Candy:Last time on total drama island, the campers are doing the x-treme torture. And the person is eliminated is taffy. So who will win and who will lose? Find out right here right now on total drama island! The campers are waking up and eat pancakes for breakfast.
Bentley:(Sighs) Finally taffy is gone.
Unikitty:I know right? He deserves to leave. He ate my cream cheese sandwiches and turn richard's bed into a giant bird's nest.
Rowlf:Nice work skeeter.
Skeeter:I was waiting for that for years.
Jibanyan:(Sniffs) Pee-yew!!! Something smells stinky!
Meltus:Skunk!!!!! They all are getting outside quickly.
All:(Screaming) Skunk!!!!
Kermit:Run away!!!!
Candy:Good morning campers. Today's challenge is a Camping overnight in the forest with supplies provided
Race back to camp in the morning.
Everything the campers need can be found at their campsites if they can find it. Candy hands out maps and compasses to bentley and blazion (though zorch snatches the map from blazion), then tells them to watch out for bears, as they lost a few interns in pre-production. maractus is initially afraid of bears, but joltik reassures her with a false story about a previous encounter with a bear that he and his grandpa took down. This reminds gonzo of a time she saw a bear rummaging through her neighbor's garbage and had spaghetti noodles hanging from his teeth, so she thought the bear ate the neighbor's cat. This story grosses out piggy.
Gonzo:There I was in the stormy night!! I was staring into the eye giant beast!!!
Rowlf:Scary!
Joltik:Very scary. On the way to the campsite, scooter walks up to skeeter, having noticed that she looks upset. He asks her if it has something to do with bentley reading her diary in the last challenge, but rowlf walks off without replying. Meanwhile, bentley is plotting to bring taffy down at their next plan that it was fozzie who prompted rowlf into doing so, when she read piggy's diary out loud on national television. Rowlf still insists that unikitty is going down in spite of that. Elsewhere, bentley is leading the puppycorn to their site, when burnard spots a blueberry bush, so she and meltus stop to eat some. After a while, burnard and meltus realize that the rest of their team is gone. After calling out for their team, the two realize they are lost, which sends them into a panic.
Burnard:Team Hiro?!
Meltus:Where did they go?!
(Interview)
Burnard:Boy that was something?! I hate getting lost!
(End of interview) The team froggy reach their camp and arcanine sees that there is no food at the site. Kermit points out that since this is a survival challenge, they have to find their own food. Rowlf and animal joke around about how funny it would be if they made bear sounds and ended up attracting a real bear. Kermit then heads out into the woods to find some food, since he claims he is an expert on the subject.
(Interview)
Kermit:Look as you know I'm more than just a survivor, I am also a good hunter. That's all I gotta say.
(End of interview)
Meanwhile, burnard and meltus are still lost and start arguing when meltus calls out burnard on his bad sense of direction, which leads to their first major fight. As night falls, they continue to argue when burnard says that at least she knows how to drive, but meltus dismisses this and says that burnard once crashed a car wash due to his poor sense of direction. Their arguing attracts a pair of squirrels who mimic the two in sync, until the mixels get fed up when meltus claims that everyone thinks he's crazier and nicer than burnard, and decide they are no longer friends.
Burnard:Are you saying I'm stupid?! You're stupid!
Meltus:Just get over it man!
Burnard:You want me to get over it?!
Meltus:Yeah!!!!
Burnard:Oh yeah?! Do you want me to fight you?! Let's go!!!! They both are fighting each other and then they stopped.
Meltus:Well I can't believe that!!!
Burnard:Me too!!!
Both:Our besties days are over!!! I hate you!!!! They are walking away from each other.
(Interview)
Burnard:Jerk!!!
(Interview)
Meltus:Loser!!
(Interview)
Burnard:Sneezer!!
(Interview)
Meltus:Belch mouth!!!!
