If I know Sonica Well, Than I know Sonic like the back of my hand, and say, Yes this could happen, and It would if Sonic wouldn't run away from his problems than yeah it could work.

But I see why people would hate this ship.

Amy's cannon Age is 12

And Sonic's cannon Age is 15

And that raises some red flags with some people

As for me

I think its cute,

Very wholesome and they are just perfect for either, I think