Requested by ChaosQueen47

You slammed your door closed and locked it. Then, you flew to all of your windows, locked them, and shut the curtains.

Your heart was beating fast. Your mane was a mess. You were breathing heavily. Screams hurt your ears as you listened in from outside.

"No, no this can't be happening." You leaned against the door, hoping no one would get in. "The Elements of Insanity... They're taking over!"

You were about to cry when something starting banging on your door. You then stood up and leaned against it. "Come on, I know someone's in there!!" Fluttershout's creepy voice yelled.

The door suddenly broke open, sending you into your wall. You opened your eyes to see the insane mare standing there, (SHE LOOKS SO PERFECT STANDING THERE!... Sorry I had to. XD) smiling.

She laughed, then said, "IM GONNA SCREAM!" You plugged your ears and looked away, ready for her scream... But she didn't make a sound.

You looked back at her, ears still plugged, jut in case she was tricking you. But, instead of her screaming and smiling- you saw her have a look on confusion on her face.

She said something, but you couldn't make it out, so you unplugs your ears. "What?"

"I said, is that you (y/n)?"

"Yeah..."

"Why aren't we screaming!?" A tough voice came from her. "Just hold on a second. I'm trying to figure out if that is (y/n), my college sweetheart!"

"...Fluttershy?" You say, standing up.

"Well, it's Fluttershout now, but yes. That's me!"

I never really new who Fluttershout was before... It's Fluttershy?

"Are... Are you gonna kill me?"

"Yes!-no!" Two voices came from her. "Yes we are!! We agreed on killing ponys, REMEMBER? Yes, but that's (y/n)! My old marefriend!" (Girlfriend)

"I-I'm so confused." You say.

"Well, you see, I got taken over by a dead guy, and now I'm Fluttershout! But, I still have a little bit of Flutter in me." She looked at you with big cute eyes. "(Y/n), would you... Be mine again?"

"WHAT?" You were taken aback by this.

"I know, I know! Who would date Fluttershout, but remember the old times?"

"Yeah, I remember when you CHEATED on me with Discord!"

She Blushed. "Yeah, but-"

"And I said I would never trust or date you again." You said. "So no!"

You saw anger in her eyes. "HOW DARE YOU!" She yelled, pinning you and your arms down so you wouldn't be able to block the scream. "IM GONNA SCRE- no!!" She then leaped off of you. "I love this mare!"

"How can you love me when you said you loved discord??" You say, tears on your cheeks- from fear, and sadness.

"I love you because I was stupid to cheat on you with him-I truly love you (y/n)!"

"I-I still love you too..." You cry. "But how can we be together now?? You could kill me at any second- the elements of INSANITY could kill me t any second!!"

"I will make sure no pony EVER would hurt you!! Please, (y/n)."

"But Flutter I-"

Suddenly, she came close to you and kissed you. This took you by surprise, but she was passionate. She then backed away and stared at you- a speechless (s/c) Pegasus.

"F-fine." You say, blushing and smiling a little. "We can make this work."

"No we can't!- yes we can." Fluttershout smiled. Then, you walked out of the house.

Together, just like the college years.