(End of interview) The team Hiro are seen setting up camp, and unikitty confronts Dr. Fox by saying she pitches a tent like a guy. She sees this doesn't have the desired effect and tries to correct herself, only to say that what he means is that she isn't afraid to get dirty. In the confessional, Dr. Fox slaps herself over her mistake. Hawkodile asks puppycorn where the food is, calling his "woman." Unikitty says that she refuses to dignify this with a response. When komajiro arrives with a sick rabbit in his arms, Hiro suggests the rabbit should be their dinner, saying he's never had rabbit stew, but komajiro intends to make it a pet, naming it Bunny. By this point, baymax notices that burnard and meltus are absent. The missing campers stumble upon a tree with a fork in it, which they realize they had seen two hours ago, meaning that they have been walking in a large circle. They hear an owl in the darkness and in a panic, they run screaming through the woods, into a cave. They think they will be safe there until morning, but meltus is then scared when a bat flaps around his head. When the bat leaves, meltus sits on a rock and mutters that they will surely die there. Back at the froggy camp, gonzo tells the others the story of how he and his grandfather fought a bear. Afterward, kermit notices that animal is missing. When they call out to him, they attract the attention of a nearby bear, which comes into camp and scares everyone (especially rowlf, who wets himself), making them go into a tree for their safety. The scene then shifts to the Hiro camp, where zorch gets spooked by an owl and reveals that he is afraid of being alone in the forest, which reminds  of a scary story of a killer with a hook for a hand. He tells the story and ends up scaring the rest of the Hiro camp after he pulls out a hook on his right hand for the ending. Bentley laughs hysterically at their reactions and vulk chews him out for this, but zorch just keeps fooling around. At that moment, an owl spooks vulk right into zorch's arms. He seems to be surprised by this, but then he looks at stuart with a pleased expression on his face while the latter gives him a thumbs up in approval. Meanwhile, gonzo is called upon by the other team members to deal with the bear; he reveals that he was only being theatrical with his story, and gets blamed for attracting the bear in the first place. Hidabat fears that the bear ate animal, which scooter thinks that this is good as he thinks it would ensure that the bear is no longer hungry. Everyone looks at him shocked, though she covers for himself by claiming that it's survival of the fittest, and by making fun of Cody for wetting his pants, causing him to become ashamed of himself. The branch maractus is sitting on gives way, and she falls down near the bear, which moves in on her. Maractus screams for help, but unexpectedly, the bear asks if she is okay. Taking off its head, the bear is revealed to be animal in a costume.
Animal:Me bear! Yabababahahaha!!!!
Fozzie:It's just animal. Back at the Hiro camp, all of the team Hiro (with the lone exception of Hiro) are shown to be too frightened by zorch's story to leave their tent, let alone sleep. Unikitty says she has to go pee, and komajiro revealed that he did so already, by holding up a jar with urine in it. Not wanting to share a jar, she heads outside to find a private place. However, what she finds are bats, and one of them flies right into her face. This scares the other campers as they see a girl with wings on her face as a shadow jumping outside of their tent. Flain then trips over the campfire, accidentally kicking an ember onto the tent, and burning it to the ground, leaving the team Hiro with no shelter. The team Hiro (except for a sleeping zorch) glare at her for this. The team froggy are then shown sharing the fish amongst themselves when another rustle is heard from the bushes, and another bear appears; at first it seems like another person in a bear costume, but gonzo tries to take the head off and only tears out some fur. This bear is a real one, and it scares the team froggy up the tree again (not before causing rowlf to wet himself again). Meanwhile, Hiro is chewing out flamzer for burning down the tent. Zorch says that everything is cool, but hawkodile says that things couldn't possibly get worse. Unfortunately for both teams, a storm then comes in and it rains all night. Everyone is stuck in the rain, with no shelter, except for burnard and meltus, who are alone and scared in the cave. The next morning, the rain has stopped, and unikitty complains that thanks to animal and gonzo, they were unable to sleep in their tent last night. Burnard and meltus have a bigger problem: the cave they resided in belongs to the bear. At the Hiro camp, Dr. Fox wakes up cuddling with hawkodile, who smiles at her. She then accuses hawkodile of cuddling her, but hawkodile calmly replies that it was her who initiated the cuddling as he was sleeping, teasing her about it. Unikitty is then shown in the confessional stating that since she was unconscious at the time of the "alleged cuddling with said neanderthal," it's like it never happened. Back at camp, Candy is preparing the campfire for that night's bonfire ceremony when the team Hiro come out of the woods, declaring victory. The team froggy  arrive a moment later and see the Bass already there; piggy turns on animal and gonzo, blaming them for losing the challenge. But Candy stops them, pointing out that two of the team Hiro are missing; unikitty nonchalantly dismisses burnard's and meltus's absence by claiming they were eaten by wolves, to which zorch adds sarcastically that it was a "darn shame." The two missing campers then arrive and start rambling on about how they were lost and wound up in the bear cave, found by the bear, and how scared they were. Now safe, burnard and meltus apologize for all the mean things they said, and reaffirm their BFFFL status. Unikitty asks if they've finished their little love-fest, and then blames them for losing the challenge for their team; the team froggy win an all-expenses paid trip to the Tuck Shop, while burnard and meltus are left with their angry teammates. Burnard and meltus then look worried that they will be split up. Afterwards, the team froggy are seen enjoying themselves in their hot tub, though some are disgusted when fozzie vomits near it.
Candy:Okay. The first marshmallow goes to:Hiro, baymax, bentley, komajiro, flain, vulk, zorch, flamzer, unikitty, puppycorn, Dr. Fox, hawkodile, richard, kevin, stuart, and bob. Burnard and meltus this is the last marshmallow. It it goes to......... Meltus.
Burnard:Aw.
Meltus:Well better luck next time. Candy catapult burnard in the sky.