Suzy: ...So. Let's stick to the issue of the items in the bar, shall we?

Emily: Yes...      I'd like to discuss how they got there in the first place...

Edmond: Well, the wine bottle was in the bar from the start. As for the rest of the items, though...

Pedro: It's a mystery.

Richard: ...Maybe instead, we can first talk about the meaning of each item being in the bar, then try to figure out how they got there. Or the other way round, it doesn't really matter.

Edmond: Good idea Richard. Let's discuss.

) Nonstop Debate (

- Broken Wine Bottle
- Cardboard Box
- Teatowel

Richard: Very well then...      Starting off with the possible usage of each of the items.
(Broken Wine Bottle)

Candy: The wine bottle was used as a counterattack in the bar, so we can cross that off.
(Broken Wine Bottle)

Freddy: As for everything else, they...      Th-They must've been used in a different way...
(Broken Wine Bottle)

Kylie: Maybe the broken mop was used in the bar?
(Broken Wine Bottle)

George: The mop came from the janitor's closet, but I don't think it could've been used effectively in the bar...
(Broken Wine Bottle)

Rebecca: ...Hold on. Wasn't Danny...      Bleeding from his neck?
(Broken Wine Bottle)

Zoe: Yeah. Why do you ask?
(Cardboard Box)

Rebecca: It's just that...      If Danny was carried to his dorm from the bar...      Wouldn't there have been a lot more blood between the two places?
(Teatowel)

Peppa: No, that's wrong!

} BREAK {

Peppa: Wait a minute. I think that there's something that wasn't found in the bar that could answer that, Rebecca.

Rebecca: Really...?

Peppa: Think about the teatowel that we found underneath Danny's head.

Pedro: I don't get it.

Suzy: ...Actually, I think that Peppa's onto something. Think about it like this: After Danny died, he was bleeding heavily from the neck, and the culprit needed to patch it up. 

Suzy: By wrapping the teatowel around his neck, they made a temporary bandage to try and prevent the bleeding for the duration of the transport to Danny's room.

Suzy: However, it appears that it only lasted until the janitor's closet, considering the drips of blood...

Pedro: Oh! ...Wait. Didn't we testify that this whole case was planned just a few moments ago?

Zoe: So...    Does that mean that the teatowel was also in the bar at a certain time?

Peppa: Yeah...

Edmond: Hold on...      There's quite a few teatowels in the storage room. They're next to normal sized towels.

Emily: ...Are there any arrows there too?

Edmond: Oh yeah, quite a few.

Emily: And any cardboard boxes?

Edmond: There's an entire corner filled with different sizes of boxes in that room.

Emily: ...I think we've found where the items originally came from.

Edmond: Yeah, I was considering that thought...

Pedro: So how did they get up there?

George: Considering their planning...      Something tells me that they hid a stash in the bar.

Candy: What do you mean?

George: W-Well...     You could easily fit a few arrows, a teatowel and a handgun into that cardboard box, right? 

Zoe: ...Pretty sure that you could.

Edmond: Yep, you definitely can.

George: So if you were to take said box with said items inside it and hide it in...    Let's say the corner of a dark room, would anyone be able to find it?

Kylie: Nah, don't think so. Especially if it were closed.

George: Exactly. And considering what was known to be used in the bar, as well as the location of the box when we found it...

Richard: That's...        Pretty ingenious thinking, George. It's kind of making me feel a bit hot and bothered, actually.

George: ...

George: ...It's making him feel how...?

Richard: George...?

George: ...Oh, uh, thanks! Thanks...

Richard: Don't mention it. Anyways, going on the basis that a stash was set up in the bar by the killer...     What could each of the items in that stash have in usage towards Danny's death?

Kylie: ...I might have a few ideas!

