Playlist for this chapter: Monte Fish: Hotel// Isabel LaRosa: older (sped up)// Isabel LaRosa:I'm yours// One of the Girls: The Weeknd// Meg Myers: desire (sped up or not)// Ari Abdul-babydoll// Fill the void- lily rose Depp and The Weeknd// Boyfriend-Dove Cameron 

Evelyn's POV

"We'll play it my way. Never have I ever slept with more than one person at the same time." I said provocatively, wondering if either of them had done what I had never. 

Jax and Ashton look at each other and then frown at me, Ashton's head cocked to the side as he tries to figure me out. Jax's fingertip rubs the edge of his wine glass gently as he stares into my soul. They both drink from their wine glasses and I raise my eyebrows, wow so they both have experience in that. Interesting. 

I didn't know what was wrong with me tonight, I felt reckless, I've behaved for so long that I wanted to do something crazy. I wanted to feel something different. Something that only both of them could give me at the same time. 

I uncross my legs and brush my foot against Jax's leg, discreetly. I do the same to Ashton with my other foot, just to get the idea of physical contact going because I had no idea how this was going to unravel. Jax clears his throat and Ashton clenches and unclenches his fist. I suck on my bottom lip, eyes fluttering back and forth between both of them. They both knew me well, they both knew I was asking for something, and by the way Ashton's irritation radiated off his body I knew he was coming to realize what it was. Seems fair, doesn't it? 

"What? Both of you slept with the same girl?" I ask, wanting to find out more. Jax laughs and Ashton shakes his head, seeming a little embarrassed to talk about the topic with me.

"No, Evelyn that's not-no it wasn't like that," Ashton mutters looking at his glass.

"We were not involved in each other's threesomes, he did it at one point, and I did it at one point. College is like that, it's overrated." Jax says, squinting at me as if he's trying to decipher why I've brought this up. 

I nod my head nonchalantly, loving the honesty. 

"Never have I ever enjoyed a threesome," Jax says, throwing his hands up as if he doesn't know what else to say. 

I look over at Ashton and see if he drinks his wine or not, but he doesn't, and I get a sense of satisfaction from that. But a sense of curiosity as well. 

"Well?" I ask Ashton. His eyes darken when they land on me and for a second, I'm intimidated. Intimidated and turned on, all the same, he knows. He's just figured out exactly what I want to do. He downs the rest of his wine, greedily. Grabs the car keys from the table and calls the waiter over for the bill. My high hopes are deflated for a moment until I hear what he says next. 

"Let's finish this at our place." Ashton says with an expression on his face that says, 'I'm not happy about this but I'll satisfy you'. Jax doesn't ask any questions he just keeps his eyes on me and then shoots Ashton a perplexed look.  

The drive back to Jax and Ashton's house was nerve-racking because I genuinely didn't have a clue if either of them got the memo, not really anyway. None of us were really saying what we were thinking, we were all talking in riddles. 

Jax opens the car door for me, and I follow him and Ashton into their house. Ashton tells me to make myself at home and I hug the coat I was wearing tighter around my body; I don't know if it was just my nerves, but it was freezing in here. It was just past midnight so I shot my brother a text saying I wouldn't be home anytime soon. 

Ashton walks over to his fridge and grabs three shot glasses and a whole bottle of vodka. Oh boy.  I see Jax walk over to him, and I hear him whisper something to Ash, a question. 

- - -

Jax's POV

"What the hell is this?" I ask Ashton, because if it's what I'm thinking then we've all lost our minds. Ashton's jaw clenches and unclenches as he hands me a shot glass. 

"Just do what she says. Follow your.... instincts. And whatever happens, tonight stays in between the three of us. That's it." He whispers through gritted teeth. I gape at him as if he were speaking in another language completely. You have got to be kidding me, no. Was I actually doing this? I can see the pain in Ashton's eyes and yet, he's willing to put it aside for her. 

I genuinely don't know if I'm angry that I won't have her to myself or if I'm raging with desire. I see Ashton hand her the shot glass, their eye contact with each other unfaltering. Yeah, we're all going to need to be a lot drunker right now for this.

- - - 

Evelyn's POV

Ashton turns the house speakers on and starts blasting music that fits the vibe we're all about to be in. I may not be able to trust him in one way, but if there are two people I would have a threesome with, that I know I'd be safe with....it's them. The music is playing outside as well as inside the house. 

