I don't actively seek out music from this band, but I still wanted to make a list.

5) Immortals (American Beauty/American Psycho)

4) The Phoenix (Save Rock and Roll)

3) Novocaine (American Beauty/American Psycho)

2) My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark (Light Em Up) [Save Rock and Roll]

Honorable Mentions

Centuries (American Beauty/American Psycho)
The Patreon Saint of Liars and Fakes (Take This to Your Grave)
Alone Together (Save Rock and Roll)
Jet Pack Blues (American Beauty/American Psycho)
Fourth of July (American Beauty/American Psycho)

1) Sophomore Slump or Comeback of the Year (From Under the Cork Tree)