Here are some rejected Newsies ships. Feel free to comment any others, and I'll add them!

____________________________________________________________

Pulitzer + shaving cream – Joving Pulitzeam 

Santa Fe + Jack – Janta Felly (or Fanta Jelly, courtesy of Consultingdemiwitch)

Snyder + jail – Snail

Box of cigars + Race – Racebox of Higgars

Medda + mortgage – Miss Medortgagedda

Katherine + the screaming of ten angry editors – Is that even legal