Jax pours the three of us shots and we clink our glasses together and down three more shots. I wince, but they don't. I'm sitting on their black, luxurious couch. My heart beating twice as fast, Jax pulls out a cigarette and lights it up. He's sitting on the couch across from me, one arm extended over the top of the couch, one foot tapping the floor. A sign of nerves. 

Ashton walks over to me, his amber gaze on fire with lust and anger. He must hate me right now, but I know him. He couldn't hate me even if he tried. He grabs my chin gently at first, forcing me to look up at him. 

"One night, one night, and then forget about ever counting on me for something like this ever again. You're meant to be mine, and mine alone. But it's only fair." He whispers venomously, and yet I'm more turned on than I have been in months. He releases my chin and starts walking away to the pool outside, his muscles flexing as pulls his shirt above his head. 

He wants me to initiate it, don't mind if I do. I look over at Jax who is still smoking, looking at me with a desire-fueled gaze. 

"Do you really want this, Evelyn?" Jax asks in the sweetest voice, a voice I haven't heard since I first met him. I nod my head and he passes me the rest of his cigarette as he stands up. I take a long puff, putting the cigarette out on the dark, marble Ashtray.  

Jax walks over and stands behind me, I feel him take my coat off. His warm breath inches away from my neck, a small shiver electrifying my body. My heart was pounding against my chest, and I took a glimpse outside through the double doors. Ashton's outside in the pool, I notice his pants and boxers on the floor. 

Jax moves my hair to one side, so it falls over my left shoulder and plants a wet, tremble-inducing kiss on my neck. He forces me to turn around gently and stares at my lips for what feels like an eternity. The music makes the moment even more mesmerizing.  

"You can have whatever you want." He whispers. He grabs my face in his hands, and I look up at him, a storm coursing in my heart. He leans in and I kiss him with all the passion I can muster, a wave of warmness hitting me. A nervous drip coursing through my veins. I pull him in, wanting to get closer as he grabs my waist, Jax's fingertips digging into me. My tongue dances with his as I suck lightly on his bottom lip. I pull away, an insatiable hunger in the atmosphere. He gazes down at me, not a smirk, not a frown but a matched fierceness in his eyes. 

I grab his hand and guide him outside, stopping when I see Ashton's arms extended over the edge of the pool. The glow from the pool light illuminated his features, his well-defined chest, his abs, and his v-line. I groan internally letting go of Jax's hand as he walks over to the pool steps and begins unzipping his pants. My gosh, they're both so beautiful. Ashton's wet hair caused droplets to form over his forehead and the rest of his lean body. 

Ashton looks at me, biting his bottom lip. He's wearing nothing, no swim trunks here. The music blared loudly into the starry night. I was beginning to break out into a nervous sweat. I look over at Jax, his clear-cut body, his flawless skin. Jax looks at me as he makes his way into the pool before submerging his whole body. Wow, they are just...impressive to look at. 

I was a monument under the moon, my hunger for them radiating into the night. Ashton and Jax are about a yard away from each other, Ashton swims to the part of the pool I'm closest to as Jax stands there, waiting for me to move. 

"What? Are you nervous? You need me to guide you through this or you want to let yourself figure it out?" Ashton asks in a challenging tone. I smirk, but he's right I do need some guidance. He realizes that when I don't move a muscle.

"Take your dress off Evelyn, slowly." He says, through gritted teeth. His eyes watch my every move. Jax had moved closer to where I was as well, I felt like I had an audience which made me tremble slightly.

I start unzipping the sparkly dress I was wearing and let it fall to my ankles. My body revealed the black and beige strapless lingerie set I was wearing. The bra has a mesh-like texture, pushing my breasts up. My thong intricately designed. I kick my dress away softly. 

"Come here." Jax manages to whisper, my eyes flicker to him and I look at Ashton quickly as they both smirk. My core starts aching aimlessly. I walk over to the edge of the pool, my high heels still on. 

"Take a seat, we'll get these off you," Ashton says, talking about my shoes. I sit down, the cold concrete beneath my ass causing my eyes to widen a little. Ashton wraps his hand around my left ankle and Jax's fingers trail over my legs until his hand reaches my right ankle. Jax undoes the straps gently while Ashton is purposely working fast and firmly. Once they're done and I'm sitting vulnerably in front of them Jax's hands grip my thigh as he studies my face, I smirk at him.  Ashton starts trailing kisses up my left thigh, and I gasp. I push myself into the water as they give me some space. 

