These are just kind of what I've seen that people love. Unlike my favorites, covers will be included.

10) The Hardest Button to Button

9) My Doorbell

8) We're Going to Be Friends

7) Blue Orchid

6) Hotel Yorba

5) Ball and Biscuit

4) Icky Thump

3) Fell in Love With a Girl

2) Dead Leaves and the Dirty Ground
I don't know about you guys, but this one surprised me the most. It's a great song, and I was shocked that this was not only included at or near the top of every list I found. It might not be the most well known, but amongst the fans, it is one of the most loved.

Honorable Mentions

You Don't Know What Love Is (You Just Do As You're Told) [Icky Thump]
This was another one of those surprise songs. I never really hear it mentioned a lot, but it was at least mentioned in every list I saw.
Hello Operator (De Stijl)
This one is similar to the previous, but wasn't as surprising.
I'm Slowly Turning Into You (Icky Thump)
Personally, I have nothing to say because I've never heard the song before...so I don't really care.
I Just Don't Know What to Do With Myself (Elephant)
This one was actually surprising because I hear about it a lot, but it didn't make the list.
Truth Doesn't Make a Noise (De Stijl)
This one was really shocking because a lot of people seem to think it's the best song ever and I really thought it would make the list, but nope.
Offend in Every Way (White Blood Cells)
This was probably the closest song to making the list.
The Denial Twist (Get Behind Me Satan)
This song was second closest to making the list.

1) Seven Nation Army
No one can deny this song as the most popular, come on.