This is my opinion, you are allowed to put in suggestions...

Creator God: Scott Cawthorn

God/goddess of AU's: Rebornica

Goddess of Jeremike: Bamsarakilledyou

God of Jeremike feels: Rikiiruchii (did I get this right?)

Goddess of fnaf art: Pole-Bear

God/goddess of fnaf fanfics: FnafFanficParlour

God of fnaf awesomeness: Foxy's_Weed

Goddess of best fnaf writing: EnderAngie

Goddess of fnaf feels: carefree_meme233

Goddess of fnaf epicness: Me (got a problem?)