The song Bathroom by Montell Fish starts playing which makes me grin, seems fitting. The cold water makes me flinch and Ashton and Jax both invade my personal space; I'm inviting them to do so. Ashton goes underwater and starts dragging my panties off until they're completely out of range. Jax had moved behind me, unclipping my bra and trailing kisses on my neck and along my jawline. I close my eyes, enjoying the warmness of their bodies close to me. I moan as Ashton stands in front of me, taking a fistful of my hair as his lips crash into mine passionately, with a hunger that I had tasted before. I kissed him back enthusiastically as Jax pressed up against my ass, I felt his erection grow against me. I moaned at the hardness. 

Pleasure in every direction, I was all in and so were they. 

"You okay?" Ashton whispers I nod my head as he sucks roughly on my breast, and I extend my arm backward touching Jax's neck behind me. 

Jax grabs my wrist and kisses the palm of my hand gently, sucking on one of my fingers causing a moan to escape from my throat. I feel Jax's fingertips trail down my back until he reaches below my waist. I gasp as Ashton turns me around and now, I'm facing Jax. His eyes were darker than ever, a smirk dancing around his mouth. Jax levels himself until he's the one that has to look up at me, he licks my stomach, all the way up to my breast and then my neck. I close my eyes overwhelmed with all the emotions, all the yearning. 

Jax starts working his fingers, rubbing my clit gently until my legs are shaking. At the same time, my hand is on Ashton's raging erection, moving my hand back and forth, jerking his cock firmly. Ashton groans in my ear, sucking gently on my earlobe. I cry out loudly at the way Jax pumps his fingers into me, I gasp as my eyes widen. Jax has a mischievous grin on his face revealing a dimple I hadn't seen before. 

"Even in this pool, I can feel how wet I'm making you," Jax whispers, licking my bottom lip before kissing it. I can feel his long fingers touch a sweet spot in my pussy and it makes me moan loudly. 

I look down at Jax and he stops working his fingers on my clit suddenly and I gasp at the shock of not feeling them anymore.

"This is what you wanted right?" Ashton asks as his hands grip my arms. I moan loudly before I say, "I want more." 

"Oh, more huh? You hear that Jax?" Ashton says. Jax is back to towering over me, now leveling with Ashton's height behind me. I'm stuck in the middle of these two beautiful men, and I don't even know where to look, I'd like to be stuck here forever. 

"Yeah, I heard her. Well, I'm such a gentleman that I'll give her exactly what she wants." Jax says, his hands sneaking into the crook of my neck. 

"Put your hair up," Jax whispers, grabbing my cheeks firmly with one hand as his thumb caresses my cheekbone. 

I do as I'm told, putting my long hair into a tight and high ponytail, my now very wet hair. The three of us naked, goosebumps and all. 

Ashton grabs my hips, pulling my ass onto his hard length and I groan. I wrap my hands around Jax's neck as he bites my bottom lip and our tongues mingle with each other once more as his fingers squeeze the tip of my breast gently, giving me a shock of pleasure. 

"You want to do this?" Ashton whispers. 

"Give me all of it." I moan. I look at Jax his eyebrows furrowed together as he hears what I say to Ashton. 'What' I mouth at Jax, frowning. I see him gulp and his jaw clenches. 

- - -

Jax's POV

I feel the jealousy creep up on me and remind myself this is what she wants. For tonight, I'll just focus on pleasing her. I'm as turned on as her, her body, the softness of her skin, and her perky, plump tits teasing me, her wet core telling me she enjoys what I do to her. I could eat her up right here in this pool. 

- - - 

Ashton's POV

I push aside the jealousy inside me when I think about how someone else was watching her undress, how she wasn't only doing it for me at this moment, how Jax was touching her it had almost made me nauseous but at the same time for some sick reason, I was turned on watching her and hearing her moans. But I hoped in giving her what she wanted that she'd understand I was eager to please her and only her.

- - - 

Evelyn's POV

I feel Ashton enter me; his firm cock mixed with the wetness I was dripping in. My nails dug into Jax's shoulders, and I bit down on his bottom lip. Ashton pulled on my ponytail forcing me to look up at Jax's eyes as I cried out in pleasure. The force of Ashton's strokes caused ripples in the water between the three of our bodies in the pool. His strokes caused me to lean on Jax who was rubbing my clit as Ashton was penetrating me, stretching me out with every inch of him.

