Lucifer frowned as he stared at me, thinking I was going to stay with him. He had cheated on me, some other female who was a student of rad had been with him. His arms were crossed, he had hurt me too much. "Listen, I know you think you're gonna break up with me but you know there's no one who's better than me." I smirked, I knew one man who was. Satan.

Satan had told me his feelings before, knowing I was in a relationship with his brother. For some reason, Satan hated his older brother. Devildom would freeze over the day those two males got along.

I left Lucifer's room, making my way towards Satan's. I knocked on his door, I heard his bed move as he got up and opened the door. "Oh, hey Y/n." His face turned red as his blonde hair started to move in front of his eyes. "I need a favor, or possibly something you would like." He cocked a brow, "it's something to get back at Lucifer." He smiled, "I'm in." I put my hand on the door frame, "how about I come in and we talk about it. It's something a little deeper than just getting back at him." He peeked his head out, looking left and right down the hallway before pulling me in. "What's it about?" He shut the door, I made my way across the mountains of books to get to his bed. "Well, Lucifer cheated on me." His hands went to his hips, "again?" Tears whelled in my eyes, "what do you mean, again?" Satan's eyes widened as he looked down. "I'm sorry, I thought you knew." My hands went to my face as he sat beside me and comforted me. "It'll be okay, I promise that." My head laid on his chest as I gripped his shoulders. "You already know how I feel about you." He sounded disappointed, as if he wish he never told me. "Satan, make sure you meet me in the garden tomorrow after school. Lucifer would usually get there about ten minutes after school let's out." He nodded silently, I got up and he grabbed my hand. "Would you like me to join you tonight?" I paused, then pulled my hand away. "It's fine, I'll be in my room if you need anything."

I woke up the next morning nervous, but today was the day I ended it with Lucifer. I heard a knock on my door, then Satan walked in. He shut the door behind him as he towered over my body. "Time to get up Y/n, I wanted to be the one getting you up today." I got up and got dressed in the bathroom as Satan sat on my bed. He never done this, he didn't even know what I had planned for after school. "So, what are you doing today?" His blonde hair was adorable on him, especially when he smiled. I came out and he grabbed my hand, pulling me out of my room to head to school. Lucifer stopped us before we got out the door, pulling me from Satan. "Satan, you know she walks with me." He stood his ground, "well maybe she wanted to walk with me today." A smirk appeared on Lucifer's face, "well she's my girlfriend, not yours." I could tell that hurt Satan, he stormed off towards school and Lucifer let out a laugh. "Says the one who always cheats on me," I took off after Satan as Lucifer stood there with his mouth opened wide.

The classes were long but Satan met me in the garden like I asked. "So, what did you want to meet for?" I grabbed his hands and he smiled. "I see you feel the same way then?" He placed his hands on my cheeks as this was about the time Lucifer came out. He pulled me into a kiss, which I returned and pushed my hands into his hair. I was pulled away from him as I looked up to see Lucifer. "How dare you kiss my Y/n!" Satan smirked, "she's my girl now Lucifer." Lucifer stood there shocked, "no she's not!" They both looked at each other, "well, tell us who you pick?"

If you picked Lucifer

I took a deep breath, "I would still choose Lucifer. Even if he cheats on me, maybe he'll change." Satan's eyes watered as he covered his mouth with his hand. "Were you using me?" I sheepishly looked away as he turned on his heel and ran. Lucifer pulled me close to him, "that stunt you pulled was very inappropriate." I rolled my eyes, "well, maybe if you didn't cheat on me. I'll give you one more chance Lucifer." He smirked, "you keep saying that but we know it's still going to happen."

If you picked Satan

"I'm sorry Lucifer, but I am breaking up with you." Satan smirked as he had defeated his older brother. Satan pulled me back to him, wrapping his arms around me. "At least I won't cheat on her like you, because unlike you Lucifer, I do love her." My face turned red as he kissed my cheek. "Come on, let's get heading home." He grabbed my hand and I happily walked with him. "I know it may take some time, but I promise I'll never cheat on you. I'm not my brother." He chuckled as we walked, finally defeating his brother and stealing his girlfriend.