean?

Y/n: Can I be honest with you?

Zee: Always

Y/n: Back in Gotham, I was a really dumb kid...I stole whatever I can get my hands on around my school. Got so frequent people started calling me "The Eel" because of how slippery I was. Then one day, this girl came up to me and offered me a deal. She wanted my help stealing an answer sheet for an upcoming chemistry exam. Everything went smoothly until he showed up...

Zee: Until "who", showed up?

Y/n: The Batman...

(Flashback 10 months ago)

You don't know why the heck you decided to take this girl's deal. She has no idea how to break into buildings. Your entrance was her throwing a giant rock into the window and smashing it completely. As long as you're in and out without getting caught, you were perfectly fine with it. You entered through the window into the chemistry class and look around the classroom. Perfectly empty, the perfect opportunity to rob an answer sheet.

Y/n: Alright, we're gonna make this quick. Grab the answer sheet and let's head out

Girl: Hold your horses, I wanna check out anything else I wanna grab before we leave

Y/n: Fine, but quickly and quietly, please

Girl: Whatever, loser. Hey, check this out

The girl motions to a rack with samples of dirt and clay, along with different chemicals.

Y/n: This has to be the dumbest way to stock chemicals for a class...

Girl: There's another shelf over there, go see what's on it

You check out the shelf on the other side of the room and see more chemicals on it, you notice the viscosity of the chemical, almost as if it was liquid rubber

Y/n: Yeah, well there's nothing really valuable here...

Girl: How about we change my grade then

Y/n: I already told you, in and out. Let's get this answer sheet already

Girl: Roger that, "Eel Boy"

You pull out your tools and get to work on the locked desk drawer

Y/n: I have a name you know

Girl: No kiddin, huh? Next, you're gonna say something like, "I eat when I feel hungry"

Y/n: Haha, very funny

Girl: What is your name anyway?

Y/n: It's Y/n

Girl: Y/n, huh? I'm Basila-

When she says her name, you finally manage to unlock the drawer and grab the answer sheet

Basila: - and this my friend is gonna be the start of a beautiful relationship

Suddenly, lightning flashes revealing a large, bat-shaped figure standing behind you. Your eyes go wide as the figure punches you into Basila, who in turn gets knocked into the shelf with the rocks and chemicals on it, causing them to spill all over her. You get up and try to escape, but the figure grabs you and tosses you into the chemicals on the other shelf, causing them to spill on you as well. You try to get up, but find that you can't as you are literally melting into the floor. You try to reach out to Basila, but she climbs out of the window and escapes, leaving you with the figure

The figure walks up to you and reveals himself to be Batman, he injects something into your arm, and the next thing you know, you're waking up in a hospital, 2 months later completely fine.

Y/n: I-I'm alive? W-Where am I?

Doctor: Woah relax there. You're perfectly fine, you're in Gotham Hospital. You got into a nasty accident 2 months ago and have been in a coma ever since. You're lucky to be alive, Y/n

Y/n: 2 months...what happened to me?

Doctor: Got in a car accident, nasty one at that. You'll never believe the guy who hit you

Just then your mom and dad rush in and hug you

Mom: Are you okay? Is nothing broken anymore?

Y/n: Anymore?!

Dad: Doc's said you broke both your legs and an arm. We didn't think you were gonna be able to walk again

Y/n: I don't think anything is broken.

You get up and start walking perfectly fine

Y/n: Yeah, I'm perfectly fine

???: Well, that's good to hear

You turn to see none other than Bruce Wayne walk into your hospital room

Y/n: Bruce Wayne?... What are you doing here?

Bruce: Yeah, about that...the car you got hit by was actually my car

Y/n: What?!

Mom: Mr. Wayne felt bad about what happened and bought you here himself. He called us and told us what happened

Doctor: He even offered to pay for your hospital bill

Dad: The point is if it wasn't for Mr. Wayne's quick thinking here, you probably would've died

Y/n:

Later that night after being cleared out of the hospital and going back home, you're brushing your teeth in the bathroom. You couldn't help but think about that night at Gotham High. You knew you weren't hit by a car, there was no way since you never made it out of the building. So why is everyone telling you that you were in a car accident? You couldn't help but wonder when suddenly your elbow starts drooping down slowly until it hits the floor. You drop your toothbrush and look at your arm entirely, as it's now the size of the world's longest spaghetti noodle. Your other arm slowly starts doing the same thing and falls to the floor. You speed walk to your room hoping no one sees your arms getting dragged along with you, and lock your door using your teeth. You breathe heavily as your arms finally start returning to normal

Y/n: What the heck is happening to me...