"You're such a good girl," Jax whispered, looking into my eyes as I bit into my own bottom lip.

"Damn right, she is," Ashton growls as he fills me up with his long, thick cock. I grip Jax's shoulders even harder my nails marking his skin and he studies my face as I moan causing him to bite down on his lip over and over again.  Everything happening wasn't only erotic it was filled with such intensity I thought I'd cum over and over right then and there. Ashton pulls out of me and I gasp at how suddenly the action was done. He plants a kiss on my neck.

"I'm not done with you," Ashton whispers, but a moment later I no longer feel his presence behind me. 

Jax picks me up, forcing me to straddle his hard shaft. He carries me over to the edge of the pool where my dress lies and places me on the hard concrete once more. He begins lowering his head as he puts my legs on his shoulder. I wrap my legs around his neck and arch my back as Jax skillfully starts tasting me. I moan loudly, very aware that Ashton is no longer in the pool with us. 

Jax makes eye contact with me as he licks and kisses my clit. Forcing the wet folds of my core apart with his tongue and then his fingers, he continuously drives his fingers in and out of me until I'm on the edge of exploding with the most mind-boggling orgasm. 

"What else do you want hmm?" Jax asks, his voice husky and dripping in lust. 

I can't take the ache in my ovaries any longer and I keep crying out in moans, saying his name over and over again. Feeling my warm, wet core contract around his fingers. He frowns in such a divine way, feeling me. I'm literally wrapped around his finger right now. 

"I wanna feel you inside, please. Right now." I beg. 

Jax feigns concern, moving his mouth to one side as if he needs to think about it. Licking the two fingers that were just inside of me and I raise my eyebrows as my mouth turns into an o-shape. That was so fucking hot. 

"Unfortunately, I can't. Not here anyways." He says very bluntly, leaving me hurting for more of him and confused. He pulls himself out of the pool using his upper body strength and I sigh wondering what he is going to do next. 

Jax tells me to stand up and then swoops me off my feet so that I have to wrap my arms around his neck as my legs straddle his waist. Our skin is wet against one another, making me want to grind against him, I feel his hardness poking the entrance of my pussy in an involuntarily teasing manner.

"I would make such sweet love to you if we were alone, but instead I'm forced to fuck you senseless tonight. I hope you know I'm only doing this to please you and I'm sure Ashton is doing it for the same reason but I'd be lying if I didn't say I wanted you alone so I could really give you something to look forward to." He whispers. A shudder runs through my body, and I place a kiss on his lips. His wet eyelashes fluttered, the light in his eyes making me feel safe. 

Jax carried me to the room where Ashton resided. Ashton was lying down, the red lighting in his room the only thing illuminating our faces and bodies. Jax had laid me down on the king-sized bed. 

"You still want more?" Ashton whispers as he kneels on the bed before me. I nod my head slowly. 

"Then that's what you'll get." He says. 

Ashton tells me to turn around and face him on all fours and my heart starts racing at this request, but I do it because I wanted to. I look back at Jax and he swallows nervously, his cock still harder than when he first touched me earlier in the pool. I nod my head at Jax, in a way showing him that I'm okay with this. He bites his bottom lip reluctantly. There wasn't a lot of talking being done, we were busy. 

"Both of you are so eager to please me, it really turns me on," I whisper. 

I put Ashton in my mouth until he reaches the back of my throat and I gag a little but keep going when I hear a deep moan escape his lips. Jax is kissing down my back and my legs give away a slight tremble at his warm lips on my skin. I look up at Ashton and his beautiful eyes are looking back into mine as he grabs my ponytail, releasing it gently. 

Jax licks my clit teasingly from the back, causing me to stop sucking on Ashton because of the moan I had to let out, and then he thrusts his hard cock into me with such deep, slow strokes I completely collapse onto the mattress as I grip Ashton's hand harder and harder. I make myself lift my head so, I'm looking at Ashton and although he has a somewhat pained expression on his face his eyes darken as he rubs my lips with his finger. 

