(Meanwhile, In an alternate universe)

Twilight, Applejack, Fluttershy, Rarity and Rainbow struggled against the ropes that tied them back. They didn't what was happening, how it happened, why it happened and who brought them here, but they did know that they were in big trouble.

"I don't understand... Why are we here ?" Rainbow asked, trying to set herself free.

"Don't ask me ! What do I know ?" Twilight protested.

"You've read so many books, so I assume you know a lot !" 

"This isn't the time to be funny ! Let's think about how to get out of here !" Rarity interrupted.

"Don't worry.. You'll be free, alright. For eternity.." Pinkie said as she stepped out of the shadows. Her hair was straight, and part of it was falling on her face. Her eyes were red, instead of blue. Blood red, to be exact.

"What are you talking about ?" Applejack asked.

"Remember how you drive a knife through the apples' cores everyday, Applejack ? Well, I'm just gonna drive one through yours." Pinkamena replied, pulling out a knife from behind her.

"You can't do this ! The police will find you out !" Twilight protested. Pinkamena let out a sound somewhere between a snort and a laugh.

"Do you have any idea how long I've been doing this for ?" She said. She stepped over to the wall and flicked on a light switch. Instantly, ten bodies came into view.

"The Dazzlings ?" Applejack questioned.

"Principal Cinch ?" Twilight muttered.

"The Shadowbolts ?" Rainbow stopped struggling.

"And.. Sunset Shimmer ?" Rarity scrunched up her face in confusion.

"More like her human world's counterpart." Pinkie explained. "Before the Fall Formal fiasco, I saw her outside a coffee shop and brought her in here. Killed her. Boy, I was so disappointed when she came to school the next day."

During all of this, Fluttershy hid behind a curtain of her hair, holding back quiet sobs.

"Am I the only one who's glad that Cinch died ?" Twilight muttered under her breath.

"Well.." Pinkie turned the light off. The girls were part glad since they couldn't look at the bodies, and part scared, as they didn't know what was to come.

"Let's begin, shall we ?" She finished, taking slow, small steps, towards Fluttershy. And, my readers, I'm very sorry to say this, but as you know, Pinkamena also exists in the human world, which, technically is our world, and...

You're next.