???: I can answer that for you

You turn around to see Batman standing in front of your bed

You scream at the top of your lungs until he puts his hand over your mouth to shut you up

Batman: Listen here, kid. You're gonna have to trust me on this. Now I'm gonna let go, and you're gonna listen to what I have to say. Do I make myself clear?

You nervously nod as Batman moves his hand off of your mouth

Batman: Now, you weren't in a car accident

Y/n: Don't you think I know that already? I'm not an idiot.

Batman: So you remember what happened that night at the high school right?

Y/n: Yeah, but how do you-...

It then clicks into your brain. Everything that happened that night with Batman and how Bruce Wayne hit you with his car when you know you were never in a car accident. You look as Batman removes his mask to reveal that he is, in fact, Bruce Wayne

Y/n: You're...him?...You're Batman?!

Bruce: Yep, it's my fault this is happening to you. You were bathed in an unknown industrial chemical mixture that also entered your bloodstream through a cut on your cheek. Your entire physiology changed due to this mixture, and your body is now in what I would call a "fluid state"

Y/n: A "fluid state"?

Bruce: Correct, your body is now neither liquid nor solid. You're completely malleable, almost exactly like rubber

Y/n: You're kidding right? I don't wanna be like this for the rest of my life!

Bruce: Sorry, but what's done is done. And it wouldn't have happened if you hadn't broken into that school. You're lucky I didn't turn you or your friend in for that.

Y/n: So what do I do?

Bruce: You keep living like a low-rate criminal and I put you in prison, or you can choose to reform and I'll move you out of this city for a better life

You thought about it for a minute and decided it'd be best to move out of Gotham

Y/n: Alright, I'll become a hero...just like you. But only because I want a better life for me and my family...

Bruce: Fair game, alright, I'll make some calls and we'll move you over to Metropolis soon

Bruce puts his mask back on and gets ready to climb out your window onto the fire escape

Y/n: Hey Bruce?

Bruce: Yeah?

Y/n: Thanks, for everything

Bruce: Don't mention it

Bruce leaps off the fire escape and glides off into the night as you look at your arms

Y/n: A hero, huh?...

(End Flashback)

Y/n: 2 months after that night, my mom got a job working at STAR Labs and moved my family here to Metropolis.

Zee: Wow, that's a lot to take in...do you want me to get some fudge from Sweet Justice and help take your mind off things?

Y/n: I'd like that...

Zee: I'll be right back then

Zee goes to leave up to Sweet Justice and you sit back on the couch, waiting for her to come back. After a few minutes, you hear someone come down the entrance.

Y/n: That was fast? Did Barry have to go to work today or- OOF!

You turn around only to get punched by your imposter. You spit out a tooth and regain your composure and make your fists into mallets

Y/n: You're gonna rue the day you decided to ruin my life!

Imposter: Funny, I can say the same exact thing!

The imposter makes mallets out of their own hands, but they look like they're made of dirt and clay instead of their actual body. The two of you fight it out, throwing punch after punch until the imposter gains the upper hand and puts you into a choke hold, pinning you to the wall

Imposter: 10 MONTHS! I HAVE WAITED FOR THIS DAY FOR 10 MONTHS!

Y/n: Waited for what?! What did I ever do to you?!

Imposter: You still don't get it, huh? Then lemme refresh your memory...Eel Boy...

Y/n: Eel Boy?...

Just as it clicks into your head, the imposter molds itself into a female figure, covered head to toe in dirt and clay. You immediately recognized her

Y/n: Basila?...

A/N: I hope you enjoyed this MEGA CHAPTER cuz holy crap this took so long to write. I'm working on part 2 as we speak so it'll be out sometime later today. Now we got a new character, and I'm having so much fun writing for her! Let's see what happens next chapter huh?