"You like that? Tell me how you want it baby." Jax whispers as he pushes his cock into me even deeper, slower. I turn to look back at him, my eyebrows furrowed as the sensation of my wetness encases his cock inside me, gripping him at my core. His one dimple showcasing as he smirks at me. I close my eyes and throw my head back. 

"Harder." I moan. 

"You're so bad." Jax breathes, speeding his movements into me as he grips my hips harder and thrusts into my crevice with twice the force.

Ashton locks eyes with me and sticks his finger in my mouth as I make a show of sucking it slowly. 

"Nah, Evelyn's a good girl. Aren't you?" Ashton whispers but he doesn't have a single smirk or smile on his face just this serious expression that makes me feel hotter than I feel already. At this point, my eyes are rolling back and I'm wondering who's going to make me cum tonight. I scream as Ashton moves from in front of me and lays next to me, he begins rubbing my clit with his fingers impressively while Jax was rhythmically thrusting in and out of my warm, tight pussy. The music from the speakers mixed with the moans escaping me.

I grip the sheets tightly, my body covered in sweat. 

"He's right you're such a good girl, fuck. Look at you, taking all of me." Jax groans. He pulls his cock out of me slowly and I could feel my wetness dripping down my inner thighs. I frown when I look back, wondering why he stopped. 

"Don't worry, we're not done just yet," Ashton says switching places with Jax, I pretend I don't see his jaw clench and unclench. Ashton pulls on my ponytail forcing me to sit up on my knees as he kisses my neck sensually. Jax's veiny hands grabbed my tits and put them in his mouth. 

"How much more should we give her Jax?" Ashton mumbles, not looking at him. They've both kept their eyes fixed on me this entire night. 

"I think she can take a little more unless her eyes are lying to me. I think we could wipe the smirk off her face with a little more." Jax says, his body glowing red from the lighting. 

This isn't what a proper, elegant girl does. Good thing I'm not proper nor elegant tonight. 

"You could try," I say, a nervous crack in my voice making Jax smirk. I moan and lick my lips as a bead of sweat drops down my forehead and he sucks harder on my tits, creating a hickey he proudly looks at when he stops. This causes Ashton to suck on my neck, making me gasp as he tries to leave his own imprint on me. 

Jax turns me around ordering me to open my mouth, I do as I'm told slowly but surely. Ashton opens my legs and starts kissing in between my legs, placing wet and warm kisses all along my inner thighs, which almost drives me mad. When I open my mouth Jax caresses my face and places his thumb on my tongue as I suck it. 

"nuh-uh, leave it open," Jax whispers, his muscles taunting me as I look at him while my head is facing backward in his direction. His hand grasping my chin now and the second Ashton's tongue makes contact with my wet, dewy-like core Jax spits inside my mouth and my eyes go wide, that's new, but I liked it. 

"You behave so well." Jax groans. I feel Ashton's fingers intertwine with my own and I close my eyes momentarily trying not to scream both of their names out, I start feeling faint from the overwhelming sensation of pleasure.  

"There's no one else here but us, let me hear you," Ashton says before he proceeds to swirl his tongue in a circular motion on my clit, pushing the wet lips in-between my legs apart with his tongue. 

"Fuck, fuck." I whimper, completely falling apart. I arch my back, my legs are shaking, and my whole body is writhing in such messy pleasure I can't fathom it anymore. 

"What is it Eve, you're spent aren't you?" Jax teases, kissing my lips with so much passion I thought he'd drain me of my own. He moves a few strands of hair that escaped from my ponytail and I take his scent in grabbing his neck, he smells of chlorine, sweat, and cologne. I  pulled him down to my lips again. I felt something immensely confusing for Jax in that moment it was desire and want and feelings that I thought wouldn't surface, but there was no denying that these two guys had me in a chokehold. 

"I can't- I can't take it anymore." I squeal, my eyebrows furrowed as I bit harshly on my bottom lip. 

"You can, and you will baby," Ashton whispers, demandingly. Oh my gosh, what the actual fuck are they doing to me I feel like I'm floating on cloud nine. 

- - - 

By the end of the night, the three of us were lying there, our chests rising and falling like the waves that crashed at shore near my house. I lay in the middle of both of them and the craziest part was they did all of the work tonight. I had come three times by the time we were all done with each other. We were a hot and sweaty mess and I never thought I'd live to see the day when I lived a recently found fantasy out. 

Two is better than one indeed. At least for tonight, it was.