) Nonstop Debate (

- Arrows
- Missing Janitorial Key
- Blood Drips

Kylie: So then! I'm considering what the arrows could be for, and my first guess was that they're some kind of slip up made by the killer...
(Arrows)

Kylie: My second guess was that they're (just a red herring)!
(Arrows)

Kylie: Anyone else got any other ideas?
(just a red herring)

Zoe: Well...     At first I thought that they could've had something to do with killing Danny...
(just a red herring)

Zoe: But then we all agreed that it was the gun, so I discarded that thought.
(just a red herring)

Richard: Well...      I personally don't know why the arrows are there.
(just a red herring)

Emily: It's fine, it's not like we can't figure out why they're there.
(just a red herring)

Emily: There has to be some reason for why they're there...
(just a red herring)

Peppa: No, that's wrong!

} BREAK {

Peppa: Or maybe, there's no reason for them to be there whatsoever! 

Emily: Huh?

Peppa: Maybe it's like what Kylie suggested earlier: They're a red herring!

Zoe: You're saying that they're meant to try and throw us off track?

Pedro: Now that I think about it...     Considering that list of weapons that I read earlier, as well as the weirdly clean state of the arrows...

Pedro: That might've been a failed attempt to try and frame someone of the crime!

Pedro: ...Right, Richard?

Richard: ...Seems like it. But let's recall ourselves to a major thing about this case - The noises that we heard during the murder.

Richard: Do those sound like noises that a bow and arrow would make?

Pedro: ...Nope. Which is why I'm saying that it's a framing of you. Not in the best way, yeah, but still.

Freddy: ...

Candy: ...So. What now.

Suzy: Maybe...     We can talk about when this stash was hidden?

Pedro: I'm pretty sure that I know that! It was after the killer left the pool!

Zoe: ...Are you crazy? It makes a lot more sense if it was before the pool party altogether.

Edmond: I agree with Zoe. You wouldn't have enough time otherwise.

Suzy: I kind of want to agree with Pedro. It just seems like the right option, for some reason.

Emily: ...Maybe Pedro has a point...

Peppa: Guys...    What kind of sense does Pedro even have in his statement?!

Pedro: Hey!

Monopotato: Uh oh, uh oh! Split decision!

Pedro: AHHHHH-

Emily: ...Split decision?

Monopotato: Please don't tell me that you completely forgot the first trial.

Kylie: Uh...      I kinda did.

Monopotato: Ugh, fine. Grab onto your trial stands everyone. We're going up!

Peppa: Going up...?

Peppa: ...

Peppa: ...Wait.

Peppa: Oh god, not this again.

https://youtu.be/32GWbQt_Zn4

Monopotato: Welcome back to our dearest roof and bell! Now then, GET TO SCRUMMING!

}/^/{ Scrum Debate }/^/{

) When was the stash placed in the bar? (

During the pool party! -->

Pedro
Emily
Suzy
Rebecca
Candy
Kylie
enihpleD
dlareG

<-- Before the pool party!

Peppa
George
Edmond
Zoe
Richard
Freddy
ydneW
ynnaD

) START (

Suzy: Something's telling me that the ideal time to hide this stash would've been after leaving the party... -->

Zoe: Seriously? You'd have barely any time at all! <--

Rebecca: Even if you had a minimal amount of time, you'd have the benefit of pretty much nobody noticing you. -->

George: That doesn't mean that nobody could notice you at all though, does it? <--

Candy: True, but then you wouldn't have the issue of people questioning you about collecting the stash. -->

Richard: Well, at least by doing it before the pool party you don't have to rush yourself into collecting the random items! <--

Emily: Lighten up a bit, guys...       There's a chance that you would be able to pull it off... -->

Zoe: Still, that's just a chance, isn't it? Not something that a killer would rely on in a planned murder. <--

Kylie: Maybe their plan needed them to set up the stash moments before the murder? -->

Edmond: Uhm...     I can't think of a plan that would require a last-minute collection spree of items. <--

Suzy: Really? Honestly speaking, anything's possible at this point! -->

Peppa: True, but you need to make sure the possible stays within the rules of the scenario... <--

Pedro: Trust me, guys! There's a chance this plan could've worked! -->

Freddy: There's no way it could've worked. You wouldn't have been able to lure your victim to where you kept the stash, otherwise. <--

}= BREAK ={

____________________